You have my undying appreciation and respect together with the whole IDF for not only protecting Israel but the entire Jewish people. Ahm Yisrael chai.
Did some research on your assertion and Dr. Perlmutter in particular. First, in war, there will likely be some misdeeds by soldiers not sanctioned, in violation of rules of engagement by the army, and even more likely when civilians are purposely used as human shields in combat. Having stated this, I could not find a single case which was substantiated by an eyewitness account by this physician, with him quoting hearsay by "Palestinians" who may or may not be an arm of Hamas. The fact he is Jewish is irrelevant, and it being mentioned is another example of the use of his ethnicity as a de facto proof of his assertions. Every organization quoted, particularly MSF (Doctors without Borders) has an overt bias at best and is outright anti-Israel/antisemitic at worst. I don't doubt this volunteer was speaking with sincerity, but also do not doubt he was being used as a tool of a vicious regime who uses actors to spread their lies on the international stage as a chief strategy of propaganda to gain world sympathy against Israel, which is fighting a just war of self-defense. The unbiased NGO monitor released a 35 page report about the organization Dr. Perlmutter belongs outlining Doctors without Borders' multiple instances of anti-Israel misinformation and outrageously false claims of Israel committing Genocide in Gaza, a disgusting inversion of the Holocaust. He claims to be a Zionist but was uninterested in volunteering in Israel to help the multitude of Jewish wounded and maimed civilians from Hamas' purposeful attacks and Crimes against Humanity.
Thank you, LTD Nadav Shoshani! Both for your service to Israel and the entire western world and this insightful piece! 🇮🇱🫡 No army in the world is more humane than the IDF, nor is any army in the world more scrutinized, lied about, and vilified. The IDF is transparent, honest and accountable. Not to mention heroic and daring! It was they who defeated the Arabs on multiple occasions and saved Israel from destruction in 1948, 1956, 1967, and 1973. It was they who drove the PLO out of Lebanon in 1982. It was they who put down both the intifadas. It was they who destroyed Iraq’s nuclear facilities in 1981, Syria’s nuclear facilities in 2007 and Iran’s nuclear facilities a year ago. It was they who rescued Noa Argamani. It was they who defeated Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis in the Gaza War. It was they who protected millions of Palestinian civilians from death on the battlefield. It is they who treat Arab and Palestinian children in their hospitals and provide them free medical care. It is they who who rescued sick Palestinian children and brought them to Germany for treatment. It is they who rescued a old Palestinian woman who Hamas had handcuffed to a post to use as a human shield. It was they who killed Yahya Sinwar the modern day Adolph Eichmann and the architect of October 7th. It was they who killed Hamas chief Ismail Haniyeh.
Not an easy job in a world filled with propaganda.
I have always liked to listen to Jonathan Conricus the former IDF spokesman.
Even on "X" their algorithm sends me picture after picture of destroyed buildings in Gaza and how it is all Israel's fault.
I have a lot of Israeli favorite people I follow on "X" so Musk's company just throws The Left Wing/Muslim Propaganda at me as if that is what they think I want to see as if there is only one legitimate side in the Middle East and it isn't Israel.
I just ignore "X's" news feed any more. Imagine what MSN, CNN, Tik Tok or foreign news outlets are like.
And then the height of insults, a reporter for, of course, the New York Times, “wins” the Pulitzer Prize for reporting with the full regalia of Gazan suffering awarded by, who else, Columbia U. Stayed tuned for my expose of this fraudulent enterprise, the Pulitzer Prize.
Nadav, what really stood out to me was your point about social media becoming another battlefield. Israel may be winning military battles, but it often feels like it is losing the propaganda war badly, especially online. The other side understands emotional messaging, slogans, and viral narratives far better than Israel and its supporters do.
I also appreciated your emphasis on complexity and transparency. Most people consuming this conflict through TikTok clips and headlines have no understanding of how complicated urban warfare, hostages, human shields, or split-second military decisions actually are. Yet social media rewards certainty, outrage, and simplicity far more than nuance or facts.
And then, these insults and distortions are legitimate-sized by a reporter for, of course, the New York Times, who “wins” the Pulitzer Prize for reporting with the full regalia of Gazan suffering awarded by, who else, Columbia U. Stayed tuned for my expose of this fraudulent enterprise, the Pulitzer Prize.
As Robert E. Lee believed "Duty is the sublimest word in our language" or for that matter in any tongue. LTC Shoshani, your duty is to your family and country.
Thank you for your service. Despite all those points some journalists will never accept some truths that do not fit with their beliefs and ideologies about Israel.
You have my undying appreciation and respect together with the whole IDF for not only protecting Israel but the entire Jewish people. Ahm Yisrael chai.
Jewish Surgeon volunteered in Gaza 👇 describing evil deliberate actions by Israeli Soldiers
Did some research on your assertion and Dr. Perlmutter in particular. First, in war, there will likely be some misdeeds by soldiers not sanctioned, in violation of rules of engagement by the army, and even more likely when civilians are purposely used as human shields in combat. Having stated this, I could not find a single case which was substantiated by an eyewitness account by this physician, with him quoting hearsay by "Palestinians" who may or may not be an arm of Hamas. The fact he is Jewish is irrelevant, and it being mentioned is another example of the use of his ethnicity as a de facto proof of his assertions. Every organization quoted, particularly MSF (Doctors without Borders) has an overt bias at best and is outright anti-Israel/antisemitic at worst. I don't doubt this volunteer was speaking with sincerity, but also do not doubt he was being used as a tool of a vicious regime who uses actors to spread their lies on the international stage as a chief strategy of propaganda to gain world sympathy against Israel, which is fighting a just war of self-defense. The unbiased NGO monitor released a 35 page report about the organization Dr. Perlmutter belongs outlining Doctors without Borders' multiple instances of anti-Israel misinformation and outrageously false claims of Israel committing Genocide in Gaza, a disgusting inversion of the Holocaust. He claims to be a Zionist but was uninterested in volunteering in Israel to help the multitude of Jewish wounded and maimed civilians from Hamas' purposeful attacks and Crimes against Humanity.
https://themedialine.org/headlines/ngo-monitor-accuses-doctors-without-borders-of-promoting-anti-israel-genocide-claims/
Thank you, LTD Nadav Shoshani! Both for your service to Israel and the entire western world and this insightful piece! 🇮🇱🫡 No army in the world is more humane than the IDF, nor is any army in the world more scrutinized, lied about, and vilified. The IDF is transparent, honest and accountable. Not to mention heroic and daring! It was they who defeated the Arabs on multiple occasions and saved Israel from destruction in 1948, 1956, 1967, and 1973. It was they who drove the PLO out of Lebanon in 1982. It was they who put down both the intifadas. It was they who destroyed Iraq’s nuclear facilities in 1981, Syria’s nuclear facilities in 2007 and Iran’s nuclear facilities a year ago. It was they who rescued Noa Argamani. It was they who defeated Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis in the Gaza War. It was they who protected millions of Palestinian civilians from death on the battlefield. It is they who treat Arab and Palestinian children in their hospitals and provide them free medical care. It is they who who rescued sick Palestinian children and brought them to Germany for treatment. It is they who rescued a old Palestinian woman who Hamas had handcuffed to a post to use as a human shield. It was they who killed Yahya Sinwar the modern day Adolph Eichmann and the architect of October 7th. It was they who killed Hamas chief Ismail Haniyeh.
Beautifully written 💙
Not an easy job in a world filled with propaganda.
I have always liked to listen to Jonathan Conricus the former IDF spokesman.
Even on "X" their algorithm sends me picture after picture of destroyed buildings in Gaza and how it is all Israel's fault.
I have a lot of Israeli favorite people I follow on "X" so Musk's company just throws The Left Wing/Muslim Propaganda at me as if that is what they think I want to see as if there is only one legitimate side in the Middle East and it isn't Israel.
I just ignore "X's" news feed any more. Imagine what MSN, CNN, Tik Tok or foreign news outlets are like.
And then the height of insults, a reporter for, of course, the New York Times, “wins” the Pulitzer Prize for reporting with the full regalia of Gazan suffering awarded by, who else, Columbia U. Stayed tuned for my expose of this fraudulent enterprise, the Pulitzer Prize.
The New York Times is just pages of lies.
Columbia University is hopeless. Expensive with close minded "teachers and students."
The Pulitzer Prize recipients have been Woke for decades.
Three destroyed institutions with no credibility.
Firstly, thank you for sharing this. You’ve had a unique perspective when it comes to this war and I’m grateful you’ve shared it with us.
Second, thank you for your service. It’s not an easy position at all to be the spokesperson.
May Hashem bless you, your wife, and your 2 daughters with security and good health.
Nadav, what really stood out to me was your point about social media becoming another battlefield. Israel may be winning military battles, but it often feels like it is losing the propaganda war badly, especially online. The other side understands emotional messaging, slogans, and viral narratives far better than Israel and its supporters do.
I also appreciated your emphasis on complexity and transparency. Most people consuming this conflict through TikTok clips and headlines have no understanding of how complicated urban warfare, hostages, human shields, or split-second military decisions actually are. Yet social media rewards certainty, outrage, and simplicity far more than nuance or facts.
And then, these insults and distortions are legitimate-sized by a reporter for, of course, the New York Times, who “wins” the Pulitzer Prize for reporting with the full regalia of Gazan suffering awarded by, who else, Columbia U. Stayed tuned for my expose of this fraudulent enterprise, the Pulitzer Prize.
Expect the unexpected, this is what Israel is dealing with since 1948.
As Robert E. Lee believed "Duty is the sublimest word in our language" or for that matter in any tongue. LTC Shoshani, your duty is to your family and country.
Thank you for your service. Despite all those points some journalists will never accept some truths that do not fit with their beliefs and ideologies about Israel.
Here is one more lesson as if our 10’s of Billions that go to support this genocidal country are not enough for these MF Israeli Soldiers
Thank you so very much for your service. I am extremely grateful to the IDF and I admire each and every IDF soldier.
"holding onto the belief that, one day, our enemies will accept our existence and push forward for a better future"
Whenever I hear that I recall this article, only 10 days before Oct 7, to come back to reality:
https://www.timesofisrael.com/in-israeli-first-gazan-girl-receives-new-kind-of-pacemaker-in-innovative-procedure/
LTD Shoshani .. my heart goes out to you, and all fellow Israelis. Thank you.