Zionism was never a promise that nothing terrible would happen to Jews again. It was the promise that, whatever happened, there would still be somewhere to go home to and celebrate our holidays.
Our Jewish world, especially in the diaspora, has also changed significantly since then. It’s hard to believe Israel had relative normalcy before October 7th. The world despises Israel and Jews 10x more today
My mother’s cousin made Aliyah in 1971. She recently wrote to us in a family email that this was the first year since 10/7/23 that her family decided that putting up the sukkah felt like the right thing to do. She said that it’s finally beginning to feel like Israel is turning a corner, and slowly they’re getting back to an “Israel normal.”
Wow Justin what you wrote is hard to take after reading Joshua’s beautiful post about the people on the plane wanting to go “home.” Try kindness next time. There are many allies of ours in the diaspora who love us. I know them.
I can understand where Justin is coming from. I don't think what he writes diminishes Joshua's words; he's just commenting on change. What he says is true, but it doesn't make what Joshua has written untrue. Where does kindness come into it with the people who demonstrably hate us? We are not Christians, turning the other cheek.
We need to remember 10/7/23, the Hebrew date on which it occurred: Simhat Torah 5784. Our opponents are co-opting 10/7 on college campuses and in the public square.
We remember Israeli Independence day on the Hebrew date; we remember the Yom Kippur War on the Hebrew date; and we remember our Bar/Bat Mitzvot by the parsha
I am ruminating about your suggestion, Alan. In my Reform community and, according to Gemini, also in Israel, we combine Simchat Torah and Shemini Atzeret into one day on 22 Tishrei. This morning, for the first time, it felt weird to experience the joy of Simchat Torah during the Torah service, and then the very real sadness of the Rabbi’s drash, followed by our Yizkor service. I wish we had done them in reverse order. The more traditional Diaspora observance of Yizkor the day before Simchat Torah now makes more sense to me. Having once had the privilege of observing Yom Hazikaron the day before Yom Haatsmuut in Israel, I experienced only minor emotional whiplash. Our congregation, on Yom Kippur, schedules Yizkor just before Neilah, and that works. When would you suggest we commemorate the tragedy of October 7th? Would we go from sadness to joy and immediately back to sadness again? We can’t be the only two Jews pondering the options . . .
This year, our Conservative congregation decided to combine Shemini Atzeret and Simhat Torah, as in Israel. The rationale was to increase attendance, and it was successful. Combining the joy of Simhat Torah with the sadness of Yizkor and Simhat Torah 5784 reminds us that both joy and sadness are part of our history.
Joshua, your essay written from the perspective you chose, from one short sentence uttered by an Israeli passenger, is acutely moving because it's spot on. There is no guarantee of safety anywhere in the world and to expect otherwise would be foolish, although we should, I think, be able to expect that our government will do its very best to keep us safe. A home to return to, that's the stuff that quells nightmares. And Israel for Jews is just that place.
Your articles resonant with me. I learn from them. They make me think. Go deeper. Provide another layer to being Jewish and the need to fiercely protect and preserve who we are and our journey. To teach it to our children. Thank you for being here. And while I feel all that you write about is necessary, they are too long.
This brought me to tears of joy. Never in my life have I felt more proud to be a Jew.
Our Jewish world, especially in the diaspora, has also changed significantly since then. It’s hard to believe Israel had relative normalcy before October 7th. The world despises Israel and Jews 10x more today
My mother’s cousin made Aliyah in 1971. She recently wrote to us in a family email that this was the first year since 10/7/23 that her family decided that putting up the sukkah felt like the right thing to do. She said that it’s finally beginning to feel like Israel is turning a corner, and slowly they’re getting back to an “Israel normal.”
Wow Justin what you wrote is hard to take after reading Joshua’s beautiful post about the people on the plane wanting to go “home.” Try kindness next time. There are many allies of ours in the diaspora who love us. I know them.
I can understand where Justin is coming from. I don't think what he writes diminishes Joshua's words; he's just commenting on change. What he says is true, but it doesn't make what Joshua has written untrue. Where does kindness come into it with the people who demonstrably hate us? We are not Christians, turning the other cheek.
They are furious that October 7 did not paralyze and destroy Israel once and for all.
We need to remember 10/7/23, the Hebrew date on which it occurred: Simhat Torah 5784. Our opponents are co-opting 10/7 on college campuses and in the public square.
We remember Israeli Independence day on the Hebrew date; we remember the Yom Kippur War on the Hebrew date; and we remember our Bar/Bat Mitzvot by the parsha
I am ruminating about your suggestion, Alan. In my Reform community and, according to Gemini, also in Israel, we combine Simchat Torah and Shemini Atzeret into one day on 22 Tishrei. This morning, for the first time, it felt weird to experience the joy of Simchat Torah during the Torah service, and then the very real sadness of the Rabbi’s drash, followed by our Yizkor service. I wish we had done them in reverse order. The more traditional Diaspora observance of Yizkor the day before Simchat Torah now makes more sense to me. Having once had the privilege of observing Yom Hazikaron the day before Yom Haatsmuut in Israel, I experienced only minor emotional whiplash. Our congregation, on Yom Kippur, schedules Yizkor just before Neilah, and that works. When would you suggest we commemorate the tragedy of October 7th? Would we go from sadness to joy and immediately back to sadness again? We can’t be the only two Jews pondering the options . . .
This year, our Conservative congregation decided to combine Shemini Atzeret and Simhat Torah, as in Israel. The rationale was to increase attendance, and it was successful. Combining the joy of Simhat Torah with the sadness of Yizkor and Simhat Torah 5784 reminds us that both joy and sadness are part of our history.
A domu trzeba bronić. Nie ma co filzofować za dużo!
Joshua, your essay written from the perspective you chose, from one short sentence uttered by an Israeli passenger, is acutely moving because it's spot on. There is no guarantee of safety anywhere in the world and to expect otherwise would be foolish, although we should, I think, be able to expect that our government will do its very best to keep us safe. A home to return to, that's the stuff that quells nightmares. And Israel for Jews is just that place.
Beautiful, Joshua
Beautiful. Thank you!🙏
So interesting and insightful. Grateful to follow your musings. Thank you.
Thank you, Joshua, for this beautiful way to end my Simchat Torah observance.
Your articles resonant with me. I learn from them. They make me think. Go deeper. Provide another layer to being Jewish and the need to fiercely protect and preserve who we are and our journey. To teach it to our children. Thank you for being here. And while I feel all that you write about is necessary, they are too long.
Another great one. I love this.