11 Comments
User's avatar
Judith Ross's avatar

As I sat in my shul on Simcha Torah Shabbat, those thoughts were racing in my head. I recalled attending Services on the fateful day in 2023, wondering how can we sing and dance with the Torah while our people in Israel are being slaughtered, or taken hostage. Our rabbi said we dedicating this Service to those victims, and we continued to try to make the day filled with joy of the Torah. How ironic that in our Jewish holiday calendar we really only have two days that should be filled with joy, Simcha Torah, and of course, Purim. And the Purim of 2020 was a day of so before COVID 19 was declared as an epidemic! Yesterday, I found myself sitting and throughout most of the Service, my eyes were "leaking"! We were privileged to have a visiting Reform Rabbi from Jerusalem do the Devar Torah, and he sounded so hopeful, and our beautiful Shimshim, Danelle gave us a touching talk. She actually read a letter, translated into English, written by a survivor of that horrific day, October 7, 2023. And my tears wouldn't stop flowing. To add to the day, another member handed me her Siddur, which had been dedicated to my late husband, and again, my water works continued and then, we had Yiskor! It was long but beautiful Service. I was able to do several of the seven Hakafot, and the Kiddush was warm and friendly. I was completely drained, physically, as I had eaten breakfast by 8 a.m. and because of food allergies, there was nothing I could enjoy at the lovely Kiddush, except some grape juice; I headed home, hitting every red light, and arrived home by 2 p.m. I felt sad but also happy that we had such a good number at the Service, and being there in our shul, with excellent security, and with people I have known for many years, yet I was sad, worried and concerned for the future of my country, Canada, which seems to be bending over backwards to please Muslims, and we even have an Israeli hater Muslim kaffiyeh wearing woman running for mayor, to take over from our present mayor who never showed up for any major Jewish memorial or celebration, but she is there for Eid, and Caribbean events. It is so difficult to realize the Canada could be Jew free, and I am concerned about my children and their children, etc. Sorry to have rambled on. Your Substack just made all my thoughts come forward. Tomorrow afternoon, I will place my Whatsapp call to my brother, 99 years old, in a Kibbutz near Hadera. I know he will try to cheer me up! I do worry about the "Future of Jewish" in the Western countries, especially mine!

Dr Zee's avatar

I feel for you. So sad what has become of Canada, Ontario in particular. I no longer live there but I am Canadian. My parents coming there in 1952 after surviving the holocaust. You have written such a beautiful message with words that I resonate with deeply. Be well 🙏🙏

Jill Grunewald's avatar

You are never alone. I am also worried for Canada… my third home… I hope our leaders wake up.

Robin Santiago's avatar

A heartfelt and beautiful message. Am Yisrael chai.

Justin Yehuda ✡️'s avatar

I really appreciated reading your piece, especially the concept of beginning again. In many ways, it feels like not only have we done this as a nation, as you have described, but many of us have done the same in our personal lives too.

It’s all about the ups and downs.

Mitzi Schwarz's avatar

Just beautiful. Thank you, Vanessa Berg

Susan Sullivan's avatar

I have always loved this about Israel.

The most joyful nation of all. 🙏

The Holy Land News's avatar

The government of Israel should publish the 47 minutes GoPro clips that were filmed by the Hamas ISIS terrorists, on 7th October 2023, perpetuating their atrocities and crimes against humanity on innocent Israeli men, women, children and babies. Until then, the Jew haters and ignorant useful idiots will continue to reverse the facts and blame Israel for committing crimes against Gaza including genocide.

Jill Grunewald's avatar

Thank you for your powerful and brilliant words once again Vanessa! We danced this year on Simchat Torah, I visited the nova festival area in march of 2924. I worked to set up an attacked kibbutz so the residents could leave hotels and return. My 100 year old dad who fought the nazis, passed a month later. This simchat Torah not only did we dance in circles but in a synagogue in a New York County I returned full circle to after leaving 50 years ago. My daughter and son in law had moved to the Hudson Valley and wanted us to live closer to spend more time with them and our three busy grandsons. So we return full circle, live life to its fullest, and we dance.

Laura's avatar

And yet ironically, most of those bastards in the music industry are standing with the monsters who gunned down those youths at the Nova festival. Where is their solidarity with the victims? Where are their tributes for those massacred when they get up on stage? Where are the solidarity concerts for the victims of the Nova massacres? Nowhere to be found. Instead, they get up on stage wearing 'free palestine' shirts and show films of Gaza. Why not the footage from October 7? Appalling and disgusting. Those performers can go to hell.

,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

"Only a few kilometers away, thousands of young Israelis had gathered for the Nova music festival. They, too, had come to dance. They were not soldiers assembling for battle or politicians making a statement. They were young people gathered beneath an open sky, listening to music as the sun began to rise over the Negev".