Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Richard Baker's avatar

Totally agree with General Gallant. In the world today a country either has the military strength to prevail or enemies will take advantage of weakness. Wish the need for a strong military posture wasn't necessary but that is not reality especially for Israel. The General is correct that an effective military goes hand in hand with economic strength. Investors look for stability and not constant unrestrained chaos.

Wonderboy's avatar

Israel suffers from the fact that 12% of the population who is Jewish does not engage in productive work of any kind. I am referring to the Ultra Orthodox. They get by for the most part on government handouts and other forms of charity. Israel which has a population of about seven million Jews cannot afford the luxury of allowing these Jews to use their religiosity to avoid serving in the IDF along with staying on the dole to be a "learner". The excuse that they use prayer as a weapon against Israeli destruction will not fly anymore. Its causing way too much social strain and disruption. Israel needs that extra brain power and hands to continue to be the export nation of various tech systems because of a absence of natural recourses.

Nobody is telling the ultra Orthodox to give up their way of life, but they have to make a accommodation with a secular Israeli government that not only helps support them but also protects them from people who wish them dead. Yes the Orthodox Rabbi's are loath to give up any power they hold over their followers. But with their high birthrate at some future date they will be 20% of the Israeli Jewish population shortly after 2050. A country the size of Israel cannot support it and it will retard the financial viability of their international and domestic markets.

In my own families case I have a distant relative that lost a son to the various recent wars Israel had to fight. He is modern Orthodox but over the last few years has grown very bitter against the ultra Orthodox. What Israel cannot do is manage dissention within large segments of the population against the conduct of the super Orthodox and its external enemies at the same time. They do not have that luxury with such a small population.

10 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?