31 Comments
User's avatar
Helen Rauch-Elnekave's avatar

Brilliant. But I'm afraid that our younger, less educated generations, would not understand this insightful, all-encompassing essay. And I'm not sure exactly what it will take to awaken them to our current horrifying reality.

Jack Elder's avatar

Brilliant analysis of 2 parallel societies. Thank G-d for Israel.

Cassandra anonymous's avatar

Thank you for this key, a Rosetta Stone for understanding what is happening in New York today.

Tina Aviles's avatar

An excellent article, and quite depressing to see the continuity of blaming the Jews throughout the centuries. I'm happy to call Israel my home.

John Galt III's avatar

Vienna once mattered - it doesn't now.

New York City once mattered - it is fading into the past.

It is decrepit, corrupt and full of Muslims and Communists. The Democrats believe that is the future. It is not. Each year at the margin productive people there will leave, one by one. NYC is destroying itself but it takes time. We have plenty of time.

When I was born in NYC in 1947 there were 2,000,000 Jews in the City. As the author says above there are 1,000,000 today. That number will do nothing but shrink and so will NYC in importance.

Ken Griffin just pledged $2 billion to Carnegie-Mellon University to open up a vibarnt 35 acre tech campus in downtown Miami - that is the future without any doubt.

Chicago and NYC drove Ken Griffin out of their cities. 1st Chicago drove Citadel, his company out, and then NYC Mamdani singled out Griffin to be exterminated in his pied a terre tax ad. Griffin listened and NYC loses. That is the pattern that will repeat.

ECB's avatar

This is really well done. Frightening and yet not unexpected.

Tzippi's avatar

Wonderful piece but I couldn’t help but notice that while Luger was called out for his “Christian values”, there was no mention of Mamdani being Muslim and his strong adherence to Islamic ideology and support of Islamic extremism against Israel and Jews. Was it an accidental or intentional omission?

Yonatan Daon-Stern's avatar

Accidental. It was mentioned in Lueger’s case because his religion was part of the political campaign, whereas Mamdani masks his Islamism under communism (as if that’s more legitimate).

Tzippi's avatar

Appreciate the clarification!

Barry Lederman, “normie”'s avatar

Yonatan, your post reads beautifully while connecting the dots of being a Jew.

H. C. Helfand's avatar

Insightful, brilliant, and disturbing. Let us hope that we have learned from the past even if others haven't. And that we are strong and resolute enough to do something about it.

Aku's avatar

Superb synopsis of modern Jewish history with clever parallels between Old and New World When It comes to antisemitism it proves veracity of the "plus ça change..." saying: "the more things change, the more they stay the same" .

פופו's avatar

“ Lueger showed a young Hitler the road to power. What is Mamdani’s New York teaching the person watching now?” 😳😨 scary, thank God that Israel is independent militarly and will always protect the jews, No trust to any other country unfortunately.

Barbara Panken's avatar

Brilliant!!! Will the under 40 voters care???? I’m not hopeful.

Sir Frederic's avatar

Beautifully written, thank you. The parallels to Mamdani are spot on, an Islamist in Marxist clothing.

Robin Alexander's avatar

There is so much here that is brilliant, and poetic. It is the basis of a semester-long course. Wonderful!!!

P.S.: so glad I got out of university before the craziness began - at least I didn’t notice it; graduated 1977.

j p m's avatar

70% of Jews still voting for the dem party like indoctrinated sheeple. 25-33% of NYC Jews voted for Mandami when there was no "evil republican" excuse because they had a liberal Dem choice, Cuomo.The "As a Jews" in in entertainment, media and the universities are growing in number. I guess we don't have a problem yet.

Cassandra anonymous's avatar

I think we do. Add in the influence of the Nation of Islam, itself an outgrowth of the anticolonial movement, and you see the pincers closing.

CES.'s avatar

this is the clarion call we have seen before . Listen carefully. Do not be fooled . Stand tall and be the resistance to hatred without bounds .