The Black-Jewish alliance did not collapse simply because of disagreements over Israel. Its foundations were destroyed by a worldview that made race the measure of everything.
Beautifully written, and so informative. Thank you for the education. I've thought for a while that antiracism has been essentialized. While antisemitism is the oldest enduring racist form of hate, the fact that Jews and Jewish Israelis are now considered 'white' makes it easier to vilify Zionism and scapegoat Israel in the Middle Eastern conflict, for lack of a better way to refer to everything that has happened since the founding of the modern state in the historical homeland of the Jewish people. In Nazi Germany, Ashkenazi Jews were certainly not considered part of the "Aryan race," and I'm certain that it would also be easy to find references in government immigration and academic institutions' policy to the "Jewish race" which barred entry to other Western countries and enforced quotas for decades.
Towards the end of his life, Malcolm X was changing his mind about how black people in the USA should respond to the discrimination against them. He was moving away from the approach of the Nation of Islam and distancing himself from its dictatorial approach to black organizing. That is why he was assassinated: to stop him from causing others to leave the Nation of Islam and its categorical "whites are the devil" teachings.
I read Lewis’ essay a few weeks ago, so forgive me if she mentions him, but Eldridge Cleaver, too. He fled America for Algeria, only to discover that Arabs are probably the most racist people on earth. He came back to America and pretty much disavowed his former self. For the rest of his life, he was a friend to Jews and Israel.
One of the attractions of antisemitism is that it gives a minority something in common with more powerful majorities. They can unite with the powerful with a shared hatred, with the superior veneer of the justification of their own sufferings. And nothing is more respectable and safer than antisemitism.
"that Black and Jewish Americans see each other as rivals in a hierarchy of victimhood . . .
So how do we shift the tide?
First, tell the truth about where we went wrong. Americans must honestly examine where intellectuals and activists went horribly wrong."
They went wrong when they bought into Critical Race Theory that then eased the way into the Red-Green alliance through the canard of Intersectionality, which is not nearly so much of alliance of grievances but rather fundamentally operates on the atavistic principle "The enemy of my enemy is my friend."
Oprah and Michelle Obama are twin disappointments who used to stand for all women. They have reversed course and have angered me every day they are silent.
Replacing Martin Luther King Jr.’s humanist vision—judging individuals by character rather than skin color—with "comparative victimology" turned civil rights allies into competitors in a zero-sum hierarchy of suffering. Once modern "anti-racism" redefined prejudice to exclude anyone labeled "white" or "successful," it effectively granted ideological amnesty to antisemitism—even erasing the history of over 850,000 Mizrahi, Sephardic, and Ethiopian Jews expelled from Middle Eastern and African lands. Rebuilding genuine solidarity requires abandoning racial essentialism and returning to the simple moral truth that every human being carries inherent dignity. 🕯️🤝
Look everything that you wrote is probably true. Jewish Americans have always tended to be very very liberal and always marched alongside the so-called underserved and So called marginalized people. Every one of those groups and identities has turned against the Jews. Most notably of course are as you noted Black Americans
Thank you, Tiffany, for telling this history so plainly — the 1975 declaration Rosa Parks and Bayard Rustin signed, and the Heschel-King partnership at Selma, show what the alliance was built on: shared human dignity, not shared grievance. Your point that more than half of Israel's Jews are Mizrahi and Sephardic cuts through the 'white colonizer' story entirely. The humanist vision you describe is the one worth fighting for, and I hope we can keep rebuilding that friendship on it.
I think a big piece that’s missing from this is Farrakhan and the NOI. When Jews were finally allowed to leave the cities and move to certain suburbs, the disconnect between black and Jewish Americans really started. And then Farrakhan came in and did a lot of public outreach within the black communities while spreading antisemitism.
"The Black Power movement exploited that gap. It preached separatism and Pan-Africanism." Shades of Marcus Garvey on the African gig. The article spoke of “comparative victimology" which, in my mind, has infected the black community to the point that now there is the phenomenon of "black fatigue" among many in the white community who have become numb to their so-called "claims" because this all sounds like Aesop's story of the boy crying wolf. Finally, this game of being "anti-Zionist" obscures the fact that Zionism, as I understand it, was about creating a Jewish homeland so Jews could run their own society without having to figuratively kowtow to the authorities and people of the country in which they resided. Herzl was the originator of political Zionism which eventually took root in now-Éretz Yisra'él.
I disagree. The cause of the black/Jewish split was not race. It was religion.
In the early 1970s, blacks were at the apex of their social power. They felt they no longer needed Jewish support and expertise, besides being uncomfortable with the depth of their debt to the Jews (let's face it: without smart Jewish lawyers Dr. King would have disappeared into the American penal system the same way Mandela did into the South African one; blacks would still be sitting at the back of the bus). At that point, given the choice between siding with the Jews in the majority-minority battle and the Christians and Muslims in the gentile-Jew controversy, rhey chose to go with the gentiles..
In the final analysis, American blacks are just another cadre of antisemitic gentiles. Under attack from white racists? To paraphrase Whoopi Goldberg, it's just gentile-on-gentile violence; no concern of ours. As for free legal assistance like 60 years ago, I suggest they ask the Muslims.
Shared grievance does not make a stable friendship. Something Jews the world over should know by now.
Only shared values can lead to stable friendships.
Bravo, Tiffany Lewis! We need many more voices like hers, willing to talk facts, truth and humanism!
Beautifully written, and so informative. Thank you for the education. I've thought for a while that antiracism has been essentialized. While antisemitism is the oldest enduring racist form of hate, the fact that Jews and Jewish Israelis are now considered 'white' makes it easier to vilify Zionism and scapegoat Israel in the Middle Eastern conflict, for lack of a better way to refer to everything that has happened since the founding of the modern state in the historical homeland of the Jewish people. In Nazi Germany, Ashkenazi Jews were certainly not considered part of the "Aryan race," and I'm certain that it would also be easy to find references in government immigration and academic institutions' policy to the "Jewish race" which barred entry to other Western countries and enforced quotas for decades.
Towards the end of his life, Malcolm X was changing his mind about how black people in the USA should respond to the discrimination against them. He was moving away from the approach of the Nation of Islam and distancing himself from its dictatorial approach to black organizing. That is why he was assassinated: to stop him from causing others to leave the Nation of Islam and its categorical "whites are the devil" teachings.
I read Lewis’ essay a few weeks ago, so forgive me if she mentions him, but Eldridge Cleaver, too. He fled America for Algeria, only to discover that Arabs are probably the most racist people on earth. He came back to America and pretty much disavowed his former self. For the rest of his life, he was a friend to Jews and Israel.
One of the attractions of antisemitism is that it gives a minority something in common with more powerful majorities. They can unite with the powerful with a shared hatred, with the superior veneer of the justification of their own sufferings. And nothing is more respectable and safer than antisemitism.
❤️🩹
"that Black and Jewish Americans see each other as rivals in a hierarchy of victimhood . . .
So how do we shift the tide?
First, tell the truth about where we went wrong. Americans must honestly examine where intellectuals and activists went horribly wrong."
They went wrong when they bought into Critical Race Theory that then eased the way into the Red-Green alliance through the canard of Intersectionality, which is not nearly so much of alliance of grievances but rather fundamentally operates on the atavistic principle "The enemy of my enemy is my friend."
Don’t forget that the Selma film 2014 with one of the producers #OprahWinfrey completely erased Jews from this history.
Oprah and Michelle Obama are twin disappointments who used to stand for all women. They have reversed course and have angered me every day they are silent.
Those two black women who America have made uber wealthy also hate America.
Replacing Martin Luther King Jr.’s humanist vision—judging individuals by character rather than skin color—with "comparative victimology" turned civil rights allies into competitors in a zero-sum hierarchy of suffering. Once modern "anti-racism" redefined prejudice to exclude anyone labeled "white" or "successful," it effectively granted ideological amnesty to antisemitism—even erasing the history of over 850,000 Mizrahi, Sephardic, and Ethiopian Jews expelled from Middle Eastern and African lands. Rebuilding genuine solidarity requires abandoning racial essentialism and returning to the simple moral truth that every human being carries inherent dignity. 🕯️🤝
Look everything that you wrote is probably true. Jewish Americans have always tended to be very very liberal and always marched alongside the so-called underserved and So called marginalized people. Every one of those groups and identities has turned against the Jews. Most notably of course are as you noted Black Americans
Thank you, Tiffany, for telling this history so plainly — the 1975 declaration Rosa Parks and Bayard Rustin signed, and the Heschel-King partnership at Selma, show what the alliance was built on: shared human dignity, not shared grievance. Your point that more than half of Israel's Jews are Mizrahi and Sephardic cuts through the 'white colonizer' story entirely. The humanist vision you describe is the one worth fighting for, and I hope we can keep rebuilding that friendship on it.
I think a big piece that’s missing from this is Farrakhan and the NOI. When Jews were finally allowed to leave the cities and move to certain suburbs, the disconnect between black and Jewish Americans really started. And then Farrakhan came in and did a lot of public outreach within the black communities while spreading antisemitism.
By 1969, the Black Panthers and Stokely Carmichael with the cheers of SDS, the predecessors of DSA
"The Black Power movement exploited that gap. It preached separatism and Pan-Africanism." Shades of Marcus Garvey on the African gig. The article spoke of “comparative victimology" which, in my mind, has infected the black community to the point that now there is the phenomenon of "black fatigue" among many in the white community who have become numb to their so-called "claims" because this all sounds like Aesop's story of the boy crying wolf. Finally, this game of being "anti-Zionist" obscures the fact that Zionism, as I understand it, was about creating a Jewish homeland so Jews could run their own society without having to figuratively kowtow to the authorities and people of the country in which they resided. Herzl was the originator of political Zionism which eventually took root in now-Éretz Yisra'él.
Israel is guilty of genocide
I disagree. The cause of the black/Jewish split was not race. It was religion.
In the early 1970s, blacks were at the apex of their social power. They felt they no longer needed Jewish support and expertise, besides being uncomfortable with the depth of their debt to the Jews (let's face it: without smart Jewish lawyers Dr. King would have disappeared into the American penal system the same way Mandela did into the South African one; blacks would still be sitting at the back of the bus). At that point, given the choice between siding with the Jews in the majority-minority battle and the Christians and Muslims in the gentile-Jew controversy, rhey chose to go with the gentiles..
In the final analysis, American blacks are just another cadre of antisemitic gentiles. Under attack from white racists? To paraphrase Whoopi Goldberg, it's just gentile-on-gentile violence; no concern of ours. As for free legal assistance like 60 years ago, I suggest they ask the Muslims.