Israel may be changing its prime minister without fundamentally changing its direction. That should tell us something about the politics of personality.
Yitzhak Rabin believed most of the things Gadi Eisenkot believes in, before he was elected in 1992. A year after his election he signed the Oslo Accords with the PLO.
Maybe what they believe in is less important than whether they still believe it after the election.
Voting on the basis of ideas, issues and policies? Too difficult for many people especially here in America where so many refuse to understand much less discuss issues that affect their lives and families and others they pretend to care about
Heres the good news in America if BIBI leaves office. The average anti zionist jew will havd difficulty yelling the name EISENKOT. It doesn't just roll.off ones tongue. And they will be forced to discuss the issues rather than a personality.
Well stated. But, I don’t see much change in the politics any time soon. In the case of the US (and elsewhere) when people are taught no lessons of history, no skill of reason/analysis, and fame is to be found as an “influencer” on social media, preferably spewing hate)….not too promising.
It may well be that Mr. Netanyahu once made contributions to the conservative movement in Israeli politics—much as Trump undoubtedly succeeded in articulating the sentiments of many, particularly among the American lower class. But both politicians have now become, above all, a burden to the conservative message and movement.
Far too much attention is focused on what many perceive as their toxic personalities and the resulting social impact. Throughout history, such toxic personalities have, unfortunately, all too often exerted a disastrous influence on the course of events.
Indeed, let us return to a focus on broad visions, ideas, and plans.
Just how much are Israeli politicians ready to give up to get rid of Netanyahu?
So far, there have been criminal charges filed against him, and a trial lasting almost a decade. A trial which is now looking like the guilty parties are the prosecution (for using illegal tactics to gather evidence and for using these tactics without permission from the AG) , the police (also guilty of illegal wiretapping and blackmail), and the AG who filed the charges against Netanyahu (he either did not give permission for the above illegal tactics or he "does not remember").
Just last night, on channel N12, Elana Dayan "exposed" Netanyahu's newest crime...something about tampering with the Arab vote. Believe me, if he had tampered with that vote, they would not be sitting with 19 mandates.
But the new trial. Same as the old trial.
Then there was the five years od demonstrations. First over the "Crime Minister"(see above) when throngs of idiots came out to protest during Covid. Then there were the Judicial Reforms, so important that not one of the (at least) one hundred people I asked, could tell me what even one reform was. But it was obviously important to them, because after blocking streets, highways, hospitals and airports, they finally decided on a Refusal to Serve Movement, and thought it proper to inform the world at large that the IDF was at its weakest and "come September, Netanyahu would have no army".
And then the "surprise" invasion on October 7th occurred.
After that they were off and running about the price that must be paid to get the hostages back. What price? "At any price". Great negotiating tactic. I would not buy a car that way. Would you.
But all is permitted in the name of getting ris of Netanyahu.
Now, the Opposition ran under the following platform:
Insistence on equality in IDF service:
Toward this end, the chareidim were demonized daily for almost three years (yes, they gave plenty of ammunition).
Bennett actually said "You are killing our soldiers by not serving".
At various times, Liberman called them "Parasites.
You get the picture.
Less than 48 hours after the election, the entire opposition (save Golan) was ready, willing and able to sacrifice the draft of the chareidim. The draft was labelled as "not the right time", "the Army does not want them" or " we will do a "light draft".
Insistence on a Zionistic and democratic government:
No Opposition member was going to sit with the non zionist chareidim or the non zionist and non democratic arabs.
Again, less than 48 hours after the election, those values were thrown to wind, or maybe into the ocean where Tomer Yifat Yirushalmi's phone lies.
Suddenly, the very arabs who are still calling Hamas a "charitable organization" and are still refraining comndeming the massacre of October 7th, are worthy of such positions as sitting on the Committee of Foreign Affairs and Security". No conflict of interest there.
And, there you have it.
There is nothing the opposition won't do to rid themselves of a leader, who has devoted his entire life to this country. Nothing they won't stoop to, nothing they won't lie about, nothing they consider more important than this sacred goal.
We have become a society fueled by baseless and sickening hatred.
I fear for our survival.
At some point, the opposition indicated that "zionist
included neither Chareidim nor Arabs".
Within less than 48 hours, every one of them was willing, able and ready to
To an American audience, what you write might be new. To an Israeli audience, it is obvious. There is indeed little difference about how the main parties of the two blocs see Israel's external challenges. But being anti-Netanyahu does have a specific meaning, and it is not against a specific policy. It is being against what Netanyahu has come to represent in his later years: someone who clings to power even at the price of appointing abysmally incompetent people, destructive people even, at key positions, Ben-Gvir being exhibit 1, but by no means the only one. Someone who favors loyalty above competence, and who oversees the attempt to eliminate the only oversight that exists over the executive in Israel, the judiciary - in order to let his incompetent ministers appoint even less competent government officials. Someone who will - it now is coming to light - undermine the confidence in the election results by planting fake evidence of electoral fraud. Someone who is willing to destroy the fabric of Israeli society with poisonous discourse in order to stay in power.
Eisenkot appears indeed to be, in this respect, his exact opposite - including in his command of the English language. That's fine. This is not "anti-Netanyahu". It has a very specific, positive meaning that all Israelis understand, including the pro-Netanyahu camp. He might, in fact, represent a fundamental change of direction in internal Israeli politics. A healing of artificial internal rifts. A return to the appreciation of competence. A change that will not diminish the external challenges that Israel faces, but that may improve the ability of Israeli society to face them.
Yitzhak Rabin believed most of the things Gadi Eisenkot believes in, before he was elected in 1992. A year after his election he signed the Oslo Accords with the PLO.
Maybe what they believe in is less important than whether they still believe it after the election.
Voting on the basis of ideas, issues and policies? Too difficult for many people especially here in America where so many refuse to understand much less discuss issues that affect their lives and families and others they pretend to care about
Heres the good news in America if BIBI leaves office. The average anti zionist jew will havd difficulty yelling the name EISENKOT. It doesn't just roll.off ones tongue. And they will be forced to discuss the issues rather than a personality.
Well stated. But, I don’t see much change in the politics any time soon. In the case of the US (and elsewhere) when people are taught no lessons of history, no skill of reason/analysis, and fame is to be found as an “influencer” on social media, preferably spewing hate)….not too promising.
It may well be that Mr. Netanyahu once made contributions to the conservative movement in Israeli politics—much as Trump undoubtedly succeeded in articulating the sentiments of many, particularly among the American lower class. But both politicians have now become, above all, a burden to the conservative message and movement.
Far too much attention is focused on what many perceive as their toxic personalities and the resulting social impact. Throughout history, such toxic personalities have, unfortunately, all too often exerted a disastrous influence on the course of events.
Indeed, let us return to a focus on broad visions, ideas, and plans.
Just how much are Israeli politicians ready to give up to get rid of Netanyahu?
So far, there have been criminal charges filed against him, and a trial lasting almost a decade. A trial which is now looking like the guilty parties are the prosecution (for using illegal tactics to gather evidence and for using these tactics without permission from the AG) , the police (also guilty of illegal wiretapping and blackmail), and the AG who filed the charges against Netanyahu (he either did not give permission for the above illegal tactics or he "does not remember").
Just last night, on channel N12, Elana Dayan "exposed" Netanyahu's newest crime...something about tampering with the Arab vote. Believe me, if he had tampered with that vote, they would not be sitting with 19 mandates.
But the new trial. Same as the old trial.
Then there was the five years od demonstrations. First over the "Crime Minister"(see above) when throngs of idiots came out to protest during Covid. Then there were the Judicial Reforms, so important that not one of the (at least) one hundred people I asked, could tell me what even one reform was. But it was obviously important to them, because after blocking streets, highways, hospitals and airports, they finally decided on a Refusal to Serve Movement, and thought it proper to inform the world at large that the IDF was at its weakest and "come September, Netanyahu would have no army".
And then the "surprise" invasion on October 7th occurred.
After that they were off and running about the price that must be paid to get the hostages back. What price? "At any price". Great negotiating tactic. I would not buy a car that way. Would you.
But all is permitted in the name of getting ris of Netanyahu.
Now, the Opposition ran under the following platform:
Insistence on equality in IDF service:
Toward this end, the chareidim were demonized daily for almost three years (yes, they gave plenty of ammunition).
Bennett actually said "You are killing our soldiers by not serving".
At various times, Liberman called them "Parasites.
You get the picture.
Less than 48 hours after the election, the entire opposition (save Golan) was ready, willing and able to sacrifice the draft of the chareidim. The draft was labelled as "not the right time", "the Army does not want them" or " we will do a "light draft".
Insistence on a Zionistic and democratic government:
No Opposition member was going to sit with the non zionist chareidim or the non zionist and non democratic arabs.
Again, less than 48 hours after the election, those values were thrown to wind, or maybe into the ocean where Tomer Yifat Yirushalmi's phone lies.
Suddenly, the very arabs who are still calling Hamas a "charitable organization" and are still refraining comndeming the massacre of October 7th, are worthy of such positions as sitting on the Committee of Foreign Affairs and Security". No conflict of interest there.
And, there you have it.
There is nothing the opposition won't do to rid themselves of a leader, who has devoted his entire life to this country. Nothing they won't stoop to, nothing they won't lie about, nothing they consider more important than this sacred goal.
We have become a society fueled by baseless and sickening hatred.
I fear for our survival.
At some point, the opposition indicated that "zionist
included neither Chareidim nor Arabs".
Within less than 48 hours, every one of them was willing, able and ready to
To an American audience, what you write might be new. To an Israeli audience, it is obvious. There is indeed little difference about how the main parties of the two blocs see Israel's external challenges. But being anti-Netanyahu does have a specific meaning, and it is not against a specific policy. It is being against what Netanyahu has come to represent in his later years: someone who clings to power even at the price of appointing abysmally incompetent people, destructive people even, at key positions, Ben-Gvir being exhibit 1, but by no means the only one. Someone who favors loyalty above competence, and who oversees the attempt to eliminate the only oversight that exists over the executive in Israel, the judiciary - in order to let his incompetent ministers appoint even less competent government officials. Someone who will - it now is coming to light - undermine the confidence in the election results by planting fake evidence of electoral fraud. Someone who is willing to destroy the fabric of Israeli society with poisonous discourse in order to stay in power.
Eisenkot appears indeed to be, in this respect, his exact opposite - including in his command of the English language. That's fine. This is not "anti-Netanyahu". It has a very specific, positive meaning that all Israelis understand, including the pro-Netanyahu camp. He might, in fact, represent a fundamental change of direction in internal Israeli politics. A healing of artificial internal rifts. A return to the appreciation of competence. A change that will not diminish the external challenges that Israel faces, but that may improve the ability of Israeli society to face them.