21 Comments
User's avatar
Bless America's avatar

Thanks for this thoughtful and expert analysis. I missed a statement about the close to a million Jews expelled and dispossessed from Muslim lands from 1948 on. The pretext of the birth of Israel is noted, but it is a pretext, not a justification. The immorality and intolerance stand.

It seems that there may be a simpler retort to the false claim of a “ golden age” existing until Israel was born. The eliminationist Muslim hatred of Jews is religious. It’s in the Quran and the Hadith. It is co- existent with Islam. Islam has eliminated its Christian population in the Middle East, and there was no other pretext than they being non-Muslims. Bethlehem, the craddle of Christianity, is now a Muslim city. It used to be a Christian city. The Muslim craving for superiority and dominance doesn’t permit tolerance of any religion. It also explains today’s lamentable Muslim positions.

Shoshana Rose's avatar

Haj Amin al-Husayni can't be called by the term Palestinian, a word not invented until the 1960s.

He was an Arab, all of the massacres were by Arab Rulers of the time.

The Holy Land News's avatar

Thank you for posting this summary.

For further details, people interested can read the following book:

The Legacy of Islamic Antisemitism by Andrew G. Bostom

Description from Amazon books:

"This comprehensive, meticulously documented collection of scholarly articles presents indisputable evidence that a readily discernible, uniquely Islamic antisemitism-a specific Muslim hatred of Jews-has been expressed continuously since the advent of Islam. Debunking the conventional wisdom, which continues to assert that Muslim animosity toward Jews is entirely a 20th-century phenomenon fueled mainly by the protracted Arab-Israeli conflict, leading scholars provide example after example of antisemitic motifs in Muslim documents reaching back to the beginnings of Islam. The contributors show that the Koran itself is a significant source of hostility toward Jews, as well as other foundational Muslim texts including the hadith (the words and deeds of Muhammad as recorded by pious Muslim transmitters) and the sira (the earliest Muslim biographies of Muhammad). Many other examples are adduced in the writings of influential Muslim jurists, theologians, and scholars, from the Middle Ages through the contemporary era. These primary sources, and seminal secondary analyses translated here for the first time into English - such as Hartwig Hirschfeld's mid-1880s essays on Muhammad's subjugation of the Jews of Medina and George Vajda's elegant, comprehensive 1937 study of the hadith - detail the sacralized rationale for Islam's anti-Jewish bigotry. Numerous complementary historical accounts illustrate the resulting plight of Jewish communities in the Muslim world across space and time, culminating in the genocidal threat posed to the Jews of Israel today."

Laurel's avatar

It’s so incredibly important to push against the idea that life for Jews under Arab rule was some uniformly “Golden Age” that didn’t involve discrimination and persecution. At the least, Jews usually faced systematic discrimination and structural inequality that far too often devolved into persecution in the form of pogroms and massacres.

When confronted with the expulsion of almost a million Jews from Arab countries after 1948, the response so often is to point to this “Golden Age” before Israel, implicitly blaming the creation of the Jewish state for those expulsions. It was a myth and I appreciate when knowledgeable people bring the facts to bear, such as with this essay.

Melissa Brodsky's avatar

So crazy, I published something very similar the other day!

GARY B KATZ's avatar

Great minds think alike!

Nicholas Kannemeyer's avatar

Christians say “Give your life to Jesus - it’s the ultimate self-sacrifice” but i say “Give your life to Israel and the Jews” - a wider scope than Jesus (who WAS Jewish and Israeli and regarded himself as such - he called himself the Son of Man, not the Son of God; therefore he wanted to be known as Jewish).

I find Christians who give their life only to Jesus have not really made any sacrifice at all and it is not all that demanding. But people who give their life to Israel and the Jews… well it is A LOT more demanding and costly to one’s life and freedoms. You are constrained by identifying with Israel; isolated and set apart- you experience personal anti-semitic sympathy (…and i don’t mean sympathy) and exclusion and you are treated as an enemy of your pro-palestine society. I can’t walk down Princes Street in Edinburgh where i live, carrying the Israeli flag without risking my life (physical life and also how i am regarded by Scots) but I CAN walk down Princes Street in Edinburgh with a Palestinian flag and not be threatened by Scots (or Jews).

Giving your life to Israel and Jews is much more costly than Christians who consider giving their life to Jesus- costly because Jesus has been gentilised and is not regarded as an Israeli or a Jew. Yet Christians say it is costly and you would suffer persecution for what? - giving your life to Jesus in gentile Scotland? Definitely not! What persecution? I suffer persecution from none other than those same christians who favour Palestine over Israel and say God’s covenant with Israel and the Jews has been superseded by them!

The biggest fear of persecution and it mattering who you give your life to, is not on the account of Jesus, but on Israel and the Jews. Jesus said I came not but to the “lost sheep” of the house of…. ISRAEL;- not himself, and giving your life to Jesus means nothing without seeing Jesus not as the Son of God but as a Jew. This is the point. Giving your life to just Jesus means in Edinburgh that you are not making any sacrifice at all, because christians don’t see him as Jewish;- and i think that people who were persecuted for following Jesus did so not in divorce of the fact that he was a Jew and represented Judaism and Israel.

it is no sacrifice to give your life to Jesus in Scotland today but it is a sacrifice to stand with Israel.

This is what really giving your life to Jesus should mean in terms of cost. Scottish christians would totally disagree, but there is no sacrifice following them but they say otherwise. Jesus told us to ‘count the cost’. See Luke 14 28 - That only applies if you stand with Israel, not with the Scottish Church’s Jesus!

Nicholas Kannemeyer's avatar

There is a need for this note! Try showing it to Sky News Presenter Gillian Joseph who wears a Cross on air, and see her reaction. See if she agrees with me?!

Nicholas Kannemeyer's avatar

Anguel - i am RE-DEFINING THE BOUNDARIES between who follows God and who doesn’t (and it has nothing to do with what alignment people claim)

ryan's avatar

No one is an illegal immigrant in the United States of america. The very idea of calling someone illegal is racist. Unless that person is a Jew fleeing persecution to Ottoman ruled area now called "Palestine" or Mandate Palestine.....then only the Muslim can provide one with legality. to say otherwise is "racist." Palestine Muslim Arabic speaking identity today is pleasing to Allah. In fact Palestine is the highest ideal to which Humankind can aspire. Ask Macklemore. Jewish identity is "myth" and "racist." Just ask Jon and Mandy and beinart and moser and al sayed. I could go on.

John Webber's avatar

Excellent article. This explains why after the establishment of the modern state of Israel the P

‘’ Palestinian” spokespersons always referred to themselves being humiliated, not losing. Because under Islamic law Muslims could never live under the rule of a Jewish State.

That is the main reason for them to destroy it so they can go back to filing over Jews as the Koran demands.

The West has never woken up to this.

Now with this Myanmar ruling in the ICJ There will be no chance of any peace. Or 2 state solution. Hamas etc will do everthing they can to keep their people under horrible conditions blaming Isreal with the massive Qatari etc propaganda machine until the court they hope rules against Israel.

Giving the lead lawyer the Nobel peace prize now tells you everthing you need to know.

Then they hope the world will turn against Israel and leave them isolated.

Ed Miliband will be the first in line to call for Israel’s destruction along with Tucker Carlson and JDV

We need to start making this point and quickly in my opinion before it is too late.

Israel will not go down without a major fight which will have major consequences for the whole world.

The Jews have nowhere to go. That is now plainly obvious after October 7th.

Robin Bernhoft's avatar

A friend brought an English /Arabic Quran back after Desert Storm (1991). I thumbed through at random and found five verses commanding the reader to kill Jews and one to kill Christians. Nice holy book!

Nissan Ratzlav-Katz's avatar

Then there’s this inconvenient fact, which is worth noting even though it does relate to a time after the Zionist movement was already well established: there are more than a dozen Jewish communities in the land of Israel that were destroyed by Arabs before 1947. But not a single such Arab community.

vy's avatar

Epistle to Yemen - Maimonides

"Remember, my co-religionists, that on account of the vast number of our sins, God has hurled us in the midst of this people, the Arabs, who have persecuted us severely, and passed baneful and discriminatory legislation against us, as Scripture has forewarned us, "Our enemies themselves shall judge us" (Deuteronomy 32:31). Never did a nation molest, degrade, debase and hate us as much as they. "

GARY B KATZ's avatar

Then there's liars like Rashida Tlaib, claiming Arabs welcomed Jews fleeing Hitler to Palestine with bread.

Richard Baker's avatar

For me dhimmi status is Islamic serfdom which reduces all non-Moslems to an intentional 2nd-class position regardless of whether the local sheiks, rulers, or potentates apply it harshly or not. Islam demands you acquiese or death greets you. Finally, Islam is a cancer, to me, wherever it rears its bearded and turbaned head.

🎼HOMAYOON,Z🎗️👑's avatar

Calling systemic legal inferiority "peaceful coexistence" is a textbook exercise in historical gaslighting. The Cairo Genizah records, the 1679 Mawza Exile in Yemen, and the 1834 Safed pogrom prove that Jewish survival under Islamic rule was never a right—it was a fragile, revocable lease paid for through punitive *jizya* taxes and daily humiliation.

Even in Iran, where ancient Jewish roots predated Islam by over a millennium, the 1979 Islamic Revolution instantly revived medieval clerical supremacy and forced tens of thousands to flee. Zionism did not destroy an imaginary paradise; it ended centuries of defenselessness.

🎼HOMAYOON,Z🎗️👑's avatar

Romanticizing the *dhimmi* system as "peaceful coexistence" is one of modern academia’s most dishonest historical revisions. Conditional tolerance predicated on permanent legal inferiority, punitive *jizya* taxation, humiliating dress codes, and the constant threat of state-sanctioned pogroms is subjugation—not harmony.

From the 1834 Safed looting and the 1839 forced conversions of Mashhad’s Jews to the 1929 Hebron massacre and the 1941 Baghdad *Farhud*, anti-Jewish violence across the Middle East predated the State of Israel by centuries. Zionism did not shatter an imaginary golden age; it ended the era in which Jews had to beg for survival at the mercy of supremacist rulers.

Nicholas Kannemeyer's avatar

Anguel - The book of Esther could be the most important book in the Bible right now- because above any other book in it, it splits people into 2 distinct groups, irrespective of what alignment they claim. Those who follow God and those who don’t (the God of Israel). No other Book in the Bible does this, like the book of Esther, and it doesn’t matter if you are a practicing christian (as you see yourself) or not. It determines if you follow God or not. (There is only one!)