45 Comments
User's avatar
Jane Foster's avatar

I am not Jewish. I was brought up in Texas in the 50s and 60s, in a white middle-class family that attended a Protestant church but was not very religious. Between then and now I have lived in the Washington DC area and in several other countries including Pakistan. I never in a million years thought I would see anything like this resurgence of antisemitism. The events of October 7 broke my heart, and I thought everyone in the Western world would feel the same pain, outrage, and sympathy that I feel. I feel like I am living in the world of the 1993 film The Body Snatchers. Half the population have lost their minds. I pray for a return to sanity.

Expand full comment
Robin Alexander's avatar

Thank goodness for people like you. I truly appreciate you.

Expand full comment
Jane Foster's avatar

Thank you, Robin. I just wish we had the power to do something.

Expand full comment
Sophia Pascoe's avatar

This 🙏🏼

Expand full comment
Zarayah Israel's avatar

In retrospect, is the West being revisited by "history repeats itself" with Bonhoeffer's "Theory of Stupidity"?!! 😢

Expand full comment
Jane Foster's avatar

I had to look up Bonhoeffer. The answer is Yes, emphatically.

Expand full comment
MAG's avatar

Jane, we love you, thank you, and welcome you with open arms. The significance of non Jews calling out this centuries old hatred cannot be overstated. You are among the righteous.🙏

Expand full comment
None's avatar

Jane, I feel the same way. I don’t know anyone who expresses support for Hamas or antisemitism. And if I do, they don’t do it around me. It makes me feel as though I am in an alternate universe. How can so many embrace such a detestable construct? I am from a very similar background and have lived in other countries, too. I’ve never seen the world filled with such inexplicable hatred.

I am also from a casually Protestant Southern middle class family. I didn’t grow up in a racist household. And my parents welcomed all my friends into our home, no matter their race, religion or ethnicity.

Perhaps I‘be been lucky, but honestly, I believe people such as you and I far outnumber the haters. More of us stand with the Jewish people than against. We’re just not as loud and in-your-face as they are. Maybe we should be.

Expand full comment
Jane Foster's avatar

Maybe we should—although I don't think that would change many of their minds. In my opinion, the biggest reason for the current wave of antisemitism (and for what Elon Musk calls the Woke Mind Virus) is ignorance. Ignorance of religion, ignorance of the world outside the United States, ignorance of history. I haven't attended church since I graduated from high school, but I learned and I remember both the stories told by the Bible and the morality taught therein. I now believe that a fully realized adult needs to have learned the fundamentals of a religion. I regret not forcing myself to attend church with my child and send her to Sunday school and Bible camp.

Now 48, she's voting Democrat. I want to know how she feels about Israel, but I can't ask her anything political. I had a friend, a retired editor (as I am), tell me years ago that she knew I was better informed than she is and that she couldn't defend her "progressive" opinions but she wasn't giving them up. (Her husband is a non-observant Jew. We haven't talked since October 7, but I doubt the events of that day made her think.) These otherwise intelligent adult women are willfully ignorant. I don't think we can educate the deluded mobs no matter how loud and in-your-face we become.

Expand full comment
Susan Hirshorn's avatar

Jane I think you nailed it! We've been experiencing an invasion of the body snatchers! Nothing else adequately explains the total lack of common sense and moral clarity the West has been experiencing.

Expand full comment
Arrr Bee's avatar

Artists have always been over valued as intellectuals. They’re some of the most ignorant, self absorbed and self promoting people I have ever met. Being an artist makes a person more likely to be horrible, not less. Leni Riefenstahl was an artist and a Nazi and members of the Free Palestine cult are the new Nazi sympathizers, admirers of genocidal Islamist terrorists.

Expand full comment
Robin Alexander's avatar

Great article. Yours is not the only industry in which anti-semitism is crawling out from under rocks where it used to hide with the slugs -- and with a new boldness. I have three kids. One works at home, so he's safe. One works in the hospitality industry -- but high up and in an extremely cosmopolitan location. Last month she experienced three anti-semitic remarks from the same person: one was overheard, one was made directly to her, one was a comment at a meeting she was attending with ALL the high-ups. She pressed it and got the person to admit publicly that "those people" were "Jews." Everyone remained silent. My other child is a teacher in a school in a small city up north. While passing another teacher in the hallway, she looked at him and said, "Free Palestine."

They both took the issue to HR / the principal and in both cases were met with shock and compassion. With the first incident, the guilty party apologized profusely and everyone went on professionally as a team. With the second incident, it has only just happened so I don't know the final outcome. I worked in corporate America for 39 years and only ONCE overheard an anti-semitic remark. These two workplace incidents with my children have occurred within the past 4 weeks!

Perhaps if the general atmosphere were not so anti-semitic, one could overlook these things as the stupidity and bad manners of a few ignorant people. But in today's environment it is imperative that these things be reported. We have to make a fuss and make it understood that it is not okay to "create a hostile workplace" for Jews (it's always handy to use phrases with legal overtones; that makes employers nervous). They can think what they like, but they must behave professionally. That's all.

Expand full comment
Priva's avatar

Art is dead. Art is a form that had meaning when it was a part of aristocratic patronage and the very rare talent that could break through: very few and only the best could create amazing art because most did not have the time to create or could even attempt to live off art/music/theater. We are at a huge inflection point in which due to modernization and technology many have the time and resources to create, therefore diluting the meaning and beauty of the special and unique. Thus, there is a cannibalization of artists clawing after the shrinking crumbs as the art world collapses into pastiche and simulacrum. And it does not help that DEI has wrung the last bits of authenticity and truthfulness from art and theater. And the art world doubles down into an amoral, debaucherous joke devoid of universal beauty as what we saw at the Olympics. So it isn’t surprising that many in the art world have jumped on anti-semitism and far left radicalism because they are untalented and unimportant. And, instead of glorifying western civilization like Shakespeare, Mozart and Michaelangelo, they turn to glorifying backwards and barbaric ideologies.

Expand full comment
Sophia Pascoe's avatar

“For instance, if you are an anarchist or a universal anti-nationalist, and therefore believe no nations have a right to exist, which further entails an apathy for all country borders and nation-states including (but not only) the State of Israel, then you are a non-antisemitic “anti-Zionist.”

Many on the left seem to spring from the Islamo—leftists manifesto. Using Marxism to battle ram capitalism, at the sacrifice of women’s rights. It seems strange to me how such beliefs ironically call for a “unify or die”, the communist manifesto, the destruction of all ethnicity and religious belief, a colonial dystopian, the flip side to this ideaology is that you’re supplanting your own utopian fantasy at the cost of diversity, which is truly what makes our world so unique. Pluralist society’s who value tolerance is what the world needs. Not more communism that ends in genocides and bloodshed.

Christopher Hitchens once said all anti semites are anti Zionist. But not all anti Zionists are anti semites, I think he would approve of your reasoning here. Sadly most are anti semites.

Expand full comment
Beatrice Nora Caflun's avatar

Thank you so much for your wonderful article.......I am also an artist ( pianist ) Jewish, zionist, and also lost some friends after October 7th .......It's utterly shameful and unbelievable that so many hav sided with the murderers and kidnappers of our people !!! ...I will keep on playing sublime music every day .....Best wishes and keep on creating art......

Expand full comment
Daisy Moses Chief Crackpot's avatar

fantastik piece! "acteur" performer-filmmacher here, canceled (outta work) fer not bein' woke AND fer not complin' with the plandemic proty-culls--livin' without income with two kids (all outta da loop fer not complyin') not bein' a "walk in the park" (Central or otherwise) we had ta leave our hometown of NYC fer the boonies (NYC havin' gone ta hell in a handbasket--when we left my younger daughter knew SEVEN (!) kids that decided they were trans--an' of course NYC went full-out anti-joo...). I could beef more but fer the sake of brevity, those that cannot act--write! Ergo, if I cannot act, I stack!

(and write in the vernacular in the tradition of Al Capp/Lil'Abner--Al was also chewish--an' of my nom-de-chicken-feather namesake Daisy Mae Moses):

https://thcsofdaisymoses.substack.com/

have covered Israel & jooish themes too:

https://thcsofdaisymoses.substack.com/p/if-israel-falls-we-are-next

https://thcsofdaisymoses.substack.com/p/jewish-heroes-of-the-plandemic-a?

(the above covers the comics ya mention indirectly ;-)

https://thcsofdaisymoses.substack.com/p/puttin-on-sum-passover-alls

former lefty myself, natch ;-)

mebbe yer idear ain't so crackpotty--a forum fer jooish creativity? -- wull A Funny Thing Happened on the Way...

Expand full comment
Robin Alexander's avatar

Wow! Sorry for all the mayhem in your life, but that was an interesting read. SEVEN kids ?!? That's beyond insane. It's so so sad.

Expand full comment
Daisy Moses Chief Crackpot's avatar

thx, an' yup an' some of 'em aren't just "identifyin'" as trans--they're on hormones already (whore moans!--ouch!) doin' untold damage to themselves an' one even had a surgery at I think 13--so scary AND irreversible--an' that wuz the NYC we left behind with my daughter gettin' yelled at by two (former) friends for refusin' ta state her pronouns or her "sexual identity" as if anyone knows what that means or should care?--Oh an' she was told only gay people could use the world gay so she got a "talkin' to" fer that too--insanity! It's a LOT of kids messed up an' shamefully the parents don't say "no." So now if yer not woke AND yer chewish in NYC yer done for! Not even safe--one've her orthodox friends is now gettin' bused to private school in Joisey just b/c there were too many haters outside her school on the upper west side plus the school needed an armed guard--at a school for chewish girls no less (mean'times the entire city is goin' down the terlet...) Sad. It once wuz home--a welcomin' place fer all chews an' now it's turned upside down-

Expand full comment
Robin Alexander's avatar

This is shameful and sad and baffling and angering all at once! I was born and bred I Long Island and always think of NYC as "my city." My father's business was there on 7th Ave. My grandparents lived at the Dakota. But we're talking the 60s and 70s. So so sad -- and those kids! Agonizing. Again, sorry your daughter was subjected to the insanity; she will grow from it in the end.

Expand full comment
Daisy Moses Chief Crackpot's avatar

ah, a fellow new yawker!--7th ave evokes fond memories--until it didn't (it's kinda nasty now) But yup so SAD indeed--what NYC's become. (An' thanks fer the thoughts 'bout my younger daughter--I sure hope so!). LI is better but they got hit by the woke bug too...sadly.

Wowee, the Dakota--such a legendary place! Were they there when Leonard Bernstein was there? Carly Simon & Schusters? So many interestin' folks in one buildin'--such a gorgeous one too! (I've only seen the interior in Rosemary's Baby tho, lol). Landmarked thank god!

So ya know that neib--my daughter & I took the B- train to her dance classes right there (to git ta Lincoln Center) an' we'd see (shortly before we left) homeless men relievin' themselves (in every way) on that block--right off the park! DOORMAN blds an' THAT allowed? Can you imagine it? NEVER thought I'd see the UWS so gone ta the dogs... I mean Time Square sure, it got gross again real fast--but most don't know that the UWS is totally gettin' wrecked too...

(ps too bad they didn't keep that apt. tho!)

Expand full comment
Robin Alexander's avatar

I only remember hearing that Steve Lawrence and Eydie Gorme lived there. My grandparents retired probably in the late 60s / early 70s and moved to Collins Ave in Miami Beach. I remember visiting there, but it was sooooo long ago. Your descriptions of the city now are heartbreaking. I was there a year ago - saw a show (Some Like it Hot), ate at Sardi's. Not too bad wherever we were -- walking distance from the theatre, a bit further west I think. Now we live in West Palm Beach and only have to fight hurricanes and the occasional tornado. I wish you well. Wish us ALL well (and I hope this trans craze goes way soon, although for some, the damage will last a lifetime, I'm afraid).

Expand full comment
Daisy Moses Chief Crackpot's avatar

omg I LOVE Steve & Eydie!!! they were such an adorable couple, so talented--grew up watchin' 'em on the teevee (oh those variety shows!) -- lol Collins Avenue! Okay--it was either Wolfies 'er the Famous Restaurant there as we loved both of 'em --one of 'em was on Collins! an Famous had Fried Kreplach!) Yes yes, looong ago fer me! Yes my city, nyc, is now heartbreakin'ly sad... I miss what it wuz so much, now we're in the boonies far from any grocery with a gefilte aisle (or even shelf!)-- I think Sardis is still standin'--I went as a kid--you go fer the "ambi-ants" (the caricatures) not fer the food lol. Now Russian Tea Room--THAT wuz an'nother story--also went belly (lox) up. Never been ta W. Palm but hear it's nice--omg yes the tornados an' hurry-caines. I hate ta say it--they are not by accident (this is vy I'm a crackpot--but it's troo--the engineers like ta do stuff...so good ta have an exit plan just in case). Thx thx fer the well wishes! Back'at'cha there--yes we wish all us well an' the kids--omg the kids with this trans "mishegas"--when/how will they live normal lives? yes, agreed... Nice chattin' with ya Robin since you "remember da joint"--we are lucky ta have known the NYC of its golden days.. now they ain't even tarnished brass (I just hope the mooseums survive... the MyGrunts ain't too careful with windows & anythin' we used ta value here...) An' meanwhile--let's hope Israel survives too--what times...(oy what times!)

Expand full comment
Miriamnae's avatar

Thank you for your story. They are adding up, our stories. Am Yisrael Chai…

Expand full comment
Alfred Harder's avatar

Stupidity, Ignorance, Distortions and Lies are an art form for the Intellectually incompetent and lazy, moronic Jew haters!

Expand full comment
Alfred Harder's avatar

I know EXACTLY what I'm talking about, as I grew up in a very anti-semitic environment, once in High School confronting a teacher and former Nazi child soldier, who attempted to deny the Holocaust altogether. But, when pressed, he claimed it to be a Soviet conspiracy, which incredibly enraged me, as I've Soviet ancestry! And since Paraguay and Brazil were the only 2 Latinamerican nations to declare war against Nazi Germany, I demanded to know How many Paraguayan soldiers he had killed? When he said that he didn't know, I demanded his immediate resignation, as someone that doesn't know anything, had NO business being a teacher! Now his face got all red in rage too, and he said the unthinkable: "If the Germans did it, then the Jews deserved it!" Now I was shivering in rage, and it took 4 teachers and a dozen students to keep us from killing each other! I then demanded that the teacher be escorted out of his class and be fired! He was escorted out and I never saw, nor heart from him again!

Expand full comment
Shlomo Levin's avatar

Even though I haven't (yet) experienced this personally, I know that you're right. The more we speak up the better.

Expand full comment
Shelah Horvitz's avatar

I was in the stable for a few years at a Jewish-owned NYC gallery, but it went belly-up in February, so now I'm gallery shopping, and part of gallery shopping involves entering competitions. Although I have been a finalist in three international ARC competitions and at the international ModPortrait competition at MEAM in Spain in the past, this year I have been rejected by all the galleries to which I've submitted. There was a concerted effort online to cancel the great David Kassan's work from this year's MEAM exhibition, although that effort did fail. I had made some Jewish-themed paintings, and that work I submitted to specifically Jewish competitions, most of which accepted my work, but there was no follow-through, no exhibition, no publication, no website mention, nothing. It was bizarre and the fact that this has happened a few times is even more bizarre. The Jewish-owned galleries where I submitted my work either rejected it or ghosted me. The ARC accepted all my submissions this year *except* for one that was explicitly Jewish. This is not a question of quality. I'm doing better work now than I did when my work was being accepted everywhere. I did recently win the Gold Medal at the Guild of Boston Artists New England Regional competition, and that surprise did my soul a lot of good because I thought I was being cancelled everywhere. I was especially grateful in the context of all the antisemitism that has welled up in Cambridge and greater Boston. The fact remains, it is one thing to make the art. It is another thing altogether to get it seen. The only thing to do is to keep doing your best work and to keep trying to get it out there.

Expand full comment
April's avatar

I am not Jewish and have been outspoken in my support of Israel and the Jewish people since October 7. In my neighborhood I confront antisemitism daily in graffiti spoken words and white women wearing fancy keffiyehs. I do not feel safe as I am well known here but I can’t afford to move. I will not be silent. The “friends” I lost were never friends at all. Anyone who will stand by for a new Holocaust is no friend of mine

Expand full comment
Liz's avatar

The white women in fancy keffiyehs are very prominent in my neighborhood too and I roll my eyes every time I see one.

Expand full comment
Laura's avatar

You didn't lose friends; they were never your friends in the first place. There's not a dimes worth of difference between these marxist pigs in the art world and neo-nazis.

Expand full comment
Susan Hirshorn's avatar

The "art world" has always been a collection of mostly no-talent idiots who cling to left wing politics because that world supports them financially. But if you think those of us who reject those policies cannot appreciate good art, you're dead wrong. Jewish artists: if you have talent it will shine brightly through your work and "sell" because it is coming from your soul. Form your own groups, get Jewish and pro-Israel backers. Don't worry about it.

Expand full comment
Ron Goldman's avatar

Well said my friend! Keep up the good work and shine your light in a dark world! Good will always prevail!

Expand full comment
Jo-Ann Mort's avatar

Josh leifer is not anti-Zionist - you should read what he writes before labeling

Expand full comment