What Parents Lose When They Don’t Raise Their Kids Jewish
When parents withhold Judaism, they deprive their children of history’s greatest inheritance: resilience, purpose, and pride.
Please consider supporting our mission to help everyone better understand and become smarter about the Jewish world. A gift of any amount helps keep our platform free of advertising and accessible to all.
Parenting is always an act of transmission.
Whether consciously or unconsciously, every parent passes on language, values, rituals, and memory. To raise a child is to shape a link in a chain. But when Jewish parents choose not to raise their children Jewish, they do not merely opt out of synagogue attendance or holiday traditions; they risk breaking a chain thousands of years old.
The loss is not only religious; it is cultural, historical, emotional, and even existential.
The Jewish People are unique in history for the way they have carried memory. Empires rose and fell, leaving behind ruins. Jews, scattered across continents, carried stories, prayers, and customs. To be Jewish is to be a custodian of a shared narrative that stretches back to Abraham, Sinai, exile, persecution, renewal, and statehood.
Parents who do not raise their children Jewish deprive them of this inheritance: the ability to stand inside history and say, “This story is also mine.” Without it, children inherit only fragments, often absorbed through stereotypes, textbooks, or the occasional news headline, never the living heartbeat of a people.
In a fragmented modern world, community is increasingly rare. Jewish life, at its best, provides a built-in framework of belonging: Shabbat tables, synagogue services, summer camps, trips to Israel, holiday gatherings, and lifecycle events. These create networks of support that extend across geography and generations.
A child raised without Judaism may grow up to admire community from afar, but they will not know the particular warmth of walking into a Shabbat dinner and being embraced as family, whether in Los Angeles, Warsaw, or Tel Aviv. Parents who set aside Jewish identity leave their children to find belonging elsewhere, often in places far more fleeting and fragile.
In modern life, every day can feel the same. Technology collapses distinctions between workday and weekend, morning and evening. Judaism insists otherwise. Shabbat sanctifies time, marking rest as holy. Holidays punctuate the year with rhythms of joy, reflection, and renewal.
Without these, children lose not only a spiritual practice but a way of resisting the relentless march of secular time. They miss out on the feeling of a world paused, candles flickering, blessings spoken, bread broken. Parents who do not transmit Judaism allow their children to live in the modern world’s flat calendar, never experiencing sacred time that teaches them to step back, breathe, and live differently.
We live in an era of constant reinvention. Social media encourages young people to construct identities from curated fragments: clothing styles, political slogans, entertainment tastes. Yet these identities often lack depth.
Jewishness, by contrast, is an identity anchored in history and purpose. It says to a young person: You are part of a people older than Rome, stronger than the Crusades, more enduring than the Enlightenment. When parents neglect to raise children Jewish, they strip them of a rooted identity, leaving them more vulnerable to ideologies that promise belonging but lack the grounding of heritage.
Judaism also trains the mind. For centuries, Jews have been known not only as a people of memory but as a people of questioning. The Talmud is not a book of uniform conclusions; it is a record of disagreement and argument, of rabbis challenging one another across generations.
Children raised Jewish inherit the idea that questions are sacred, that curiosity is a religious act. This intellectual tradition teaches them how to wrestle with complexity, how to balance opposing views, and how to sharpen their thinking without fear of contradiction. Without it, children lose not only connection to their heritage but one of the most powerful life skills Judaism has given the world: the courage to ask “why.”
Hebrew, too, is an inheritance that cannot be overlooked. More than a language, it is the thread that ties modern Jews to their ancestors in ancient Israel. To pray in Hebrew, to read the Torah in its original words, to sing Hatikvah and know that it echoes voices from thousands of years ago — this is to live inside continuity.
Children raised without Hebrew lose access to this dimension of identity. They may hear translations, but translation flattens; the depth, the poetry, the rhythm, the intimacy of Hebrew are lost.
When Jewish parents teach their children Hebrew, even at a basic level, they give them the keys to unlock a shared global identity. A Jewish child who walks into a synagogue in Buenos Aires, Paris, or Jerusalem can understand the same prayers and blessings. That common tongue is a bridge across borders and generations. Without it, Jewish children become tourists in their own tradition, able to watch but not truly to enter. Parents who neglect Hebrew do not just forfeit a language lesson; they risk severing their children from the unifying heartbeat of the Jewish People.
Yet Jewish life is not only about resilience and duty; it is also about joy. Jewish humor, music, storytelling, and celebration carry an irreverent defiance that has helped the Jewish People outlast tragedy. A Shabbat table alive with laughter, a Simchat Torah filled with dancing, a Purim full of costumes and satire — these are not luxuries but lifelines. They teach children how to balance seriousness with joy, suffering with hope, responsibility with play.
Parents who neglect to raise their children Jewish deprive them of that joy-filled resilience, leaving them without access to one of the most life-affirming aspects of Jewish identity.
There is a sobering historical truth: Jews exist today because their ancestors stubbornly chose to remain Jewish despite immense pressure to abandon it. From the Spanish Inquisition to Soviet repression, Jewish parents risked their lives to pass down identity. To willingly let go now, in freedom and safety, is to break that chain voluntarily. Parents may not intend to make such a choice, but in raising children without Judaism, they declare, in effect, that millennia of sacrifice were for nothing. The loss is not only personal but collective. A diminished Jewish future is the cumulative result of individual parental decisions.
There is another danger, perhaps the most urgent in our time: children who are not raised with a strong Jewish identity are often unprepared to face antisemitism. Hatred of Jews has never disappeared; it has only changed forms.
In today’s world, antisemitism comes through social media, classrooms, protests, and even professional spaces. A child without grounding in Jewish pride, history, and resilience may not know how to respond. They may internalize shame, withdraw in silence, or even deny their heritage to avoid conflict. Raising children Jewish gives them both the knowledge and the courage to face hostility. They have the ability to confidently say, “Yes, I am Jewish. And here is what that means.” They can recognize slurs, conspiracy theories, and double standards for what they are: part of an ancient prejudice, not a reflection of their worth.
Without that training, they are more vulnerable to confusion and self-doubt. Worse, they may accept the oppressor’s narrative, believing that to be Jewish is something to hide or apologize for. Parents who do not instill Jewish pride may think they are sparing their children discomfort, but in truth, they are leaving them defenseless against one of the oldest hatreds in human history.
For much of history, Jews have lived as the underdog: outnumbered, exiled, oppressed, and underestimated. Yet rather than breaking them, this status forged resilience, adaptability, and creativity. To be Jewish was to learn how to survive in hostile environments, to rebuild after destruction, to carry identity even when forbidden. This underdog experience is not just history; it is a curriculum of life skills.
Children raised with a strong Jewish identity inherit lessons in courage and perseverance that few cultures transmit as deeply. They learn that strength is not measured only in armies or numbers, but in persistence and ingenuity. They see that Jewish communities rebuilt after the Temple’s destruction, after expulsions from Spain, after pogroms in Eastern Europe, after the Holocaust, after genocidal wars launched against Israel. This teaches them that setbacks, no matter how severe, are not the end.
The underdog experience also cultivates empathy. Jews who know their story understand what it means to be vulnerable, to be treated unfairly, to have to defend one’s dignity.
A child raised Jewish can take that empathy into the wider world, recognizing injustice wherever it arises. This does not mean victimhood; it means strength born of struggle. Being part of a people that has so often been underestimated gives Jewish children confidence in their own capacity to overcome odds. It tells them: You come from survivors, you are part of a people that never gave up. That identity becomes armor in the face of life’s challenges — whether confronting antisemitism, navigating career setbacks, or simply finding the inner strength to persevere.
Parents who fail to raise their kids Jewish deny them this inheritance of resilience. Without it, children may still learn perseverance in other ways, but they will not carry the profound example of a people who turned marginalization into ingenuity, exile into culture, and survival into flourishing.
At the same time, raising Jewish children connects them to a people and a place. Judaism is not only a faith or a culture; it is a peoplehood with a homeland. To be Jewish is to know that wherever you go in the world, there is a table set for you, a family waiting for you, and a land whose story is bound with your own. Parents who do not raise their kids Jewish sever this connection to Israel and to the global Jewish family, leaving their children without one of the most powerful sources of belonging and identity in the modern world.
In an age where consumerism and distraction often crowd out meaning, Judaism also offers transcendence. Shabbat rest, the awe of prayer, the rhythm of the festivals, the sense of standing before something larger than oneself — all of this grounds children in a spiritual framework that teaches them life is not only about acquisition and ambition, but about gratitude, wonder, and sacred purpose. Without it, children risk being spiritually rootless, seeking fulfillment in places that cannot sustain them.
And perhaps most profoundly, raising children Jewish is itself an act of defiance. Across history, countless enemies sought to erase the Jewish people. Pharaoh, Haman, Rome, the Inquisition, the Nazis — all tried to make Jewish continuity impossible. To teach a child Hebrew, to light Shabbat candles, to celebrate a bar or bat mitzvah, is to declare that they failed.
Parents who choose to pass down Jewish identity are not only nurturing their own children; they are delivering a victory across the centuries. Parents who fail to do so may think they are being neutral, but in the sweep of history, neutrality is indistinguishable from surrender.
In today’s world, Jewish continuity matters not only to Jews, but to the broader human story. Jewish contributions in science, art, politics, and philosophy have been wildly disproportionate to their numbers. Children who are not raised Jewish may still achieve greatness, but they will not carry forward the distinctly Jewish lens through which so many have enriched humanity: the restless questioning, the tension between tradition and innovation, the insistence on justice. Parents who withhold Jewish identity deprive the world of future Jewish voices in the ongoing conversation of civilization.
When parents do not raise their kids Jewish, they lose the possibility of their children finding deep belonging in a timeless story. They lose the rituals that make family life more meaningful. They lose the opportunity to hand down a tested ethical framework, a spiritual practice of resilience, an intellectual tradition of questioning, and a sacred rhythm of life. They lose continuity with their ancestors and the ability to see their children as links in a chain that stretches into the future. They risk leaving their children defenseless against antisemitism, deprived of the empathy and resilience of the Jewish underdog experience, and disconnected from the joy, transcendence, and moral responsibility that define Jewish life.
In a world where so much is fleeting, to deny children their Jewish identity is to deprive them of one of the most enduring inheritances imaginable. Parents may not see the loss immediately.
But generations later, when the chain is broken and the memory gone, the absence is profound. Raising children Jewish is not just about religion; it is about giving them the gift of rootedness, purpose, resilience, and belonging in an unsteady world.
As usual good writing and an important message. I hope that some of the Jewish billionaires will put the money that they put into alma maters into Jewish schools.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐💕💕💕💕💕 Josh Hoffman, you never stop surprising and amazing me! Thank you!