Jewish history is littered with real-life examples of what happens when sociopolitical movements become messianic doctrines. The outcome is rarely pretty.
This is a good teaching moment about the Judaism in being a Jew, that I will save. And reread.
Today's young people with "Jews Say.." t shirts printed up for them by Soros? have learned that the best way to be a Jew is to dejudaize oneself. This is not new. I saw this fifty years ago on college campus I attended. Rejected the Jewish exceptionalism that M Phillips has also written about as a particular component of of Judaic civilization. so Jewishness is pulled out only as a cudgel to beat any Jews who dare to express Jewish pride and pride in Israel and its unique accomplishments. so the book I read is promoting anti Zionism as a normal response to Zionism and Zionists as fringe and deranged our indifferently racist reaction to the "plight" of the Arabs. And show NO such cared for the million fellowJews dispossesed from the "Arab world" which is also an invention of the 20th century much as "Palestinian" is.
The dispossession of Jews is not an invention, Ryan. It is a systematic program by The State, against Jews whose property and wealth is stolen, both here in The West and in The Arab world. My apologies, if you meant The Arab World is an invention, not the Dispossession of Jewish people.
Yes the Jews plight is very real and was ignored by the world as it is today. I meant that "Arab" lke "Palestinian" as is currently used is a complete fabrication of the
20th century. The "non people "Jews as the anti Zionists love to proclaim including some Israeli post Jewish Jews.... have in fact been A PEOPLE for the past 4 thousand years. The disposession of Jews predating the Muslim Arab invasion....people from the peninusula were legitmately Arabs.....is a criminal enterprise that the left prefers to ignore.
Indeed. Best wishes, Ryan. We are a group of monitors here in the UK, both Jewish and Non-Jewish, who watch Nazism and Nazis in The State and the Armed Services. The Left are harmless Useful Idiots. Most of the Left are in fact racially prejudiced, who take out their unadmitted Hate against Jews, because they think we are small enough to bully. Best wishes and do keep posting to this site.
Good to meet you in the cyber sphere.....I do have fear...I live in NYC....the city that is about to elect the first antisemitic Israel hating mayor in the world's largest Jewish city.....it is the culmination of 2 years of hate marches as you had in London and your other cities.. It is beyond my belief and my disgust. I fear that my neigbhors all of whom know I've traveled to Israel and am very Jewish identified.....and not anti semitic will vote for this creep. this hyena. I am glad you reached out to me for clarification and solidarity.
The voice of individual moral conscience is systematically drowned out by the deliberate malicious actions of The State. The enemy has always been the Collectivised State, the people harnessed by The State for the purposes of War, and demanding our fanatical Loyalty. This is called Indoctrination. Indoctrination is a total immersive experience, and starts when we are children. I rebelled against, both at chader (Sunday School), and the Far Right Elements in The State here in Europe. The way out is not through Religion alone, but through Reason and the arguments of Logic, and a good pair of eyes and ears taking in the Real World. This has taken me years, but I have been ultimately successful. This is where my AntiNazi Zionism has come from. I Hope this helps.
Yes today this is so and it was in the past. Yet Jews have always been the leaders and instigators of these movements. Let’s first remember what happened when Moses introduced the 10 commandments! Spits in Jewish politics caused the destruction of both Temples. In fact ancient Israel was always divided into separate areas often at war with each other. There were German Jews who even supported the Nazis. Communism was invented by Karl Marx then spread by Eastern European Jews that also led to their downfall. Tiken Olam took on a new meaning in America that has caused a new political rift and most NY Jews read the NYT like it’s their Bible. Look at all the different Jewish sects there are today: Satmar ,Chabad, Modern orthodox, Reform, Conservative, to name but a few. They all have different ways of understanding Judaism, and interpreting politics. Many Jews still support the Palestinians and are quoted non-stop by the liberal media. Israel today is split into many camps as bad as America. They are a divided country on politics, religion, race, and how to deal with internal politics and the enemies that surround them. Will modern Israel suffer the same destruction as happened in Roman Times?
Modern Israel has also taken up each new “woke” fad that is destroying the West. Gender identity, LGBTQ, promiscuity, war between the Knesset and the legislature. Is Israel the new Sodom and Gemorra? Look what happened to them!
Jews have been the most troublesome and divided people throughout history. They have also been the most successful due to the hate of the world around them and their struggles for survival. Why can’t they realize that they are causing again their own destruction, not just in Israel but also in the diaspora?
The vast majority of American Jews are "unaffiliated". Many of them long ago stopped worshiping God and started worshiping the Democrat party. They think that believing in things that are based on faith is below them, so they bow down to the golden calf of leftist thought.
Our Josh Hoffman is a modern day prophet in the full and best sense of the word. He follows in the footsteps of his namesake, Isaiah, Moshe and the other greats. Thank you Josh. (PS you wrote my article better than I could. But add please the idolatry of so-called Tikkun Olam and so-called social justice). ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I seem to be living in a parallel world. I never believed that Jews could commit the crime of mass murder because the Jewish religion calls for ethical and moral behavior. I see now I never understood it.
I'll give you a handy little quote from one of the great secular religious giants of our time, Chairman Mao, from his "Little Red Book". "Political power grows from the barrel of a gun." That tells you what you need to know about the direction of the movement.
This is a good teaching moment about the Judaism in being a Jew, that I will save. And reread.
Today's young people with "Jews Say.." t shirts printed up for them by Soros? have learned that the best way to be a Jew is to dejudaize oneself. This is not new. I saw this fifty years ago on college campus I attended. Rejected the Jewish exceptionalism that M Phillips has also written about as a particular component of of Judaic civilization. so Jewishness is pulled out only as a cudgel to beat any Jews who dare to express Jewish pride and pride in Israel and its unique accomplishments. so the book I read is promoting anti Zionism as a normal response to Zionism and Zionists as fringe and deranged our indifferently racist reaction to the "plight" of the Arabs. And show NO such cared for the million fellowJews dispossesed from the "Arab world" which is also an invention of the 20th century much as "Palestinian" is.
The dispossession of Jews is not an invention, Ryan. It is a systematic program by The State, against Jews whose property and wealth is stolen, both here in The West and in The Arab world. My apologies, if you meant The Arab World is an invention, not the Dispossession of Jewish people.
Yes the Jews plight is very real and was ignored by the world as it is today. I meant that "Arab" lke "Palestinian" as is currently used is a complete fabrication of the
20th century. The "non people "Jews as the anti Zionists love to proclaim including some Israeli post Jewish Jews.... have in fact been A PEOPLE for the past 4 thousand years. The disposession of Jews predating the Muslim Arab invasion....people from the peninusula were legitmately Arabs.....is a criminal enterprise that the left prefers to ignore.
Indeed. Best wishes, Ryan. We are a group of monitors here in the UK, both Jewish and Non-Jewish, who watch Nazism and Nazis in The State and the Armed Services. The Left are harmless Useful Idiots. Most of the Left are in fact racially prejudiced, who take out their unadmitted Hate against Jews, because they think we are small enough to bully. Best wishes and do keep posting to this site.
Good to meet you in the cyber sphere.....I do have fear...I live in NYC....the city that is about to elect the first antisemitic Israel hating mayor in the world's largest Jewish city.....it is the culmination of 2 years of hate marches as you had in London and your other cities.. It is beyond my belief and my disgust. I fear that my neigbhors all of whom know I've traveled to Israel and am very Jewish identified.....and not anti semitic will vote for this creep. this hyena. I am glad you reached out to me for clarification and solidarity.
Politics and ideology are the opiate of the non-religious. And the schools serve as their pulpits
Ah, that's one Aran. There's another off the coast of Ireland, which is where my 'man' is from.
The voice of individual moral conscience is systematically drowned out by the deliberate malicious actions of The State. The enemy has always been the Collectivised State, the people harnessed by The State for the purposes of War, and demanding our fanatical Loyalty. This is called Indoctrination. Indoctrination is a total immersive experience, and starts when we are children. I rebelled against, both at chader (Sunday School), and the Far Right Elements in The State here in Europe. The way out is not through Religion alone, but through Reason and the arguments of Logic, and a good pair of eyes and ears taking in the Real World. This has taken me years, but I have been ultimately successful. This is where my AntiNazi Zionism has come from. I Hope this helps.
Insightful. I’d be interested to read your thoughts about how to navigate this.
Yes today this is so and it was in the past. Yet Jews have always been the leaders and instigators of these movements. Let’s first remember what happened when Moses introduced the 10 commandments! Spits in Jewish politics caused the destruction of both Temples. In fact ancient Israel was always divided into separate areas often at war with each other. There were German Jews who even supported the Nazis. Communism was invented by Karl Marx then spread by Eastern European Jews that also led to their downfall. Tiken Olam took on a new meaning in America that has caused a new political rift and most NY Jews read the NYT like it’s their Bible. Look at all the different Jewish sects there are today: Satmar ,Chabad, Modern orthodox, Reform, Conservative, to name but a few. They all have different ways of understanding Judaism, and interpreting politics. Many Jews still support the Palestinians and are quoted non-stop by the liberal media. Israel today is split into many camps as bad as America. They are a divided country on politics, religion, race, and how to deal with internal politics and the enemies that surround them. Will modern Israel suffer the same destruction as happened in Roman Times?
Modern Israel has also taken up each new “woke” fad that is destroying the West. Gender identity, LGBTQ, promiscuity, war between the Knesset and the legislature. Is Israel the new Sodom and Gemorra? Look what happened to them!
Jews have been the most troublesome and divided people throughout history. They have also been the most successful due to the hate of the world around them and their struggles for survival. Why can’t they realize that they are causing again their own destruction, not just in Israel but also in the diaspora?
Causing *again* their own destruction? Wow.
I know Aran. A island place of Heather and rain in The Scottish Highlands.
The vast majority of American Jews are "unaffiliated". Many of them long ago stopped worshiping God and started worshiping the Democrat party. They think that believing in things that are based on faith is below them, so they bow down to the golden calf of leftist thought.
Our Josh Hoffman is a modern day prophet in the full and best sense of the word. He follows in the footsteps of his namesake, Isaiah, Moshe and the other greats. Thank you Josh. (PS you wrote my article better than I could. But add please the idolatry of so-called Tikkun Olam and so-called social justice). ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I seem to be living in a parallel world. I never believed that Jews could commit the crime of mass murder because the Jewish religion calls for ethical and moral behavior. I see now I never understood it.
Beautifully written. Made me think.
Excellent. Your best piece Joshua.
I'll give you a handy little quote from one of the great secular religious giants of our time, Chairman Mao, from his "Little Red Book". "Political power grows from the barrel of a gun." That tells you what you need to know about the direction of the movement.