45 Comments
User's avatar
Dana Ramos's avatar

I think you are spot on about Bibi. I realized it just days after the massacre; one of the cable networks was interviewing him remotely (I think it was CNN), and the show host (I dare not call them journalists) asked (paraphrasing), "Do you think the peace accords you were about to sign with Saudi Arabia, and other countries, is out of the question now?" Bibi gave a little smile and said, "To the contrary. When this war is over, peace will be more ripe than ever before." I thought to myself, "He has a big plan all laid out, doesn't he?" Then he gave a speech over a year ago at the United Nations where he described "the Dream" for the Middle East that would bring peace and prosperity for all. All part of the Big Plan. He's been brilliant at navigating the Biden Presidency and now Trump, and he's now sooooo close to the full realization of the New Middle East and he's got Trump wanting to be part of that success (and take credit for it). It's going to happen.

Expand full comment
Richard Hacker's avatar

I agree that the PM is a wily politician; but let's not get to far ahead of ourselves here. This is all secondary to the task at hand. Whenever the world wants to start cutting some slack for Hamas, they do something to reinforce the goal of their complete obliteration. As I write this comment, I just read on "Israel Realtime" that there has been an attack on IDF troops in northern Gaza resulting in deaths and injuries. They will never stop. They must be crushed once and for all. Total annihilation in biblical proportions. Only then will the goals of this conflict be served.

Expand full comment
Shirley Friedman's avatar

Hey Guys

While you’re all running around weighing and debating the self-congratulations, you’re distracted from the greater and growing danger. It’s not any of the 4 H proxies, which all lie contained and in various states of tatters. It’s not in the real achievement of an expanding and sincere Abraham Accords, hopefully destined to be something greater than The UN 2.0. It’s not even the nuclear material Iran may or may not still have lying buried in its bunkers. It’s the tiny, irrational, but hardly irrelevant, time bombs that have been successfully secreted into the minds (if you can call it that) of the campus minions sprinkled around the globe. You’ve got little to celebrate until you figure out how to round up and root out those millions of insidious, infectious roaches. (And here you thought exploding Hezbollah pagers were a neat trick!)

Expand full comment
Shirley Friedman's avatar

PS - I just saw the Dead Sea Scrolls at the Reagan Library. How come they haven’t done much to evidence Jewish priority and primacy in the Holy Land?

Expand full comment
Before's avatar

That is a personal challenge for every Jew around the world.

Expand full comment
Jeremy Nathan Brown's avatar

My heart bleeds every time an IDF soldier falls in Gaza, but I appreciate the complexity of war. If Netanyahu can pull off the hostages coming home alive and Hamas removed from power, I will rejoice.

Expand full comment
Jonathan Goldberg KC's avatar

I agree this is a third rate article. Nothing new to see here whatever, just more flattery. I happen to agree that Bibi plays his cards brilliantly but you could have said that in two lines.

Expand full comment
Marty Oestreicher's avatar

A bit premature. How is it helpful to imply that Bibi will runs rings around President Trump? This only confirms the suspicions of the anti-Israel chorus. It will be a shame if this site turns into a Bibi propaganda vehicle with paeans like this.

Expand full comment
Jeremy Nathan Brown's avatar

I am not up for Bibi propaganda either .. but give the man credit, even if so many suffer with NDS.. Netanyahu Derangement Syndrome, the moment his name is mentioned.

He was Israel’s PM on October 7 2023, and yes, it happened on his watch. But the turnaround by the IDF since then, with the décapitation of Hezbollah, the fall of Assad, the smiting of Iran, must be credit, where credit is due.

Bibi remains Israel’s PM & with the Israeli military, and help of the USA, has achieved remarkable success so far.

Expand full comment
David Mandel's avatar

We seem to have had the same thought at the same moment.

Expand full comment
Laura's avatar

The anti-Israel chorus will believe in their wild antisemitic conspiracy theories regardless. Who gives a shit what they say.

What is your problem with Bibi? Israel is lucky he's the PM.

Expand full comment
Miriamnae's avatar

Supper at the White House between effusive Trump and experienced Netanyahu should include details over flan of the golden resort needed on the Gaza Strip which is now filth and death. Silly me? Emotive Trump sending jets over with a flourish of kisses and Netanyahu strategically killing leaders in precision strikes was a very well planned maneuver together which has now resulted in Syria leaving China and Russia and moving toward Israel and America. I read somewhere today that several Arab leaders are asking now to sign onto the Abraham accords and are openly stating they do not want any ‘Palestinian’ partition. No one wants those murderers and this mideastern change took both Israel and America. It is amazing watching Trump and Netanyahu, totally different personalities, becoming one man in this war. Which is actually more than a few prophecies in the Tanahk. Isaiah 11 is pretty eye opening. Zephaniah. Ezekiel 37…Keep writing, Josh.

Expand full comment
Before's avatar

Move the UN General Assembly to Gaza. That will be a major redeployment project and give the Gazans something to do. Imagine the ambassadors and their limousines looking for a decent lunch?

Keep the Security Council and the Veto in NY.

Expand full comment
Miriamnae's avatar

lol…yes! The UN and Red Cross HQ…

Expand full comment
Before's avatar

Yes, the height of irony putting the Red Cross HQ in Gaza after their abandonment of the hostages.

Where is the Red Crescent HQ?

Expand full comment
Inna's avatar

I like that you wrote except Keep writing Josh- he disappointed with that bold (ridiculously bold ) flattery of Bibi.

Expand full comment
Steven Brizel's avatar

Let’s see what happened today

Expand full comment
David Mandel's avatar

Well, if no one in the Trump Administration reads FOJ today, I guess it'll be alright.

Expand full comment
Inna's avatar

I am sure they do not know much about this blog where we can find this idiotic flattery of Bibi. And I have respect for Bibi, always have. Next time I will skip his writings

Expand full comment
Mary Sholl's avatar

This is a remarkably dumb analysis. Showdown, huh? Delusional and stupid.

Expand full comment
Before's avatar

Sounds like Hamas disinformation funded by Al Jazeera.

Expand full comment
Craig James's avatar

Please share with us your analysis, Mary.

Expand full comment
david miller's avatar

You're usually spot on. But this time you're a tad over the top - or maybe more so. Bibi is no strategic genius, but he is a tactical one!

Expand full comment
Menachem Hamberger's avatar

Why publish this before Bibi has run rings around Trump? Totally stupid timing, IMHO.

Expand full comment
Before's avatar

Hamas disinformation funded by Qatar.

Expand full comment
Katherine Augustson's avatar

To me Netanyahu is a HERO beyond all I’m capable of putting into words! The thing that grinds me the most about all the “armchair commentators” giving their opinions about Israel’s massive struggles being bombarded on all sides by constant wars from all over the entire world who don’t even live in Israel who’s fighting for their very existence! I’m a Jew who was raised here in America longing to just go home where I belong but unable to do so. I cannot even begin to imagine hearing warning sirens to take shelter all hours of the day or night everyday that God sends! I could write a book on this very subject but instead I’ll ask you “opinionated armchair critics” one question: Has anyone of you even given it a single thought of the weight on Netanyahu’s shoulders or horror what the nation of Israel’s citizen’s have suffered day in and day out of the losses of the families of the hostages or the horror the hostages are suffering?

So, the next time you throw out your meaningless “OPINIONS” with your fingers think about how much more suffering you’re causing on those who are living in this war a thousand miles away from Israel!

Expand full comment
Henry Tobias's avatar

Bibi should have resigned on 8 October 2023. As much as he accepts the praise, he MUST accept the responsibility as he had been prime minister for most of the last 15 years before 7 October 2023. He MUST accept the blame - and he refuses to do so. Israel urgently needed and still urgently needs a state commission of enquiry to investigate the events that led to the tragedy of 7 October 2023 and new elections. Those responsible must be held to account and Bibi as prime minister bears MOST responsibility. Bibi has done some good things for Israel, but that doesn't excuse his guilt in the events that led up to the tragedy on 7 October 2023. He and his acolytes are also trying to destroy Israeli democracy by weakening the Supreme Court. As much as I don't always agree with the Supreme Court, I do NOT trust the politicians. In a poll before 7 October 2023, Israelis trusted the politicians LESS than the Supreme Court.

Your unconditional praise for Bibi is out of place in view of the tragedy of 7 October 2023.

I am cancelling my subscription to the Future of Jewish emails. I am very disappointed in this whitewash of Netanyahu.

He is definitely NOT one of the greatest politicians of our time.

The cemeteries are full of indispensable people, especially politicians.

Expand full comment
Ron Heller's avatar

This article does not do any good for the relationship between Israel & the USA upon whom Israel depends for support. Trump has a large ego and if this article comes to his attention I dont think this will be beneficial for his support or goodwill. Future of Jewish articles are interesting & informative. However I dont know what Joshua was thinking when he insults Trump several times in this article. Is Joshua a latent antisemite or just stupid!

Expand full comment
DEMedia is Propaganda's avatar

Netanyahu Is the greatest world leader since the American founders. There are others that have been great but have not had to deal with as much as Netanyahu has internally or externally

He is far more than a mere politician . A true leader.

Trump2 is insanely corrupt and bribed by 5 Muslim Nations in addition to Musk. The most of any elected official in history.

These WH meetings often don't reveal much. They typically staged.

What the two discuss in private is unknown. Spontaneous substance Like Trump going off the rails with Zelensky is rare. Trump will need to apologize for that. Trump must be legally executed for Treason (Qatar and Saudis) so he should make up publicly with Zelensky. Trump has already said he is sending more arms to Ukraine.

Expand full comment