Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stephen Schecter's avatar

The only adequate response and the only adequate memorial to October 7 will be the declaration of Israeli sovereignty over Gaza, Judea and Samaria and the population of these areas by Jews en masse, many of whom will come from North America. As for the "Palestinians" in these areas they will be locked down for fifty years, free to leave whenever they want.

Expand full comment
Jewish Grandmother's avatar

You captured so much of what is going on in our heads and in our lives these days, those of us in N. America, and you did it with both personal humility and respect for the victims. I have avoided watching any footage of what happened on Oct. 7 because I am a wimp. Just reading about it robs me of sleep and threatens my mental stability, so I admire your courage to face the carnage and to wrestle with your own reaction to October 7th and everything that has happened since. I had the same surreal reaction at Auschwitz-Birkenau. There was an obscenity about its having become a tourist attraction, an exercise to stimulate the Polish economy. I am still not sure whether my presence there was a desecration or not. When you describe our attempts to ‘signal’ our support of the hostages with our attendance at rallies and events, our dogtags and yellow ribbons, I am reminded of the signaling of the other side with their encampments, flags and kefiyahs. Having taken an abrupt political right turn at the ripe old age of 77, I find so many of my Jewish friends still face more to the left. My otherwise revered and adored Toronto friend, the late Tony Wallis, used to embarrass us with his rightwing attitudes about Israel’s security. I am glad he didn’t live long enough to see how right he was, and I am sad that I rolled my eyes in such complete naiveté.

Expand full comment
21 more comments...

No posts