In moments like these, I’m unbelievably proud to be of Israeli heritage. There is something uniquely special about this group of people. AM YISRAEL CHAI!! 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Rugged individualism is the only way to survive. It entails being prepared, knowing that evil exists and is ever present, and the courage to destroy it when it appears. This is the mindset of heroes. 🇮🇱🇺🇸
Brilliant. Thank you for sharing this important, thoughtful piece. I will share it with members of the Jewish community in Canada 🍁 in the hope that it sparks meaningful discussion and inspires more people to speak up and take action.
The heroes on the plane fought back. The MIT professor fought back. The vast majority of American Jewish leaders, and probably American Jews as well, WON'T fight back. They are too worried about looking like evil white oppressors, too concerned their Marxist betters won't like them anymore (not that they ever did) and won't invite them to parties where puffed-up stuffed-shirt buffoons prattle on about hating Trump and loving Socialism which is to be applied to everyone but them. Our Jewish brethren are too worried about looking like...JEWS.
We have let the Left, the Marxists, the Islamofascists, all of them Jew-haters, completely control the narrative. That must stop. Make the Jew-haters declare themselves, and let their cognitive dissonance destroy them: they cannot be the good and wonderful people they see in the mirror and hate Jews. Out them as the pathetic Jew-hating racist LOSERS they really are.
It is time for the United States and Israel to put a stop to this radicalization, both Leftist and Islamic. With respect to the latter, we KNOW who the leaders are, wallowing in luxury in Oman and Qatar and probably still in Tehran as well, and also the insane Twelfth-Madhi Imans. These monsters send others to their deaths with a click of the keyboard or wave of the hand at the pulpit while their own families live the life of Riley. They need to meet the same end they urge upon their followers. Maybe rigged iPhones instead of pagers would do the trick. Suddenly this path wouldn't be so attractive. Those who fund marches, Soros and the other Marxism-for-the-but-not-for-me momzers need the same treatment. There has to be a price for fomenting Jew-hatred. Right now, there is nothing of the sort.
THIS HAS TO STOP, and only a government-level program can do it. But we need to show that we are worthy, that we will stand up for ourselves. Any other minority subject to this sort of persecution would be applauded for doing so.
You say "...only a government-level program can do it."
But that is exactly what we cannot depend on.
Those who have organized themselves at MIT did not wait for the US government to sanction MIT for its failure to act to protect Jewish staff and students.
This essay is all about how they undertook and still are undertaking numerous actions behalf of themselves and other Jews.
Exactly. Here in Europe we have done the same to the Nazis who had infiltrated MI6 and The British State. This is work, involving both Jews and Non-Jews and spanning over 80 years, which has been and continues to be very successful. The Nazis have been stopped, to the benefit of all who need and love Freedom, which is everyone, from intimidation, terror and Genocidal mass murder which these Nazis had planned.
I made Aliyah a year ago, and living in Israel taught me some really interesting things.
Almost the whole world boycotts Israel. I'm including many people and businesses in countries that don't technically boycott Israel but its citizens can do as they wish. It is extremely difficult to source anything you need. You go into Israel's stores and most of what you see is crap, the worst stuff that the world's vendors couldn't sell so they sell it in Israel. Which means a lot of things you buy (for a premium, because that's part of it) don't fricking work, or they scarcely work.
You can tell when a shipping container has come in, like every four months or so, because suddenly you can find things in stores that you couldn't find anywhere.
This has been going on for so long that Israelis grow up with a mentality where they expect to improvise or make do.
Like when I moved into my apartment and the Russian movers couldn't hook up the clothes washer because they couldn't get parts. The landlord called his buddy, a retired hydroengineer who had been quite a big shot, and the buddy set things up with ill-fitting gaskets and duct tape. A few months later, it spewed water all over the floor. Same thing, same guy, a different gasket and duct tape. But now I can wash clothes without water all over the floor. The pipes spew sewer gases and that's also part of living in Israel; fixes are by the seat of the pants and provisional and they kinda sorta work, enough so you can function, just not perfectly, but amazingly well for what was on hand. No parts? No problem, we have duct tape.
So we hear that the guy who saved the flight from its nosedive is a plumber. Well, he improvised. He probably has to improvise every day of his working life.
Israelis just put their heads down and figure out how to solve the problem, damn the torpedoes.
Well said. We Americans are so spoiled and lazy and happy to outsource our security. If you see a backpack lying on the sidewalk near your Shul or JCC do you report it immediately? If a lone terrorist enters your congregation with a knife and starts yelling "Allah Akbar" do you rally others to confront him en masse with folding chairs or run away and leave him to stab an elderly impaired congregant?? We ALL need to be brave and resilient and protect each other..
Powerlessness, as I see it, may limit responsibility for what one can do. Agency expands responsibility precisely because one can now choose.
And it is my current understanding that, at its historical core, Zionism can be understood as a demand for Jewish agency: the possibility for Jews to become authors rather than merely objects of their collective fate.
But once political agency is achieved, the Jewish question does not disappear.
It changes.
The question becomes what Jews do with that agency—and how Jewish self-determination is reconciled with the agency, rights and humanity of others.
And that takes us somewhere much more interesting than the usual argument over whether someone is “a Zionist” or “anti-Zionist.”
It also leaves room for the uncomfortable but important possibility that one can affirm the underlying principle of Jewish agency while arguing fiercely about what constitutes its just social and political expression.
When we can have a situation in Israel that does not see the necessity for preparing to defend ourselves on any given day, seemingly perpetually, we can start thinking about the just social and political expression of Jewish agency.
American Jews, especially the nebbish Jews in the Democrat party have so much to learn and emulate from the Israelis. Israelis fight off terrorists whether aboard a plane or confront them inside tunnels. American Jewish democrat politicians can't even muster enough courage to confront and condemn the antisemitic radicals inside their own party.
A blessed people. Their actions on that plane made them super Jews
In moments like these, I’m unbelievably proud to be of Israeli heritage. There is something uniquely special about this group of people. AM YISRAEL CHAI!! 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
The left of center American Jewish leadership is shaming itself and our entire people.
There are a great many of us who feel the same about the British Jewish Leadership.
Rugged individualism is the only way to survive. It entails being prepared, knowing that evil exists and is ever present, and the courage to destroy it when it appears. This is the mindset of heroes. 🇮🇱🇺🇸
Brilliant. Thank you for sharing this important, thoughtful piece. I will share it with members of the Jewish community in Canada 🍁 in the hope that it sparks meaningful discussion and inspires more people to speak up and take action.
The heroes on the plane fought back. The MIT professor fought back. The vast majority of American Jewish leaders, and probably American Jews as well, WON'T fight back. They are too worried about looking like evil white oppressors, too concerned their Marxist betters won't like them anymore (not that they ever did) and won't invite them to parties where puffed-up stuffed-shirt buffoons prattle on about hating Trump and loving Socialism which is to be applied to everyone but them. Our Jewish brethren are too worried about looking like...JEWS.
We have let the Left, the Marxists, the Islamofascists, all of them Jew-haters, completely control the narrative. That must stop. Make the Jew-haters declare themselves, and let their cognitive dissonance destroy them: they cannot be the good and wonderful people they see in the mirror and hate Jews. Out them as the pathetic Jew-hating racist LOSERS they really are.
It is time for the United States and Israel to put a stop to this radicalization, both Leftist and Islamic. With respect to the latter, we KNOW who the leaders are, wallowing in luxury in Oman and Qatar and probably still in Tehran as well, and also the insane Twelfth-Madhi Imans. These monsters send others to their deaths with a click of the keyboard or wave of the hand at the pulpit while their own families live the life of Riley. They need to meet the same end they urge upon their followers. Maybe rigged iPhones instead of pagers would do the trick. Suddenly this path wouldn't be so attractive. Those who fund marches, Soros and the other Marxism-for-the-but-not-for-me momzers need the same treatment. There has to be a price for fomenting Jew-hatred. Right now, there is nothing of the sort.
THIS HAS TO STOP, and only a government-level program can do it. But we need to show that we are worthy, that we will stand up for ourselves. Any other minority subject to this sort of persecution would be applauded for doing so.
You say "...only a government-level program can do it."
But that is exactly what we cannot depend on.
Those who have organized themselves at MIT did not wait for the US government to sanction MIT for its failure to act to protect Jewish staff and students.
This essay is all about how they undertook and still are undertaking numerous actions behalf of themselves and other Jews.
Exactly. Here in Europe we have done the same to the Nazis who had infiltrated MI6 and The British State. This is work, involving both Jews and Non-Jews and spanning over 80 years, which has been and continues to be very successful. The Nazis have been stopped, to the benefit of all who need and love Freedom, which is everyone, from intimidation, terror and Genocidal mass murder which these Nazis had planned.
I made Aliyah a year ago, and living in Israel taught me some really interesting things.
Almost the whole world boycotts Israel. I'm including many people and businesses in countries that don't technically boycott Israel but its citizens can do as they wish. It is extremely difficult to source anything you need. You go into Israel's stores and most of what you see is crap, the worst stuff that the world's vendors couldn't sell so they sell it in Israel. Which means a lot of things you buy (for a premium, because that's part of it) don't fricking work, or they scarcely work.
You can tell when a shipping container has come in, like every four months or so, because suddenly you can find things in stores that you couldn't find anywhere.
This has been going on for so long that Israelis grow up with a mentality where they expect to improvise or make do.
Like when I moved into my apartment and the Russian movers couldn't hook up the clothes washer because they couldn't get parts. The landlord called his buddy, a retired hydroengineer who had been quite a big shot, and the buddy set things up with ill-fitting gaskets and duct tape. A few months later, it spewed water all over the floor. Same thing, same guy, a different gasket and duct tape. But now I can wash clothes without water all over the floor. The pipes spew sewer gases and that's also part of living in Israel; fixes are by the seat of the pants and provisional and they kinda sorta work, enough so you can function, just not perfectly, but amazingly well for what was on hand. No parts? No problem, we have duct tape.
So we hear that the guy who saved the flight from its nosedive is a plumber. Well, he improvised. He probably has to improvise every day of his working life.
Israelis just put their heads down and figure out how to solve the problem, damn the torpedoes.
Many major American hi-tech companies operate in Israel.
🇮🇱👍AM ISRAEL CHAI‼️🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🌈💕🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🇮🇱
Well said. We Americans are so spoiled and lazy and happy to outsource our security. If you see a backpack lying on the sidewalk near your Shul or JCC do you report it immediately? If a lone terrorist enters your congregation with a knife and starts yelling "Allah Akbar" do you rally others to confront him en masse with folding chairs or run away and leave him to stab an elderly impaired congregant?? We ALL need to be brave and resilient and protect each other..
You had me at “Jews refusing to outsource our fate”!
Oh heavens.
This is brilliant ,such a tonic to read.
And really a generic template isn't it?
Only Israelis could have done what the passengers did on Wednesday.
And that degree of personal and collective power TERRIFIES the evil.elites and their progressive ciphers and sock puppets and sick bags
So we need to absorb that ,then regroup a la Sheffi.
Thanks for the Israeli blueprint! As opposed to the western cult of toadies ....sadly ,some of them being Jewish.
But never Israeli....that's now a special.term if honour to a watching ,awestruck world.
As if the pagers were simply a fluke eh? 😃
Thanks for this.
Powerlessness, as I see it, may limit responsibility for what one can do. Agency expands responsibility precisely because one can now choose.
And it is my current understanding that, at its historical core, Zionism can be understood as a demand for Jewish agency: the possibility for Jews to become authors rather than merely objects of their collective fate.
But once political agency is achieved, the Jewish question does not disappear.
It changes.
The question becomes what Jews do with that agency—and how Jewish self-determination is reconciled with the agency, rights and humanity of others.
And that takes us somewhere much more interesting than the usual argument over whether someone is “a Zionist” or “anti-Zionist.”
It also leaves room for the uncomfortable but important possibility that one can affirm the underlying principle of Jewish agency while arguing fiercely about what constitutes its just social and political expression.
When we can have a situation in Israel that does not see the necessity for preparing to defend ourselves on any given day, seemingly perpetually, we can start thinking about the just social and political expression of Jewish agency.
Amen brother
courageous people
American Jews, especially the nebbish Jews in the Democrat party have so much to learn and emulate from the Israelis. Israelis fight off terrorists whether aboard a plane or confront them inside tunnels. American Jewish democrat politicians can't even muster enough courage to confront and condemn the antisemitic radicals inside their own party.