Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Anne On's avatar

I think I need to use this strategy for my older friends.

Expand full comment
A. Kvetch's avatar

Very Interesting points, thanks.

I would also argue that the pro-Israel community needs to produce many more, mainstream, high quality, children's (and youth) books focusing on this topic. I mean DK-style (https://www.dk.com/) factual books laying things out clearly and graphically.

Some of the discussions you recommend above need to be supported with better underlying materials.

See a similar point being made in a letter to the JC from a few years ago (https://www.thejc.com/opinion/letters/letters-to-the-editor-september-22-2023-ww20z6g2):

"Among the significant number of children’s books published in the UK (particularly those focused on history, the ancient world, mythology, inspiring real-world characters, etc). it is noticeable how almost all Jewish characters or stories have been excised or obscured (other than the ever-present, token, reference to Anne Frank).

The Jewish people were sovereign in the Land of Israel for over 1,300 years (from 1258 BCE to 70 CE), each of the Temples stood for centuries, and our history (both in the Holy Land and elsewhere) is fascinating and complex. But I challenge anyone to find current mainstream children’s books focusing on any of these topics. There are countless books about the ancient Egyptians, Greeks, Romans, and other peoples, but none I am aware of about Ancient Israel.

There are scores of books about ancient travellers and explorers, but barely a mention of Benjamin of Tudela and numerous other Jewish travellers. There is a strong focus on women pioneers, but no current mainstream books about Doña Gracia Mendes Nasi or Glückel von Hameln (or even Golda Meir, for that matter).

The reason is pretty obvious: if you accept and celebrate the historical truth that Jews have lived in the Land of Israel for millennia (and done much else besides), this undermines the prevailing antisemitic slander that the founding of the State of Israel was a settler colonial enterprise."

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts