Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Marcia Kupfer's avatar

Bravo! One correction: the family that owns the NYT today is Episcopalian. The Sulzberger family had a Jewish origin and may still have Jewish branches or ties, but the descendants who own the NYT are not Jewish.

Dina Kim's avatar

Thank you for the post and all of the historical references. Two points: First, there’s no such thing as a Palestinian. Especially as it has erroneously been selectively used for the last 50+ years. Each time it is now used, it continues a false narrative. Like saying ’New England’ in the USA, Palestine, named after the ancient Philistines, was filled with Jewish people, who pre-dated Muslims in the area, Christians, and a mix of Middle Eastern Muslims, plus others. It didn’t “belong” to Muslims. Jews, therefore were/are Palestinians,’ too, as are all the others who were there. Palestinian doesn’t mean Muslim, only. The Egyptian Arafat hijacked the name Palestinian to begin a war campaign to remove Jews from Israel. Nowhere in the Middle East is the former casually termed Palestine better represented than in Israel because Israelis today are also Jews, Muslims, Christians, and more, just as the area was before Israel’s statehood. Second, those who are so anti-Zionist don’t complain that Middle Eastern Muslims, for religious and supposedly historical reasons believe they should dominate and control the ENTIRE Middle East, not one state, only. If the term Zionism exists for the Jewish people, what is the term that equally describes Muslims who think they should have the entire Middle East and beyond to run as Muslim nations? The fact that nobody in Israel has come up with a term for that and constantly talks about it to point out the enormous hypocrisy is stunning to me.. Thank you again for your post.

8 more comments...

Ready for more?