Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Susan Hirshorn's avatar

The Jewish world is having a hard enough time without members of our own people siding with the enemy against Israel. Yes, our people have a culture of being “argumentative”, but their ridiculous and dangerous words have become so extreme in light of Israel’s fight for survival that many people, including me, think the religious authority – the Beit Din – must step in and start issuing “excommunications”.

Throughout history, the reasons for excommunication have changed. Essentially, they changed from being crimes against G-d to crimes against the Jewish community. Now that Judaism is embodied again in an actual country, I think it is urgent for the Beit Din and the Israeli secular leaders – especially Bibi – to determine what kinds of public speech against Israel by a Jew constitutes treason and excommunicate individuals based on treason against Israel and/or Jewish communities in the Diaspora. (Their traitorous speeches affect us, too!)

During WW2 there were likely as many, if not more, citizens of Allied countries who were so frightened or confused they would have gladly spoken out against the Allies. Except they knew that if they did they’d soon be arrested as traitors. If that seems harsh, it wasn’t. Because if Hitler and the other Axis powers had won WW2 thanks to those “loose lips”, the Allied countries would not be here today (or not recognizable) and there certainly would be no Jews and no state of Israel.

Loose lips sink more than ships. They can destroy countries, cultures and civilizations. It’s time we deny “Jews In Name Only” the right to speak for Israel or for any Jew in the Diaspora. Traitors are traitors. We must call them what they are publicly so they have less value to our enemies.

Expand full comment
Diane Steiner's avatar

What's going on is precisely what you have identified and much, much more. With the biased, Jew hating news media, Jewish apologists, propagandized universities and schools, politics, and money, it is a multi-pronged problem to fight against. Please mention the antisemitism that is now found in hospitals in the US. There have been doctors, nurses in healthcare, and those fresh out of school who have said they wouldn't accept or take care of a Jewish patient, and even went so far to allude, that they would let them die. Nothing reported whether these specific people have been removed from healthcare and their licenses revoked. You can be sure of one thing, there are many more of them out there. It's becoming not only serious but extremely dangerous for Jews. I am hopeful this craziness will turn around and return to some form of sanity and common sense, but until then....Am Yisrael Chai!!!

Expand full comment
29 more comments...

No posts