Nachum, this is an excellent article, but in my opinion you omitted our number one vulnerability: the massive, bloated Jewish organizations that dominate diaspora Jewish life.
They take in enormous amounts of money, yet there is almost no accessibility, almost no accountability, no unified strategy, no coordinated messaging, and very little real leadership that reaches ordinary Jews on the street. Everything is reactive instead of proactive. We respond after the damage is already done instead of building long-term communal strength beforehand.
The other side understands slogans, propaganda, activism, emotional narratives, and strategic coordination. Meanwhile, our organizations often seem trapped inside endless bureaucracy, fundraising, conferences, statements, and institutional caution.
That, to me, is the true Jewish swamp.
And until that swamp is torn down and rebuilt from the ground up with real accountability, accessibility, clarity, and strategic seriousness, diaspora Jews will continue drifting without unified direction while the threats around them grow more organized and more confident.
Where did you get the 2 million figure? It's less than 1 million now. Not to worry, in 2027 NYC Jews will have strong representation in Congress. Their only Jewish congressman will be brad Landers, Mandami dhimmi and anti " Zionist " and all around kapo. Vibes of 1933 berlin.
We need to remember that American "elites" were very instrumental in the creation of nazi Germany through their efforts at making the delusion of eugenics into "science fact". Hitler even wrote to the American Augenics Society to thank them for the ideas with which to rid the world of "unwanted populations". It was only changed from eugenics to "population control" following WW(eleven). Many American soldiers in that war no doubt were killed by weapons manufactured by American industrialists. Those of us who are still living who have memories of the war were seriously impacted by it, probably especially if we were Jewish. It's haunted me my whole life and yet somehow we never discussed it or how it affected us. I was born in 1938 with a very good memory. I remember being in my crib, being pushed in my baby carriage, so yes, I remember WW2. I had a sister born in 1936 who, as an adult, became what I would call an antisemite. My sister, born in 1943 with no memory of the war, dismisses antisemitism, felt it was okay to be "objective" about the Muslim ideology. My sisters and I did grow up in NYC. It's possible that if a person hasn't lived through it, hasn't experienced it, that it becomes ancient history and therefore isn't real. When I was young, before we became "white", the help wanted ads in the NY Times commonly had the proviso "Blacks and Jews need not apply". How many people are aware that there was actually one Jew who was protected by Hitler and remained living in nazi Germany. That was Otto Warburg, the brilliant (and gay) chemist who Hitler thought could figure out how to cure cancer. Hitler was terrified of cancer and Warburg actually did come up with a cause and potential solution. Now, after 75 years his findings are being taken seriously. But why did he stay? Why would he want to help Hitler? Perhaps it was the same psychology that afflicts those Jews who support Mamdani.
The most dangerous lie New York Jews tell themselves is that New York cannot turn because Jews helped build it. History laughs at that fantasy. The mob does not care about Jewish comedians, hospitals, universities, publishers, or bagels. The Islamist does not pause because Brooklyn once had Jewish neighborhoods. The revolutionary Left does not spare Jews because Jews marched in old coalitions. Today’s antisemitism calls Jews oppressors, colonizers, capitalists, globalists, whites, not-whites, Zionists, and enemies—whatever label fits the day’s rage. Mamdani’s New York will not be a Jewish city. It will be a warning siren. Wake up before Election Night and elect Bruce Blakeman.
A note to say that extremist Ideologies are only a front or a cloak or cover for the basest and nastiest aspects of Human nature, which I add we all share in our darkest moments. Society breaks down when this Darkside is used by powerful malicious elements in society, and the Darkside becomes organised. This is where we are heading now. What is interesting here is how the educated middle class in America have adopted Hate on the campuses. Note well how this is being organised. This is Stage Two of a Four-stage Process, as Hatred and Exclusion become a Political program which ends as either Expulsion and/or Genocide. I have said before that Islam, when Islamic Demographics are not addressed, becomes a threat to the Host Community. This is where we are now too. Jewish Demographics are stable in the West. Islam is not. It is these concerns, and The Far Left’s response to this, which are driving Hate in the community today. The Jewish People in America have become a Projected Cypher for this. As always, the scapegoats.
I'm trying to find an audience and I was hoping that I could work with you somehow because this is the biggest moment in civilization's history when we finally get scientific evidence of God. Try reading my article titled: have the monks given us scientific proof of God.
I'm trying to save Civilization by drawing attention to an extraordinary moment that's trying to happen. The monks Theory of Everything is explaining mystery after mystery after mystery while our scientists are saying crazy things and admitting that they can't make sense of any of the crazy things they are saying and now cannot understand 95% of the universe.
We need to quickly start solving our problems which this allows us to do otherwise we will resort to violence to solve our problems. I was hoping that you would help me avoid that by letting me somehow talk to your audience or maybe write an article with you to your audience about this exciting moment and get some attention that it deserves?
When they tell you what they will do, believe them. When my wife’s mother read Mein Kampf and Hitler attacked Warsaw, she escaped east towards Russia. She pleaded with most of her family to do the same. She survived hardships and survived - they stayed and perished. When current NYC mayor openly ignores Jewish community safety, he tells you that you shouldn’t ignore his stand.
So is NY still a Jewish city as often referred to not too long ago. The phrase NY JEW was used by many. You don't hear thst much anymore. But we do have many self hating ny jews these days ( IMO).
The problem in New York is the same as in London, Paris, Toronto and Melbourne - Muslims came in greater numbers and took over. Eventually they will take away all our safe areas (even Israel is under constant threat of annihilation). Sooner rather than later, Israel will be forced to launch hundreds of nuclear weapons and end civilization.
You may be going too far their Eric! Doomsday has been predicted many times since WW2 and for thousands of years before that .... humans are terrible but they are wonderful too when their back is against the wall.
Two billion Muzzles and two billion Commies are arrayed against 16 million Jews. We are outnumbered 250:1 and our enemies control the media and most governments. 10/7 was the start of a second Holocaust that Iran has planned for decades. We won’t survive this. All we can do is take the world down with us when we are destroyed. In fact it would be Israel’s obligation to do so should it come to that.
Nachum, this is an excellent article, but in my opinion you omitted our number one vulnerability: the massive, bloated Jewish organizations that dominate diaspora Jewish life.
They take in enormous amounts of money, yet there is almost no accessibility, almost no accountability, no unified strategy, no coordinated messaging, and very little real leadership that reaches ordinary Jews on the street. Everything is reactive instead of proactive. We respond after the damage is already done instead of building long-term communal strength beforehand.
The other side understands slogans, propaganda, activism, emotional narratives, and strategic coordination. Meanwhile, our organizations often seem trapped inside endless bureaucracy, fundraising, conferences, statements, and institutional caution.
That, to me, is the true Jewish swamp.
And until that swamp is torn down and rebuilt from the ground up with real accountability, accessibility, clarity, and strategic seriousness, diaspora Jews will continue drifting without unified direction while the threats around them grow more organized and more confident.
100% correct Nachum. Thank you. ⭐🙏
Unfortunately, progressive Jews never learned the harsh lesson of pre WW2 German Jews.
Where did you get the 2 million figure? It's less than 1 million now. Not to worry, in 2027 NYC Jews will have strong representation in Congress. Their only Jewish congressman will be brad Landers, Mandami dhimmi and anti " Zionist " and all around kapo. Vibes of 1933 berlin.
We need to remember that American "elites" were very instrumental in the creation of nazi Germany through their efforts at making the delusion of eugenics into "science fact". Hitler even wrote to the American Augenics Society to thank them for the ideas with which to rid the world of "unwanted populations". It was only changed from eugenics to "population control" following WW(eleven). Many American soldiers in that war no doubt were killed by weapons manufactured by American industrialists. Those of us who are still living who have memories of the war were seriously impacted by it, probably especially if we were Jewish. It's haunted me my whole life and yet somehow we never discussed it or how it affected us. I was born in 1938 with a very good memory. I remember being in my crib, being pushed in my baby carriage, so yes, I remember WW2. I had a sister born in 1936 who, as an adult, became what I would call an antisemite. My sister, born in 1943 with no memory of the war, dismisses antisemitism, felt it was okay to be "objective" about the Muslim ideology. My sisters and I did grow up in NYC. It's possible that if a person hasn't lived through it, hasn't experienced it, that it becomes ancient history and therefore isn't real. When I was young, before we became "white", the help wanted ads in the NY Times commonly had the proviso "Blacks and Jews need not apply". How many people are aware that there was actually one Jew who was protected by Hitler and remained living in nazi Germany. That was Otto Warburg, the brilliant (and gay) chemist who Hitler thought could figure out how to cure cancer. Hitler was terrified of cancer and Warburg actually did come up with a cause and potential solution. Now, after 75 years his findings are being taken seriously. But why did he stay? Why would he want to help Hitler? Perhaps it was the same psychology that afflicts those Jews who support Mamdani.
The most dangerous lie New York Jews tell themselves is that New York cannot turn because Jews helped build it. History laughs at that fantasy. The mob does not care about Jewish comedians, hospitals, universities, publishers, or bagels. The Islamist does not pause because Brooklyn once had Jewish neighborhoods. The revolutionary Left does not spare Jews because Jews marched in old coalitions. Today’s antisemitism calls Jews oppressors, colonizers, capitalists, globalists, whites, not-whites, Zionists, and enemies—whatever label fits the day’s rage. Mamdani’s New York will not be a Jewish city. It will be a warning siren. Wake up before Election Night and elect Bruce Blakeman.
A note to say that extremist Ideologies are only a front or a cloak or cover for the basest and nastiest aspects of Human nature, which I add we all share in our darkest moments. Society breaks down when this Darkside is used by powerful malicious elements in society, and the Darkside becomes organised. This is where we are heading now. What is interesting here is how the educated middle class in America have adopted Hate on the campuses. Note well how this is being organised. This is Stage Two of a Four-stage Process, as Hatred and Exclusion become a Political program which ends as either Expulsion and/or Genocide. I have said before that Islam, when Islamic Demographics are not addressed, becomes a threat to the Host Community. This is where we are now too. Jewish Demographics are stable in the West. Islam is not. It is these concerns, and The Far Left’s response to this, which are driving Hate in the community today. The Jewish People in America have become a Projected Cypher for this. As always, the scapegoats.
Excellent column
I'm trying to find an audience and I was hoping that I could work with you somehow because this is the biggest moment in civilization's history when we finally get scientific evidence of God. Try reading my article titled: have the monks given us scientific proof of God.
I'm trying to save Civilization by drawing attention to an extraordinary moment that's trying to happen. The monks Theory of Everything is explaining mystery after mystery after mystery while our scientists are saying crazy things and admitting that they can't make sense of any of the crazy things they are saying and now cannot understand 95% of the universe.
We need to quickly start solving our problems which this allows us to do otherwise we will resort to violence to solve our problems. I was hoping that you would help me avoid that by letting me somehow talk to your audience or maybe write an article with you to your audience about this exciting moment and get some attention that it deserves?
When they tell you what they will do, believe them. When my wife’s mother read Mein Kampf and Hitler attacked Warsaw, she escaped east towards Russia. She pleaded with most of her family to do the same. She survived hardships and survived - they stayed and perished. When current NYC mayor openly ignores Jewish community safety, he tells you that you shouldn’t ignore his stand.
See
https://cup.columbia.edu/book/memory-is-our-home/9783838214825/
So is NY still a Jewish city as often referred to not too long ago. The phrase NY JEW was used by many. You don't hear thst much anymore. But we do have many self hating ny jews these days ( IMO).
The problem in New York is the same as in London, Paris, Toronto and Melbourne - Muslims came in greater numbers and took over. Eventually they will take away all our safe areas (even Israel is under constant threat of annihilation). Sooner rather than later, Israel will be forced to launch hundreds of nuclear weapons and end civilization.
You may be going too far their Eric! Doomsday has been predicted many times since WW2 and for thousands of years before that .... humans are terrible but they are wonderful too when their back is against the wall.
Two billion Muzzles and two billion Commies are arrayed against 16 million Jews. We are outnumbered 250:1 and our enemies control the media and most governments. 10/7 was the start of a second Holocaust that Iran has planned for decades. We won’t survive this. All we can do is take the world down with us when we are destroyed. In fact it would be Israel’s obligation to do so should it come to that.