55 Comments
User's avatar
Dinah Bucholz's avatar

This is an exquisitely argued case. I will keep this in my folder, perhaps forever. It's worth keeping.

I believe we are facing a looming catastrophe. I don't know what shape it will take, but I believe it will be worse than anything we have ever faced in our history in one unique way, and that is its global nature.

You say not to panic and believe a Holocaust is around the corner. Probably not. But something is around the corner. I can't recall a time in Jewish history when social unrest coupled with rising antisemitism ever turned out well for us, so I'm not optimistic.

We are considering for the first time making aliyah, because although Jews face other sorts of dangers in Israel, at least there we can be openly and proudly Jewish. I feel a strong sense of no longer belonging here (writing from the United States).

Marc Nodell's avatar

I agree 100% with you. As a student of history, the same conditions and symptoms that were prevalent in pre-Nazi Germany in the 1920s are manifesting themselves collectively in every so-called Western democracy. In less than 8 years, the 'civilized' Germans became supporters of Hitler and his Nazi ideology. It happened rapidly. Today, we see the same thing happening--scapegoating of Jews for ills of society, acceptance of such vitriol by major politicians in the Democrat party, promulgation and amplification of this hatred in academia, the media and entertainment, and a total paralysis by Jewish leadership on how to address this.

Margaret's avatar

The most chilling and ominous part of this mood is the silence and silencing of reason. This replicates the shallow breathing of pre war Europe.

Marc Nodell's avatar

Mob behavior and mentality have taken over, and sadly there are no adults in the political room to stand up to it. If anything western democracy politicians have succumbed to the mob in order to retain power. The signs of decay of the west are all too evident.

Liberal Don's avatar

seeing Gazans being intentionally starved is enough.....

Marc Nodell's avatar

That has been debunked. No one is starving in Gaza.

Liberal Don's avatar

you must have missed the clapping pans for food......total cultural genocide, bulldozed hospitals, schools, apts, museums....

Jill Grunewald's avatar

I visit Israel annually and would like to visit more often. I feel safer in Israel than I do anywhere in the world. I worry more for my grandchildren in NY than my grandchildren in Israel. I tell this to anyone who makes a face or mentions about “dangers” in Israel.

Dana Ramos's avatar

You wrote what I feel. Yes, it's around the corner and we can see it happening.

James Wills's avatar

I am not ethically Jewish, however I have been a Zionist since my teen years. It occurs to me that one of the best things Jews could do to ensure their future is to stop voting against their own interest, which is to say stop voting Democrat. Their entire power base is predicated on envy, and what easier target than those who have struggled and done well?

Ellen North's avatar

yes but the platform of the Republicans will destroy our environment and the world

stanik22's avatar

Nonsense. There is no evidence of your heartfelt thinking.

Sarah's avatar

How? That makes no sense at all.

Moses Maimonides's avatar

It all comes back to my simple explanation: Jew-haters are either LOSERS or those pandering to LOSERS.

Aku's avatar

They may be losers but at present they seem to be wining the grace of the crowds

Susan Sullivan's avatar

You are Gods chosen people. Fight, Fight, Fight. 🇮🇱

Jill Grunewald's avatar

Chosen to follow Torah… not to be gd’s favorite.

Maureen's avatar

I don’t think the Jews have much choice, do they? They are the chosen people, there’s nothing anyone can do about that; and God has provided for and prospered them always through blessing all their efforts to survive and succeed.

Liberal Don's avatar

did God provide the Holocaust?.....

Maureen's avatar

Hell no! But he made the sun to shine on good and evil people. Jew haters provided the Holocaust.

Jill Grunewald's avatar

Chosen to follow Torah … and inspirational!

Sion Owen's avatar

Great overview of Parsha and reminder that there is nothing new under the sun!

RabbiRL✍🏻RLBalfourStevenson's avatar

King Solomon was so deep in this truth it still dwells within the truth we bear. He taught us over and over again our highest goal is 'the annihilation of ego' that

what he saw the burden and conflicit all about, the cause

and the condition we face

in living form predestined

and as well given free will,

in truth that as he concludes

each verse, the treasure of beinging in the knowing

"All is vanity".

How blessed we are to still hold the bittersweet of Melech Shlomo upon our tongues

to this day.

My day was very dark, ladt night recurring semi-dreams and you have reminded me we are not alone, he lives within ever lighting our path upon

G-D's earth.

Thsnk you for bringing him in

before the storm upon the mountain.

praying in concert with all who are this night.

Laila tov -RL✍🏻

Richard Hacker's avatar

As I have said many times before, the world never forgave the Israelis for winning the Six-Day War. Imagine if Israel had lost. Everyone in the world would now be living together as brothers? I think not.

Heartworker's avatar

Most everything of that self-styled "critics of Israel" and those "(we-aren't-)antisemites(-but)..." types believe they can or must ` criticize´ regarding Israel or "the Jews", originates in their own twisted minds; the root cause of their overwrought, botched, and warped false "criticism" can be found simply by looking in the mirror, discovering and confronting their own wretchedness, envy, and inanity. - Their individual problems and inner emptiness appears as that profound and painful that, like addicts, they seek ways to avoid facing it and to snatch up cheap, facile "approval".

Ava Lewis's avatar

I Stand With The Jewish People...

Ciocarlia's avatar

Dara Horn argues that Jews are permitted to live as a minority in non-Jewish societies on the condition that they remain powerless. This essay echoes her conclusion.

Helen Rauch-Elnekave's avatar

How beautiful and insightful! Thank you.

David S. Levine's avatar

Joshua, a very interesting perspective. Sad but true.

Robin Alexander's avatar

Great piece. It's going in my folder of Best FOJ.

Clarity Seeker's avatar

Anyone able to forward this to Dana Nessel or slotkin or countless others on team oppressor- oppressed

Ellen North's avatar

so on target. We must stand up together in the face of anti semitism wrapped in jealousy and stupidity. We must also be aware of the danger that infiltration of the Islamic mindset does not take over Western civilization

Jill Grunewald's avatar

Superb piece connecting yesterday, today and hopefully smarter tomorrows! ✡️💙🤍

stanik22's avatar

The situation is like that of the Sirens in the Odyssey. They keep telling us Jews that we are wrong to create doubt, then use that doubt to kill us.