Against the backdrop of a potential hostage and ceasefire deal with Hamas, the Jewish state would be wisest to resist international pressure to choose an illusion of "peace" over existential security.
Thank you for this piece Nachum. I have been pleased to share it with some others, in hopes that it may help open their eyes - at least to some degree.
I am an American Evangelical Christian; a Christian Zionist, and I grieve for the ignorance of Israeli reality, and anti-Semitic deception that, tragically, typifies the thinking of so many Americans today; particularly amongst those who profess to be Bible-believing followers of Yeshua. While there is a great diversity of belief and practice amongst Christians, and some are less inimical towards ‘the Jews’ than others, collectively, such people contribute much aid and ‘cover’ towards the evil that is afoot in the world today; evil that ultimately seeks the destruction of Israel, and the Jewish people.
That said, I am also well aware of the diverse views of Jewish Israelis towards people such as myself, including those who would see me as an insidious ‘enemy’ - at the very least, not to be trusted. That grieves me as well, but I understand the historical basis of such views.
I do what I can, as opportunity presents itself, to counter both of those errors. Although I have been doing so for many years now, in my dealings with American Christians, such efforts have become far more common, and far more heated, since the tragedy of October 7.
Often, it feels like I am shoveling sand against the tide, and I fight against discouragement by remembering that what we are dealing with here, is spiritual in nature. It is largely, if not entirely, resistant to ‘reason’ and impervious to the presentation of truth. As such, ultimately, the evil winds sweeping our world can only be effectively countered, individually and/or collectively, through prayerful, practical, and continuous, application of (correctly interpreted) Biblical faith.
It seems I have rambled here, and I will close now. But I will do so with a final statement of appreciation and support for your own efforts, and my hope to contribute some encouragement to all who have the same spirit to resist that which seeks Israel’s destruction.
May the G_d of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob continue to bless and protect the people of Israel, give her defenders victory against her enemies, and bring all His promises to His Chosen People to fruition.
Outstanding article. The only thing the US has done for its ally, Israel, is to help extend the war to the present. While Hezbollah was building its arsenal of weapons, Israel should have been doing the same. Too much dependence on the US for weapons or any country is not a good strategy. As I've said many times, no matter what Israel does, t will never satisfy the US or any Western country that doesn't understand the serious security issues Israel faces. Israel could have hand carried food to each Palestinian, and the West, the UN and other so-called humanitarian agencies would have criticized and condemned them. So Nachum, you are correct, Israel should listen but act alone.
In order to "act as if you are alone" you must have trump cards in your deck. Re Biden's pressure on Bibi re reaching a ceasefire deal. Bibi must provide his terms - non negotiable - and have a devastating weapon ready to use (like a cyberweapon capable of taking out Iran and/or Lebanon's infrastructure) if Biden refuses. Turn the tables on those Islamo/Leftist demons in the White House.
Israel could use some real friends, but as you pointed out, they are making amazing strides on their own. What the West doesn't seem to realize is how much we need Israel--a strong, stable Israel--in the Middle East. It really is time that Israel's allies support them in all aspects of this conflict.
What a brilliant piece! I agree with you 100% A two state solution will never bring peace. More war and death will be a result, The Palestinian’s will never be happy until they destroy all the Jewish people.
Outstanding diagnosis for the cancer , the source of their success must be sabotaged cut out and boy they have source of resource so help us God of Israel chizak ye am Israel.
on Biden ie. the ruling Party's watch they completely 100% A through Z totally screwed up their exit from Afghanistan. The They ie THAT Party and their corporate cronies ARE e-v-i-l. The real deal. I claim that from and forever since Oct 7, 2023 it is and will remain for the foreseeable future be up to us Jewish individuals and clusters of and organizations of - to get "The BIG Lesson". That is really likely 100s of small personal lessons and enriching confrontations with and within our own Jewish Culture and its Practices. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vaFbxJe-N2k
I would like to share our organization, the Zionist Voters of America with Future of Jewish members. Please find the press release on our substack to read a description of our strategy to support Israel. Thank you
I am not offended, but the truthful possibility leaves me "cold". I was privileged to have grown up in a blue collar, multi-ethnic neighborhood (several ethnicities and at least three religions ). Yet it was the "block" that bound us together. July 4th was celebrated with all the enthusiasm mustered by peoples so profoundly grateful to have found a safe haven. Even the arch enemies (European) of Poles and Russians were set aside. We were American after all. I had never experienced fear nor insecurity. And I ache to think of what has become of this wonderful country. David, it is not you -- it is this cruel and violent world.
Thank you for this piece Nachum. I have been pleased to share it with some others, in hopes that it may help open their eyes - at least to some degree.
I am an American Evangelical Christian; a Christian Zionist, and I grieve for the ignorance of Israeli reality, and anti-Semitic deception that, tragically, typifies the thinking of so many Americans today; particularly amongst those who profess to be Bible-believing followers of Yeshua. While there is a great diversity of belief and practice amongst Christians, and some are less inimical towards ‘the Jews’ than others, collectively, such people contribute much aid and ‘cover’ towards the evil that is afoot in the world today; evil that ultimately seeks the destruction of Israel, and the Jewish people.
That said, I am also well aware of the diverse views of Jewish Israelis towards people such as myself, including those who would see me as an insidious ‘enemy’ - at the very least, not to be trusted. That grieves me as well, but I understand the historical basis of such views.
I do what I can, as opportunity presents itself, to counter both of those errors. Although I have been doing so for many years now, in my dealings with American Christians, such efforts have become far more common, and far more heated, since the tragedy of October 7.
Often, it feels like I am shoveling sand against the tide, and I fight against discouragement by remembering that what we are dealing with here, is spiritual in nature. It is largely, if not entirely, resistant to ‘reason’ and impervious to the presentation of truth. As such, ultimately, the evil winds sweeping our world can only be effectively countered, individually and/or collectively, through prayerful, practical, and continuous, application of (correctly interpreted) Biblical faith.
It seems I have rambled here, and I will close now. But I will do so with a final statement of appreciation and support for your own efforts, and my hope to contribute some encouragement to all who have the same spirit to resist that which seeks Israel’s destruction.
May the G_d of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob continue to bless and protect the people of Israel, give her defenders victory against her enemies, and bring all His promises to His Chosen People to fruition.
Outstanding article. The only thing the US has done for its ally, Israel, is to help extend the war to the present. While Hezbollah was building its arsenal of weapons, Israel should have been doing the same. Too much dependence on the US for weapons or any country is not a good strategy. As I've said many times, no matter what Israel does, t will never satisfy the US or any Western country that doesn't understand the serious security issues Israel faces. Israel could have hand carried food to each Palestinian, and the West, the UN and other so-called humanitarian agencies would have criticized and condemned them. So Nachum, you are correct, Israel should listen but act alone.
In order to "act as if you are alone" you must have trump cards in your deck. Re Biden's pressure on Bibi re reaching a ceasefire deal. Bibi must provide his terms - non negotiable - and have a devastating weapon ready to use (like a cyberweapon capable of taking out Iran and/or Lebanon's infrastructure) if Biden refuses. Turn the tables on those Islamo/Leftist demons in the White House.
Israel could use some real friends, but as you pointed out, they are making amazing strides on their own. What the West doesn't seem to realize is how much we need Israel--a strong, stable Israel--in the Middle East. It really is time that Israel's allies support them in all aspects of this conflict.
What a brilliant piece! I agree with you 100% A two state solution will never bring peace. More war and death will be a result, The Palestinian’s will never be happy until they destroy all the Jewish people.
Outstanding diagnosis for the cancer , the source of their success must be sabotaged cut out and boy they have source of resource so help us God of Israel chizak ye am Israel.
I definitely have felt this way all along and you have backed up my feelings with good solid evidence and facts. Fantastic article. Thank you.
on Biden ie. the ruling Party's watch they completely 100% A through Z totally screwed up their exit from Afghanistan. The They ie THAT Party and their corporate cronies ARE e-v-i-l. The real deal. I claim that from and forever since Oct 7, 2023 it is and will remain for the foreseeable future be up to us Jewish individuals and clusters of and organizations of - to get "The BIG Lesson". That is really likely 100s of small personal lessons and enriching confrontations with and within our own Jewish Culture and its Practices. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vaFbxJe-N2k
I would like to share our organization, the Zionist Voters of America with Future of Jewish members. Please find the press release on our substack to read a description of our strategy to support Israel. Thank you
Israel actually HAVE ANY ACTUAL FRIENDS?
The possible reply to be given leaves me cold .. very cold.
Understood.
If I offended you, my sincere apologies.
I am not offended, but the truthful possibility leaves me "cold". I was privileged to have grown up in a blue collar, multi-ethnic neighborhood (several ethnicities and at least three religions ). Yet it was the "block" that bound us together. July 4th was celebrated with all the enthusiasm mustered by peoples so profoundly grateful to have found a safe haven. Even the arch enemies (European) of Poles and Russians were set aside. We were American after all. I had never experienced fear nor insecurity. And I ache to think of what has become of this wonderful country. David, it is not you -- it is this cruel and violent world.
For everything we see as cruel, or cold, there is so much more that is kind and loving.
There is no one person on this planet more sour than me. If I find great and joyful things every day, anyone can!
There is no blanket that can produce warmth that is needed in today's world.