It’s easy to debate Israel from a safe distance. It’s different when you’ve taken the flight, sat at the bar, and known the people who never came home.
Good stuff! I've told many Israel-critics: "Spoken exactly like someone who never had a jihadist try to plunge a knife into his/her neck, or lost a loved one to Pal terror. It's easy to be an armchair general when it's not your ass on the line!" They rarely even try to respond to that - at most, they strike back with a slogan and a buzzword chaser.
No more podcasts, interviews, war pundits, speciall TV programmes giving opinions, usually bad ones, about how Israel should live, what Israel should do, etc.
As always, you’ve left me with chills reading your well stated, and brilliantly written piece. Am Yisrael Chai! Who applauds calculated terrorism that trains a pilot whose mission is to stab a captain and bring down innocents? Only premeditating terrorists plan how to get around a locked cockpit, designed since terror brought down two towers and almost the US pentagon? Yet there are still those applauding these terrorists? The insanity is beyond comprehension. 😳🤯😡.
As I have said since 1967, Israel and Israelis should listen to no nation or people who have not walked down the streets of Israel, spent time in its establishments, and interacted with israelis. A better country and people have never existed on earth, ever! Am Yisrael Chai! 💙🤍🇮🇱. Thank you for you for your gift of writing all I feel Vanessa! 🙏🏻
This is a great piece. One thing I have not heard from all the “free Palestine” people in the time since the Oct 7 attack is what exactly they think Israel should have done in response. What, in their expert opinion, is the right response to a brutal terrorist attack done by people who embed themselves among civilians? I have never gotten an answer to that.
I've asked all my most intelligent friends, all of whom swallow the entire NY Times line, a simple question: If you were Israeli PM on 10/7 what would you have done?
They either mumble and avoid an answer or say something senseless like Israel should have let the UN or some international peacekeeping force enter Gaza instead. As if any country would allow its soldiers to be sitting ducks for Hamas! As if evacuating the territory and handing it over to the Palestinians, who instead of building a state only prepared for more jihad, wasn't the answer to every question about who and what Israel is dealing with.
The truth is most people are intellectual conformists, even the smart ones, especially when they'd have to face angry children screaming "baby killer!" and intense social pressure over an issue that doesn't affect them personally. What Westerners really want is for Israel to somehow pacify the feral Palestinians so they can have peace and quiet and go back to feeling like good liberals on the right side of history.
Westerners have no clue what Israel is faced with, and most need to shut up, as we all should do about topics we're ignorant of.
They think Israel should have had some sort of "limited" response. Whatever that limit would be. And ,if it failed....well, them's the breaks. No skin off their noses. Or death. And actually, many could live very well with Israel's defeat.
If it were really bad, they could have some ceremony of regret. And then not be bothered with that troublesome entity in the Middle East. That's why their answer to Hamas terrorism is to push to give them a state. Even if Hamas tells anyone who will listen that they want the area Judenrein. Isn't that what happened with Hitler? Tsk tsk. But don't look for sanctuary anyplace where we live. If you're killed, we'll be really really sorry. It's true - people love dead Jews.
There is some horrible mental illness spreading worldwide that convinces otherwise normal people (though usually LOSERS of one sort or another) that Jews are lily-white colonizing oppressors who deserve to die for being Jews and wanting to be Jews in the place Jews come from and thereby colonizing the land and oppressing and killing po' little brown 'palestinians'. Rather than fight this disease, we have sat back and "there-there'd", hoping the virus of hate will pass, ignoring those (Qatar, Iran, MoBro's, etc.) dumping more and more of this virus into the waters of the Internet, and in some cases even succumbing to it.
ENOUGH!
This HAS TO STOP. Time to fight this scourge with every last resources, using whatever is necessary. As the flydubai miracle demonstrates, this disease is fatal...for Jews, if left untreated. We know the treatment...we just have to have the courage to deploy it.
Moses, Jew Hate always exists and will never stop. The haters will believe anything to validate their hate. It has come in waves every 60-100 years, for 2000 years. The last big wave was the Holocaust era. Nearly 80 years ago. So we have been due, and here we are with levels of hate matching or exceeding the 1930s and 40s. Thank God there is Israel now.
The keffiyeh crowd stands for one thing and that is to annihilate Jews and the Western way of life. History will ultimately record this period as an unprecedented wave of collective hysteria.
What about us Jews who support Israel with our whole hearts, with no ‘if’s’ or ‘but’s’? Who have cut friends and family out of their lives because of the attitudes described in this piece? Who defend Israel online and in person against those who hate her and want her destroyed? Who stand up and defend other Jews when no-one else will? And who, btw, were doing this long before October 7th?
You want us to shut up? Really? Maybe you need to rethink you’re attitude. Not every Jew in the diaspora is a treacherous asshole.
I wrote a whole long reply and lost it, but yes, of course we’re on the same team and we’re in the same family.
That said it’s very difficult for you to have coherent, intelligent views based in reality if you don’t live here. Especially when it comes to assessing the situation and understanding Israel’s perspective and feelings because that place a huge role in what your politics will be.
Diaspora Jews often times think that Israel Israel are radical in one area or another. It appears radical because they don’t live here and understand what it’s like to live here now.
Stop putting all Diaspora Jews in the same category. I have devoted my whole working life to fighting Jew hatred and fighting terrorism and extremism on line. I am Zionist to my very core. And G-d willing I hope to make Aliyah with my dog in the near future.💪🇮🇱
Looking forward to seeing you and your dog! I believe you’re as dedicated as any Israeli. All I meant to say is, that while Israelis obviously appreciate diaspora Jews, they don’t care about their opinions on Israeli politics (ie what Israel should and should not do). They don’t even care what I think since I’m an Oleh 🤣
Nor do you know what it is like to live in a country where the Jew is the minority, has no military of its own, and get shot in the streets for supporting Israel as happened in Washington D.C. or burned alive as happened in Boulder, Colorado.
B) will post this few times so each of you see this.
Like I said, we’re all the same team and the same family. All I mean to say is, no Israeli cares what your opinions on Israeli politics are because your opinion has substantially less value to them as people not living in the country and suffering alongside the various paths taken in the way they do.
Get over it or make Aliyah.
That said, I admire you tremendously and think we all have to do our part for the Jewish people wherever we are.
Eva, thank you; I really appreciated your response to me. I’ve never seen that attitude from any Israeli on here either… and my Israeli friends would not speak in that rude, dismissive manner: I’ve had nothing but support and encouragement (as well as “but please keep yourself safe”… ie they show concern) from them. There’s no need to take this kind of attitude… and as for making aliyah, it is not an option for all, for various reasons(in my case, age, health, and finance… not that I should need to feel I have to explain)
So you are saying Diaspora Jews should be silent and listen to all the BS we hear daily about Israel and the trinity of falsehoods: genocide, apartheid, ethnic cleansing. Not only would I find that impossible, it comes back to bite us when the Jew haters attack us in the streets, shopping malls, subways, and in the media and universities.
I’m well aware I don’t live your reality… born and grew up in Scotland: that said, I try to do what limited little things I can to show that those inthe diaspora (and that also includes frequently having to point out to other diasporans that there are other places than the US, which is not something I like doing but feel the need to, and wish I didn’t)are here and trying to do what we can.
Do *not* tell me to keep my mouth shut. There’s more I want to say but won’t, as I don’t want this to become nasty… though your comment was exactly that.
Like I said, we’re all the same team and the same family. All I mean to say is, no Israeli cares what your opinions on Israeli politics are because your opinion has substantially less value to them as people not living in the country and suffering alongside the various paths taken in the way they do.
Get over it or make Aliyah.
That said, I admire you tremendously and think we all have to do our part for the Jewish people wherever we are.
I said nothing about your politics. Adding that you ‘admire me’ doesn’t negate your attitude... there are ways of expressing opinions, some of which don’t come across as unnecessarily rude.
The greatest difference between Israel and the West right now is the difference between people who have no experience of existential threats and people who have experience of living with constant existential threat. The difference has become so great, it's almost like the same beast evolving into two different species.
For the cossetted, comfortable Westerner, who has nothing to live or die for, it makes no sense to risk blood and treasure to destroy an enemy—certainly there's some combo of therapy and bribery that could turn them into allies, and certainly they'd prefer Prime and Netflix to war and struggle. What is most important to Western liberals is having a good conscience, projecting all the proper social signals to your chosen cohort, and ideally having a peaceful, easy life followed by a peaceful, easy death.
But Israelis have none of these luxuries, especially the most delicious luxury of all: crafting your own pseudo-reality and getting to live safely inside it, with the real world hidden away behind various walls (social, cultural, psychological)—not to mention our vast wealth and security. Instead Israelis turn 18 and serve in the military, live in homes with bomb shelters installed, and wake up every day wondering who might jump out of somewhere with a gun or if a stray missile might fall. They know that tomorrow (or even today) are never guaranteed.
I think this explains why Westerners refuse to let Israel defeat its enemies and why Westerners have lazy, self-flattering sympathy for whoever codes as "oppressed victim"—it's all about THEM and their fundamentalist belief that they reside at the apex of humanity and that everyone on earth wants to be them and can be, if only we feel their pain and boost their self-esteem. It is essentially Nietzsche's Last Man lecturing Achilles.
"I am tired of listening to people who have never experienced any of this explain, with astonishing confidence, what Israelis should fear, what Jews should tolerate, how Israel should defend itself, what constitutes an “acceptable” response to being attacked, and at precisely what point Jewish self-defense becomes morally inconvenient for everyone else."
Beautifully written. Those who should read this will never get over their biases and their stupidity. You would think 9/11 would have informed the ignorant living in the West. Especially those self-hating Jews. But no, they do not want to be informed. They want to join the self-righteous crowds.
Vanessa. I am not a Jew. This is a powerful piece. Thank you.
I have saved a couple of paragraphs from close to the end. I am going to use those as rebuttals to online posters when they trash Israel and it's actions after Oct. 7. I hope you won't mind. It says/you say what I want to say so much better than I ever could.
As a non-Jewish rapper once said, and I swear it gets truer every day, especially for us: “hypocrisy is the greatest luxury.” The privilege of that hypocrisy - including and especially diaspora, self-hating Jews - is an instant eject button from the realm of validity. Fuck ‘em.
Wonderful piece. Very powerful. Thank you 🙏🏻
Good stuff! I've told many Israel-critics: "Spoken exactly like someone who never had a jihadist try to plunge a knife into his/her neck, or lost a loved one to Pal terror. It's easy to be an armchair general when it's not your ass on the line!" They rarely even try to respond to that - at most, they strike back with a slogan and a buzzword chaser.
No more podcasts, interviews, war pundits, speciall TV programmes giving opinions, usually bad ones, about how Israel should live, what Israel should do, etc.
As always, you’ve left me with chills reading your well stated, and brilliantly written piece. Am Yisrael Chai! Who applauds calculated terrorism that trains a pilot whose mission is to stab a captain and bring down innocents? Only premeditating terrorists plan how to get around a locked cockpit, designed since terror brought down two towers and almost the US pentagon? Yet there are still those applauding these terrorists? The insanity is beyond comprehension. 😳🤯😡.
As I have said since 1967, Israel and Israelis should listen to no nation or people who have not walked down the streets of Israel, spent time in its establishments, and interacted with israelis. A better country and people have never existed on earth, ever! Am Yisrael Chai! 💙🤍🇮🇱. Thank you for you for your gift of writing all I feel Vanessa! 🙏🏻
This is a great piece. One thing I have not heard from all the “free Palestine” people in the time since the Oct 7 attack is what exactly they think Israel should have done in response. What, in their expert opinion, is the right response to a brutal terrorist attack done by people who embed themselves among civilians? I have never gotten an answer to that.
Same here.
I've asked all my most intelligent friends, all of whom swallow the entire NY Times line, a simple question: If you were Israeli PM on 10/7 what would you have done?
They either mumble and avoid an answer or say something senseless like Israel should have let the UN or some international peacekeeping force enter Gaza instead. As if any country would allow its soldiers to be sitting ducks for Hamas! As if evacuating the territory and handing it over to the Palestinians, who instead of building a state only prepared for more jihad, wasn't the answer to every question about who and what Israel is dealing with.
The truth is most people are intellectual conformists, even the smart ones, especially when they'd have to face angry children screaming "baby killer!" and intense social pressure over an issue that doesn't affect them personally. What Westerners really want is for Israel to somehow pacify the feral Palestinians so they can have peace and quiet and go back to feeling like good liberals on the right side of history.
Westerners have no clue what Israel is faced with, and most need to shut up, as we all should do about topics we're ignorant of.
They think Israel should have had some sort of "limited" response. Whatever that limit would be. And ,if it failed....well, them's the breaks. No skin off their noses. Or death. And actually, many could live very well with Israel's defeat.
If it were really bad, they could have some ceremony of regret. And then not be bothered with that troublesome entity in the Middle East. That's why their answer to Hamas terrorism is to push to give them a state. Even if Hamas tells anyone who will listen that they want the area Judenrein. Isn't that what happened with Hitler? Tsk tsk. But don't look for sanctuary anyplace where we live. If you're killed, we'll be really really sorry. It's true - people love dead Jews.
God bless this lady, her ethical clarity, her Jewish guts.
There is some horrible mental illness spreading worldwide that convinces otherwise normal people (though usually LOSERS of one sort or another) that Jews are lily-white colonizing oppressors who deserve to die for being Jews and wanting to be Jews in the place Jews come from and thereby colonizing the land and oppressing and killing po' little brown 'palestinians'. Rather than fight this disease, we have sat back and "there-there'd", hoping the virus of hate will pass, ignoring those (Qatar, Iran, MoBro's, etc.) dumping more and more of this virus into the waters of the Internet, and in some cases even succumbing to it.
ENOUGH!
This HAS TO STOP. Time to fight this scourge with every last resources, using whatever is necessary. As the flydubai miracle demonstrates, this disease is fatal...for Jews, if left untreated. We know the treatment...we just have to have the courage to deploy it.
Moses, Jew Hate always exists and will never stop. The haters will believe anything to validate their hate. It has come in waves every 60-100 years, for 2000 years. The last big wave was the Holocaust era. Nearly 80 years ago. So we have been due, and here we are with levels of hate matching or exceeding the 1930s and 40s. Thank God there is Israel now.
The keffiyeh crowd stands for one thing and that is to annihilate Jews and the Western way of life. History will ultimately record this period as an unprecedented wave of collective hysteria.
Agreed. Calling all Diaspora Jews to keep their mouths silenced please 🤫
What about us Jews who support Israel with our whole hearts, with no ‘if’s’ or ‘but’s’? Who have cut friends and family out of their lives because of the attitudes described in this piece? Who defend Israel online and in person against those who hate her and want her destroyed? Who stand up and defend other Jews when no-one else will? And who, btw, were doing this long before October 7th?
You want us to shut up? Really? Maybe you need to rethink you’re attitude. Not every Jew in the diaspora is a treacherous asshole.
I wrote a whole long reply and lost it, but yes, of course we’re on the same team and we’re in the same family.
That said it’s very difficult for you to have coherent, intelligent views based in reality if you don’t live here. Especially when it comes to assessing the situation and understanding Israel’s perspective and feelings because that place a huge role in what your politics will be.
Diaspora Jews often times think that Israel Israel are radical in one area or another. It appears radical because they don’t live here and understand what it’s like to live here now.
Stop putting all Diaspora Jews in the same category. I have devoted my whole working life to fighting Jew hatred and fighting terrorism and extremism on line. I am Zionist to my very core. And G-d willing I hope to make Aliyah with my dog in the near future.💪🇮🇱
Looking forward to seeing you and your dog! I believe you’re as dedicated as any Israeli. All I meant to say is, that while Israelis obviously appreciate diaspora Jews, they don’t care about their opinions on Israeli politics (ie what Israel should and should not do). They don’t even care what I think since I’m an Oleh 🤣
Nor do you know what it is like to live in a country where the Jew is the minority, has no military of its own, and get shot in the streets for supporting Israel as happened in Washington D.C. or burned alive as happened in Boulder, Colorado.
A) I grew up in New York
B) will post this few times so each of you see this.
Like I said, we’re all the same team and the same family. All I mean to say is, no Israeli cares what your opinions on Israeli politics are because your opinion has substantially less value to them as people not living in the country and suffering alongside the various paths taken in the way they do.
Get over it or make Aliyah.
That said, I admire you tremendously and think we all have to do our part for the Jewish people wherever we are.
Well said. I found that comment deeply hurtful
As did I. Hurtful and completely unnecessary.
I’ve never seen anything like this from any other Israeli on here.
Eva, thank you; I really appreciated your response to me. I’ve never seen that attitude from any Israeli on here either… and my Israeli friends would not speak in that rude, dismissive manner: I’ve had nothing but support and encouragement (as well as “but please keep yourself safe”… ie they show concern) from them. There’s no need to take this kind of attitude… and as for making aliyah, it is not an option for all, for various reasons(in my case, age, health, and finance… not that I should need to feel I have to explain)
So you are saying Diaspora Jews should be silent and listen to all the BS we hear daily about Israel and the trinity of falsehoods: genocide, apartheid, ethnic cleansing. Not only would I find that impossible, it comes back to bite us when the Jew haters attack us in the streets, shopping malls, subways, and in the media and universities.
I’m well aware I don’t live your reality… born and grew up in Scotland: that said, I try to do what limited little things I can to show that those inthe diaspora (and that also includes frequently having to point out to other diasporans that there are other places than the US, which is not something I like doing but feel the need to, and wish I didn’t)are here and trying to do what we can.
Do *not* tell me to keep my mouth shut. There’s more I want to say but won’t, as I don’t want this to become nasty… though your comment was exactly that.
will post this few times so each of you see this.
Like I said, we’re all the same team and the same family. All I mean to say is, no Israeli cares what your opinions on Israeli politics are because your opinion has substantially less value to them as people not living in the country and suffering alongside the various paths taken in the way they do.
Get over it or make Aliyah.
That said, I admire you tremendously and think we all have to do our part for the Jewish people wherever we are.
I said nothing about your politics. Adding that you ‘admire me’ doesn’t negate your attitude... there are ways of expressing opinions, some of which don’t come across as unnecessarily rude.
I was just trying to be kind with that line -- my views stand. I apologize for coming across as unneccesarily rude - that was not my intention.
The greatest difference between Israel and the West right now is the difference between people who have no experience of existential threats and people who have experience of living with constant existential threat. The difference has become so great, it's almost like the same beast evolving into two different species.
For the cossetted, comfortable Westerner, who has nothing to live or die for, it makes no sense to risk blood and treasure to destroy an enemy—certainly there's some combo of therapy and bribery that could turn them into allies, and certainly they'd prefer Prime and Netflix to war and struggle. What is most important to Western liberals is having a good conscience, projecting all the proper social signals to your chosen cohort, and ideally having a peaceful, easy life followed by a peaceful, easy death.
But Israelis have none of these luxuries, especially the most delicious luxury of all: crafting your own pseudo-reality and getting to live safely inside it, with the real world hidden away behind various walls (social, cultural, psychological)—not to mention our vast wealth and security. Instead Israelis turn 18 and serve in the military, live in homes with bomb shelters installed, and wake up every day wondering who might jump out of somewhere with a gun or if a stray missile might fall. They know that tomorrow (or even today) are never guaranteed.
I think this explains why Westerners refuse to let Israel defeat its enemies and why Westerners have lazy, self-flattering sympathy for whoever codes as "oppressed victim"—it's all about THEM and their fundamentalist belief that they reside at the apex of humanity and that everyone on earth wants to be them and can be, if only we feel their pain and boost their self-esteem. It is essentially Nietzsche's Last Man lecturing Achilles.
"I am tired of listening to people who have never experienced any of this explain, with astonishing confidence, what Israelis should fear, what Jews should tolerate, how Israel should defend itself, what constitutes an “acceptable” response to being attacked, and at precisely what point Jewish self-defense becomes morally inconvenient for everyone else."
YES! AMEN!
Beautifully written. Those who should read this will never get over their biases and their stupidity. You would think 9/11 would have informed the ignorant living in the West. Especially those self-hating Jews. But no, they do not want to be informed. They want to join the self-righteous crowds.
Terrorist hijacking attempt on flight no FZ 1073 just days away from the 3rd anniversary of 10/7. Am Yisrael Chai🇮🇱
Such a powerful piece coming, as it does, from personal experience. Thank you, Vanessa.
Peace and love to you.
Vanessa. I am not a Jew. This is a powerful piece. Thank you.
I have saved a couple of paragraphs from close to the end. I am going to use those as rebuttals to online posters when they trash Israel and it's actions after Oct. 7. I hope you won't mind. It says/you say what I want to say so much better than I ever could.
As a non-Jewish rapper once said, and I swear it gets truer every day, especially for us: “hypocrisy is the greatest luxury.” The privilege of that hypocrisy - including and especially diaspora, self-hating Jews - is an instant eject button from the realm of validity. Fuck ‘em.