Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bruce's avatar

One factual error-before the 1960s no Arabs identified themselves as, “Palestinians” they referred to themselves as, “Arabs”.

In what now seems odd- it was the Jews who identified as, “Palestinian”.

Expand full comment
Ellis Geist's avatar

Thanks for this analysis. I'd like to add something to the mix that challenges the premise that the Nakba was a catastrophe of mass displacement. Constantin Zureiq, the person who coined the term, was referring to the shame and humiliation brought about by the failure of multiple Arab armies to defeat the lowly Jews.

In his own words: “Seven Arab countries declare war on Zionism in Palestine . . . Seven countries go to war to abolish the partition and to defeat Zionism, and quickly leave the battle after losing much of the land of Palestine – and even the part that was given to the Arabs in the Partition Plan . . . Our public diplomacy began to speak of our imaginary victories, to put the Arab public to sleep and talk of the ability to overcome and win easily – until the Nakba happened . . . Zionism is deeply implanted in Western life, while we are far from it . . . They live in the present and look to the future, while we are drugged-up dreaming of a magnificent past . . . We must admit our mistakes . . . and recognize the extent of our responsibility for the disaster that is our lot.”

But instead of waking up to Arab folly, the Nakba’s meaning was twisted and weaponized against the Jews, scapegoating them for the catastrophe that Arab’s brought upon themselves. There would have been no Arab refugee crisis had they not declared war on Israel. (And had they won, there would have been no Jews.)

Nakba became yet another in a long list of words that has been inverted and weaponized against the Jews. In 2023, Mahmoud Abbas, the Palestinian Authority President, signed a presidential decree stating that anyone denying the “Nakba” faced up to two years in jail. In Orwellian fashion, "Nakba” is now officially defined to mean “a crime against humanity” carried out by the “Zionist gangs.” This is pure gaslighting, and the endless rewriting of history and butchering of language is a main reason why there has not been peace since then.

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts