Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Susan Sullivan's avatar

Thank you for this beautiful piece. Your heart break and pain are palpable. There are no words to express your pain and the evil wickedness that has taken place. You have each other and from what I know about Israel you will come together and love each other and cherish life.

Expand full comment
erin claman's avatar

'Today, we grieve not only the loss of a mother and her two sons, but also for our own failures. For the moments we did not act fast enough. For not immediately understanding that the most basic human value — the protection of children — should have been non-negotiable.' Joshua, your piece spoke to me in so many ways - todah raba. However, this paragraph really upset me.

I remember Oct 7. I remember calling a friend who lives in Kochav Yakov. I remember her telling me, 'We are in awe and disbelief. HOW COULD THIS HAVE HAPPENED?' She said in pain & UTTER amazement. 'They' had years and years of planning, years of watching Us, years of digging tunnels. Years of studying & planning every move they would make make against Us. It was meticulously planned. And neither the IDF nor Bibi & the Knesset caught wind, not even a whiff of this before it happened? Our country & the Diaspora had no idea, NONE. I, a Canadian Jew, a Zionist will ALWAYS remember that.

And, Israel's bargaining for hostages, always one or two or a few released, living or dead, for scores of evil terrorists released from Israeli prisons only to take up where they left off? This Israeli pattern of wheeling & dealing goes all the way back to Entebbe. Hamas knew Israel engages in lopsided hostage swapping for Satan & Haman. They used the knowledge of this Israeli practice on Us again, yet again. REALLY? This policy needs to be reviewed, ACHSHAV! It is painful for Israel & the galut; we spend sleepless night & then bury The Bibas? A toddler, a baby, and an Ima.

This should NOtT of happened; UNCCEPTABLE!, an AVEYRA! and hopefully NEVER AGAIN!

I'm just sayin', Erin (Toronto, Canada)

Expand full comment
35 more comments...

No posts