Discussion about this post

User's avatar
EKB's avatar

Very well done genetic understanding of Ashkenazi jews. We had our genetics done by 23 and me, which came out 98% ashkenazi Jew with the rest either north african or italian/southern europe so we fit!

But I have another question- how long does indigeneity last? you see if the palestinian claim to indigeneity is never ending say 2000 years from now they can claim indigenous status and create a state of Palestine, why is it that Jews cannot do the same thing especially since archaeological evidence shows there were past jewish nations in that area? The reality is, that the antiisrael, Judenhass, Palestine cult, needs to try to eradicate the connection of the ashkenazi Jew or all Jews to the Land of Israel in any way they can. Or to try to subsume the history of the jews for the palestinian arabs, its why UNRWA schools even teach that there was never nations of israel, Judea or the holy temples. it's the only way they can keep their narrative about the palestinian arabs alive. Otherwise they are seen as the true hypocrites that they are

Expand full comment
Martin  H's avatar

This is a brilliant essay, a mine of information and just what I needed so thank you🙏🏻.. I am not religious in the slightest but since Oct 7 have become pretty obsessed with Jews, judaism and Israel on the whole and I find it fascinating. I am learning a lot from various authors on this platform and I can’t thank you all enough. Happy new year to you all 🎉😊🇮🇱🇮🇱🎗️

Expand full comment
44 more comments...

No posts