This is quite simply the best thing I’ve seen written about the Israeli Palestinian conflict: the magnum opus. Every sentence is 100% accurate and not debatable. Jews have willfully ignored the obvious reality that we are fighting an evil ideology which must not be tolerated. I’ve formed a group for Jews on Facebook based on the harsh realities of what is called Jews for Jews. This is exactly what we preach. Without fighting the enemy within (utter denial) we can never defeat the Palestinians. We have engaged a campaign of committing suicide in an effort to shape world opinion by fighting every war “not to win.” This is a fools game.
We keep thinking like ghetto-bochers and make the same mistakes again and again and again. We have one of the world’s best militaries but hamstring it out of some timid Jewish foolishness. Just as we separated the Nazis from the Germans and the Poles and the Ukrainians, even though the citizens of all three were more than happy to help slaughter us, so we coddle the ‘palestinians’ who are even worse. This is all to curry favor with the rest of the world but all in vain. We were despised even on the morning of October 7, before the IDF even started to respond. Would we be hated more if we had completely flattened Gaza, civilians and all? I’ve just been to Hiroshima. No one knocked on their roofs.
I begin to think that the world hates us even more because we come across as that timid little ghetto-bocher, asking nicely if we could possibly be allowed to live one more day. Perhaps things would be different if we responded with utter destruction when attacked. Flatten Gaza. Flatten Tehran. And then wave our middle fingers at the world and ask who wants to be next.
Israel could learn from the rock opera “Tommy”. Put in your earplugs, put on your eyeshades you know where to put the cork.. Even if this recent Gazen food distribution shooting is proven 100% to be hamas, the truth will be forgotten as the world turns against the jews as quickly as the next hamas orchestrated PR murders. Until Israel is rid of this surge upon their land, the temporary of times of peace will remain temporary. World opinion will not change, as it hasn't since history adopted jew hate as a law of nature, like gravity. So Israel must forge ahead and do what must be done. The antisemites be damned.
Brilliant well written analysis. I agree with everything you've written and the previous comments. Now how do you change the "conceptzia" delusion in Israel? I hope you can find the broadest possible media outlets in Israel. Thank you Joshua Hoffman for providing the platform for this essential powerful essay.
Thank you very much. I need to spread my principled stance to an audience that is willing to listen and to be challenged. Happy to take interviews and post in more publications.
I do not live in Israel but totally agree with this sad real truth!! Former and present Israeli governments were so deluded by their wrong doctrine that they can not wake up from this nightmare...All this BS about sending leaflets and warnings before attaching, hoping international opinion will be favorable, is a complete nonsense. Suprise is a key element in winning wars! This must change!
Take sovereignty over gaza and Judea&Samaria. You leave it and talk about demographics and let the world complain about occupation and apartheid. It’s time to man up, win this war, make Israel the land that God promised you.
Your scripture says to treat the foreigner with respect but if he doesn’t want your God to be his God and your people to be his people then why is he there? Does this land belong to Israel or no?
So Israel has to choose. Be strong and retake your land or be weak and be driven out. There is no other solution
You fight and win a war by destroying your enemy on the battlefield and the will power of its civilian population that supports your enemy by whatever means that accomplish that goal
Israel belongs to Israel—Gaza, Judea, and Samaria. You should have never given up Sinai. It is time to say enough. I am not Jewish, but I think it is time to stand up and declare Israeli sovereignty from the river to the sea. Be done with this scourge.
“Everyone has a choice: if you want to follow a good path and be righteous, it’s up to you. If you want to follow a bad path and be wicked, it’s up to you. This is what it means when God says, ‘The human has become like one of us, with the ability to know good and evil .’”—Maimonides, Laws of Repentance [Quoted in Moshe Silver’s The Weight of Gold, chapter 34.]
Hamas has one goal which rendering the Land and State of Israel Judenrein .Douglas Murray wrote that IDF officers told him that it was no accident that Mein Kamph and the Koran were in almost house or apartment in Gaza and that tunnels were found in children’s bedrooms and that Hamas uses civilians to shield its terrorists You can find videos of 10 year olds telling their fellow residents of Gaza to reject food distributed by the IDF or the U.S. Hamas must be obliterated and the will of its population to support Hamas destroyed That is how this war will be won
> It is the West’s and Israel’s infantilisation of Gaza that is truly racist
I really liked this sentence. Over 10 years ago (already!) I was arguing online with European leftists on a newspaper forum about criminality from immigrant descents. Those leftists basically said "it's not their fault, they are discriminated blabla". I told them "if it's not their fault, then they have no responsibility, no ability to make their own choice, and those criminals must be thus treated at best like children and live under strong supervision of responsible adults". None of those left-wing pseudo-intellectuals could bring a single reasonable counter-argument beyond "shut up and f*ck off from here you fascist".
Mostly brilliant. I agree about Hamas and the Palestinian death cults and the need to continue to destroy Hamas and the rest of the killer cults in Gaza. But I can't accept blaming Israel for not entirely taking the gloves off. I'm an American, so it's not for me to judge Israel, but to support her as much as I can. However, I think most Israelis realize that Hamas must be TOTALLY destroyed.
Everything is true in this article. I kind of struggle with the term or concept of "Palestine" or "Palestinian". Sometimes I think that what happened on October 7th should appropriately be referred to as the Palestinian Massacre. Not the Hamas massacre, not the Gazan massacre, the Palestinian massacre. But then that kind of gives legitimacy to those terms, which really are inventions. Maybe they should be referred to as PFKSARTs. (People Formerly Known Simply
I find the term useful to distinguish between them and the Arabs who live in Israel and abroad. It’s indeed a distinctive political movement. The most evil movement that had many iterations: Nazism > Communism > Islamism. I’ll release in the coming future an essay about that. So follow me to stay tuned.
This is quite simply the best thing I’ve seen written about the Israeli Palestinian conflict: the magnum opus. Every sentence is 100% accurate and not debatable. Jews have willfully ignored the obvious reality that we are fighting an evil ideology which must not be tolerated. I’ve formed a group for Jews on Facebook based on the harsh realities of what is called Jews for Jews. This is exactly what we preach. Without fighting the enemy within (utter denial) we can never defeat the Palestinians. We have engaged a campaign of committing suicide in an effort to shape world opinion by fighting every war “not to win.” This is a fools game.
Thank you very much! Please invite me to the group :)
https://www.facebook.com/share/g/1A1Sb5oJtM/?mibextid=wwXIfr
It took decades to denazify Germany.
It will take generations to denazify Gaza.
It needs to start with eliminating the UN indoctrination of Gazans.
Transfer the General Assembly and its related committees to Gaza as a redevelopment project and give the citizens something to do.
Keep the Security Council and its veto in NY.
We keep thinking like ghetto-bochers and make the same mistakes again and again and again. We have one of the world’s best militaries but hamstring it out of some timid Jewish foolishness. Just as we separated the Nazis from the Germans and the Poles and the Ukrainians, even though the citizens of all three were more than happy to help slaughter us, so we coddle the ‘palestinians’ who are even worse. This is all to curry favor with the rest of the world but all in vain. We were despised even on the morning of October 7, before the IDF even started to respond. Would we be hated more if we had completely flattened Gaza, civilians and all? I’ve just been to Hiroshima. No one knocked on their roofs.
I begin to think that the world hates us even more because we come across as that timid little ghetto-bocher, asking nicely if we could possibly be allowed to live one more day. Perhaps things would be different if we responded with utter destruction when attacked. Flatten Gaza. Flatten Tehran. And then wave our middle fingers at the world and ask who wants to be next.
Absolutely! I called this "shtetl mentality", check this out:
https://www.philosophyineedit.com/i/164640333/iv-still-in-the-shtetl
Israel could learn from the rock opera “Tommy”. Put in your earplugs, put on your eyeshades you know where to put the cork.. Even if this recent Gazen food distribution shooting is proven 100% to be hamas, the truth will be forgotten as the world turns against the jews as quickly as the next hamas orchestrated PR murders. Until Israel is rid of this surge upon their land, the temporary of times of peace will remain temporary. World opinion will not change, as it hasn't since history adopted jew hate as a law of nature, like gravity. So Israel must forge ahead and do what must be done. The antisemites be damned.
Exactly!
Brilliant well written analysis. I agree with everything you've written and the previous comments. Now how do you change the "conceptzia" delusion in Israel? I hope you can find the broadest possible media outlets in Israel. Thank you Joshua Hoffman for providing the platform for this essential powerful essay.
Thank you very much. I need to spread my principled stance to an audience that is willing to listen and to be challenged. Happy to take interviews and post in more publications.
I do not live in Israel but totally agree with this sad real truth!! Former and present Israeli governments were so deluded by their wrong doctrine that they can not wake up from this nightmare...All this BS about sending leaflets and warnings before attaching, hoping international opinion will be favorable, is a complete nonsense. Suprise is a key element in winning wars! This must change!
Then Israel has to stop playing at war.
Take sovereignty over gaza and Judea&Samaria. You leave it and talk about demographics and let the world complain about occupation and apartheid. It’s time to man up, win this war, make Israel the land that God promised you.
Your scripture says to treat the foreigner with respect but if he doesn’t want your God to be his God and your people to be his people then why is he there? Does this land belong to Israel or no?
So Israel has to choose. Be strong and retake your land or be weak and be driven out. There is no other solution
You fight and win a war by destroying your enemy on the battlefield and the will power of its civilian population that supports your enemy by whatever means that accomplish that goal
Israel belongs to Israel—Gaza, Judea, and Samaria. You should have never given up Sinai. It is time to say enough. I am not Jewish, but I think it is time to stand up and declare Israeli sovereignty from the river to the sea. Be done with this scourge.
“Everyone has a choice: if you want to follow a good path and be righteous, it’s up to you. If you want to follow a bad path and be wicked, it’s up to you. This is what it means when God says, ‘The human has become like one of us, with the ability to know good and evil .’”—Maimonides, Laws of Repentance [Quoted in Moshe Silver’s The Weight of Gold, chapter 34.]
Hamas has one goal which rendering the Land and State of Israel Judenrein .Douglas Murray wrote that IDF officers told him that it was no accident that Mein Kamph and the Koran were in almost house or apartment in Gaza and that tunnels were found in children’s bedrooms and that Hamas uses civilians to shield its terrorists You can find videos of 10 year olds telling their fellow residents of Gaza to reject food distributed by the IDF or the U.S. Hamas must be obliterated and the will of its population to support Hamas destroyed That is how this war will be won
Thought provoking article. Well said.
> It is the West’s and Israel’s infantilisation of Gaza that is truly racist
I really liked this sentence. Over 10 years ago (already!) I was arguing online with European leftists on a newspaper forum about criminality from immigrant descents. Those leftists basically said "it's not their fault, they are discriminated blabla". I told them "if it's not their fault, then they have no responsibility, no ability to make their own choice, and those criminals must be thus treated at best like children and live under strong supervision of responsible adults". None of those left-wing pseudo-intellectuals could bring a single reasonable counter-argument beyond "shut up and f*ck off from here you fascist".
Exactly correct. Every word.
Amen brother
Mostly brilliant. I agree about Hamas and the Palestinian death cults and the need to continue to destroy Hamas and the rest of the killer cults in Gaza. But I can't accept blaming Israel for not entirely taking the gloves off. I'm an American, so it's not for me to judge Israel, but to support her as much as I can. However, I think most Israelis realize that Hamas must be TOTALLY destroyed.
Thank you!
Everything is true in this article. I kind of struggle with the term or concept of "Palestine" or "Palestinian". Sometimes I think that what happened on October 7th should appropriately be referred to as the Palestinian Massacre. Not the Hamas massacre, not the Gazan massacre, the Palestinian massacre. But then that kind of gives legitimacy to those terms, which really are inventions. Maybe they should be referred to as PFKSARTs. (People Formerly Known Simply
as Arabs Reinventing Themselves).
I find the term useful to distinguish between them and the Arabs who live in Israel and abroad. It’s indeed a distinctive political movement. The most evil movement that had many iterations: Nazism > Communism > Islamism. I’ll release in the coming future an essay about that. So follow me to stay tuned.