Genocide is not determined by the likes of a student council election. You cannot vote it into being. Either there is evidence of systematic extermination, or there is not. And, in Gaza, there is not.
What people need to understand is that the charge of genocide has nothing to do with facts or reality and certainly has nothing to do with the welfare of the actual Palestinian people, who exist as props and symbols in the minds of Western liberals. Charging Israel with genocide is an attempt to transform Jews into Nazis and thereby morally delegitimize the Jewish state and the Jewish desire for self-determination. It's not enough that Jews be demonized and attacked, they must be humiliated and stripped of any claims to protected status. Every aspiring victim group has a bad case of Holocaust Envy and feels a deep need to reverse the Jews’ historical role from victims to villains, as a way to remove them from the top of the victim pyramid and transform Jews from a protected class into oppressors who deserve punishment.
As Israeli writer Shany Mor put it: “Hauling the Jews in to plead their case before a special tribunal and face the charge that they are the real Nazis has been the fantasy of every antisemite since the first gavel hit a sound block at Nuremberg.”
The charge of genocide against Jews also works to soothe Western guilt. If the Jews are now the perpetrators instead of the victims, one no longer has to wrestle with the memory of what one’s grandparents did, or failed to do, during the actual Holocaust.
Jew haters are sick and tired of hearing about the Holocaust, sick of hearing that Jews are minorities who need and deserve protection, and many Europeans will never forgive Jews for making them murder millions of their families. The Palestinians are simply a pretext, the real goal here is to make Jews into hated outcast second-class citizens again, and stripping them of any moral status is the first step on the road to dehumanization.
I see the Holocaust envy/rage thing ALL the time. They had Holocaust envy BEFORE the Holocaust itself; it’s why the Holocaust occurred in the first place. You can read it in Hitler’s writings where he could not contain his glee after Kristallnacht. Went driving around to revel in the destruction, and he was like a giddy, giggling child. Even when I hear the “reasons” broken down for why different ppl hate Jews, I still don’t get the obsessional nature nor the degree to which ppl hate this specific group, and the “reasons” are delusional. It shows such blackness of the heart and derangement of the mind that you’d think it would be a rare phenomenon. And yet…
The so called scholars need to go back to the drawing board. Find another cause to meddle with. I agree, they are willing Israel to commit genocide. Nothing like that is happening!!
It now occurs to me that this conscious misinterpreting of " genocide", after the world has seen many true genocides and can tell, without smart-aleck definitions or re- definitions, what a genocide looks like and what wars and refugees or displaced populations look like, can only have one profound reason: to obscure and deny the genocide of the Jews themselves, which historically speaking, happened not so long ago.
If anything in a war looks like a genocide, perhaps the Jews never suffered a genocide after all. The goal is not to protect the falsely named as " victims of genocide ", the Gazans .The goal is to deny that Humanity, which includes useful idiots like these wannabe "scholars", committed true atrocities against the Jews, so that perhaps, as punishment for their " wickedness" in allegedly committing "genocide", the Jews might be subjected to a new genocide. It has already been demonstrated:Iran denied the Holocaust whilst all the while agitated for the genocide of Israel.
The Third Temple and the Kingdom of Yisrael (Davidic Dynasty) ARE ETERNAL and Sanhedrin is also in the Third Temple on Mount Moriah in Jerusalem Very Soon Baruch HaShem ✡️🇮🇱🕎❤️🙏❤️🔥
To qualify as 'genocide,' it's necessary to have the premeditated intention to systematically destroy a people or a specific group of people. That's precisely what Hamas did on October 7, 2023.
Israel, of course, has no such intention.
This doesn't mean that Israel, and especially Netanyahu, is blameless: by allowing Hamas to continue its assaults and fortification course for years, the conditions were created in which the IDF could only fight the terrorists with extremely bloody methods, at the cost of countless civilian casualties and a significant lack of humanitarian supplies.
Bloodshed in the eyes of the entire world—who is then surprised by the horror this tragedy evokes? Netanyahu is at least giving the appearance of wanting to postpone the moment of reckoning over his failures, because within the IDF, there is significant doubt as to whether this conflict can be resolved militarily, certainly not without the loss of thousands of Israeli soldiers and even more Palestinian civilians.
Like so many of Israel's critics they want Éretz Yisra'él to disappear which means they have much in common with the Third Reich and Mohammed Amin al-Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem during WWII, who was Hitler's buddy and fellow Jew hater. What always get me is these critics completely ignore October 7th as if Israel is supposed to act like nothing happened. Finally, these idiots don't understand the meaning of the word genocide and I personally have met people in the US who say the Holocaust/ Shoah never happened despite the overwhelming evidence.
But all the leftie newspapers and arab newspapers only re-iterated the first one in their typical libelous ways. This is really important that we get to the bottom of. Because genocide is not just about numbers, it's also about intent. I find it hard to believe that 47% of Israelis would want genocide, but I suppose I would understand it after October 7th. Still, seems implausible and perhaps the article that was supposed to be published in the scholarly journal never made it past peer review for good reasons (some mentioned in the 2nd Haaretz article above).
On IAGS’ own website’s “history” section, it says this:
“These early genocide scholars, a number of whom began with study of the Holocaust, were attacked by other scholars who insisted on the ‘uniqueness’ of the Holocaust.”
Yeah, so on this very “scholarly” website, they can’t help but bring up how the good members were “attacked” by the bad members who dared to state the obvious. That was written by someone from a Muslim-majority country I think; Western academics would say it in a different way, something about intersectional justice etc. It amuses me that that’s even there cause it is objectively insane.
Wrong. Humanity just wants Jews to stop committing a New Holocaust. A Palestinian Holocaust. Jewish Supremacy, like this bogus page IS the fucking problem. If you don’t change, you’re done. ✅
What people need to understand is that the charge of genocide has nothing to do with facts or reality and certainly has nothing to do with the welfare of the actual Palestinian people, who exist as props and symbols in the minds of Western liberals. Charging Israel with genocide is an attempt to transform Jews into Nazis and thereby morally delegitimize the Jewish state and the Jewish desire for self-determination. It's not enough that Jews be demonized and attacked, they must be humiliated and stripped of any claims to protected status. Every aspiring victim group has a bad case of Holocaust Envy and feels a deep need to reverse the Jews’ historical role from victims to villains, as a way to remove them from the top of the victim pyramid and transform Jews from a protected class into oppressors who deserve punishment.
As Israeli writer Shany Mor put it: “Hauling the Jews in to plead their case before a special tribunal and face the charge that they are the real Nazis has been the fantasy of every antisemite since the first gavel hit a sound block at Nuremberg.”
The charge of genocide against Jews also works to soothe Western guilt. If the Jews are now the perpetrators instead of the victims, one no longer has to wrestle with the memory of what one’s grandparents did, or failed to do, during the actual Holocaust.
Jew haters are sick and tired of hearing about the Holocaust, sick of hearing that Jews are minorities who need and deserve protection, and many Europeans will never forgive Jews for making them murder millions of their families. The Palestinians are simply a pretext, the real goal here is to make Jews into hated outcast second-class citizens again, and stripping them of any moral status is the first step on the road to dehumanization.
That was brilliant and spot on. What’s the scoop when it’s Jews on the forefront of insisting on genocide??
Thanks!
Your question hits on a much-discussed topic, here is one answer I've found interesting and compelling:
https://archive.is/20230812222347/https://www.haaretz.com/2009-01-01/ty-article/the-jew-flu-the-strange-illness-of-jewish-anti-semitism/0000017f-dedf-d856-a37f-ffdf366f0000
Sad to see how long ago that was written but how relevant it is today...
I see the Holocaust envy/rage thing ALL the time. They had Holocaust envy BEFORE the Holocaust itself; it’s why the Holocaust occurred in the first place. You can read it in Hitler’s writings where he could not contain his glee after Kristallnacht. Went driving around to revel in the destruction, and he was like a giddy, giggling child. Even when I hear the “reasons” broken down for why different ppl hate Jews, I still don’t get the obsessional nature nor the degree to which ppl hate this specific group, and the “reasons” are delusional. It shows such blackness of the heart and derangement of the mind that you’d think it would be a rare phenomenon. And yet…
What upset me the most is “journalists” unwillingness to do any research at all and just broadcast this disinfo to the world
The so called scholars need to go back to the drawing board. Find another cause to meddle with. I agree, they are willing Israel to commit genocide. Nothing like that is happening!!
The genocide that occurred was on 10/7 and before that the Holocaust
It now occurs to me that this conscious misinterpreting of " genocide", after the world has seen many true genocides and can tell, without smart-aleck definitions or re- definitions, what a genocide looks like and what wars and refugees or displaced populations look like, can only have one profound reason: to obscure and deny the genocide of the Jews themselves, which historically speaking, happened not so long ago.
If anything in a war looks like a genocide, perhaps the Jews never suffered a genocide after all. The goal is not to protect the falsely named as " victims of genocide ", the Gazans .The goal is to deny that Humanity, which includes useful idiots like these wannabe "scholars", committed true atrocities against the Jews, so that perhaps, as punishment for their " wickedness" in allegedly committing "genocide", the Jews might be subjected to a new genocide. It has already been demonstrated:Iran denied the Holocaust whilst all the while agitated for the genocide of Israel.
Those haters only learned a few words.. thats : I want .. genocide .. islamophobi
The Third Temple and the Kingdom of Yisrael (Davidic Dynasty) ARE ETERNAL and Sanhedrin is also in the Third Temple on Mount Moriah in Jerusalem Very Soon Baruch HaShem ✡️🇮🇱🕎❤️🙏❤️🔥
How likely is it that both of the following are true at the same time:
1- Israel is NOT committing genocide in Gaza
2- Bibi knows there is no military solution to Hamas but is prolonging the war to avoid getting kicked out of office & facing the music
To qualify as 'genocide,' it's necessary to have the premeditated intention to systematically destroy a people or a specific group of people. That's precisely what Hamas did on October 7, 2023.
Israel, of course, has no such intention.
This doesn't mean that Israel, and especially Netanyahu, is blameless: by allowing Hamas to continue its assaults and fortification course for years, the conditions were created in which the IDF could only fight the terrorists with extremely bloody methods, at the cost of countless civilian casualties and a significant lack of humanitarian supplies.
Bloodshed in the eyes of the entire world—who is then surprised by the horror this tragedy evokes? Netanyahu is at least giving the appearance of wanting to postpone the moment of reckoning over his failures, because within the IDF, there is significant doubt as to whether this conflict can be resolved militarily, certainly not without the loss of thousands of Israeli soldiers and even more Palestinian civilians.
Like so many of Israel's critics they want Éretz Yisra'él to disappear which means they have much in common with the Third Reich and Mohammed Amin al-Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem during WWII, who was Hitler's buddy and fellow Jew hater. What always get me is these critics completely ignore October 7th as if Israel is supposed to act like nothing happened. Finally, these idiots don't understand the meaning of the word genocide and I personally have met people in the US who say the Holocaust/ Shoah never happened despite the overwhelming evidence.
Well written. We need to figure out what was the deal with the article (supposedly in Palestine/Israel Review) that was reported on in Ha'aretz supposedly showing that 47% of Israelis (much higher percent for religious) support genocide of Palestinians:https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2025-06-03/ty-article/.premium/a-grim-poll-shows-most-jewish-israelis-support-expelling-gazans-its-brutal-and-true/00000197-3640-d9f1-abb7-7e742b300000. I wrote the author of this article and also the author of the survey at Penn State to ask why I can't see it published anywhere in a peer-reviewed journal. No response so far. There was also a debunking:https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/2025-06-04/ty-article-opinion/.premium/do-82-of-israelis-really-back-expulsion-of-gazans-the-data-tells-a-different-story/00000197-39da-da41-a9f7-3dde468d0000?lts=1757028393316.
But all the leftie newspapers and arab newspapers only re-iterated the first one in their typical libelous ways. This is really important that we get to the bottom of. Because genocide is not just about numbers, it's also about intent. I find it hard to believe that 47% of Israelis would want genocide, but I suppose I would understand it after October 7th. Still, seems implausible and perhaps the article that was supposed to be published in the scholarly journal never made it past peer review for good reasons (some mentioned in the 2nd Haaretz article above).
On IAGS’ own website’s “history” section, it says this:
“These early genocide scholars, a number of whom began with study of the Holocaust, were attacked by other scholars who insisted on the ‘uniqueness’ of the Holocaust.”
Yeah, so on this very “scholarly” website, they can’t help but bring up how the good members were “attacked” by the bad members who dared to state the obvious. That was written by someone from a Muslim-majority country I think; Western academics would say it in a different way, something about intersectional justice etc. It amuses me that that’s even there cause it is objectively insane.
Salo Aizenberg is a member of a right wing think tank. Right wing think tanks are not real news.
Someone needs to educate the arabs from Gaza about the palestinian state. It's called Jordan 🇯🇴. Now pack your bags and move!!!
Wrong. Humanity just wants Jews to stop committing a New Holocaust. A Palestinian Holocaust. Jewish Supremacy, like this bogus page IS the fucking problem. If you don’t change, you’re done. ✅
.. back to school for you .. and open your eyes to the real world ..
https://youtu.be/8m6ux-IeNo4?si=lpj9-YYXRNID47Yq
https://youtu.be/_YB8xqBIq_s?si=FZ-ZHux9e4epLPZf
💙🇮🇱💜✡️
🎗️🎗️🎗️
Worse than the Gaza Ministry of Health…Omg, lies.