Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bryce Walat's avatar

I remember attending a lecture during my college days given by a priest who was also an attorney. The priest talked about the trials of Jesus before the Sanhedrin and Pontius Pilate. He pointed out that “If it was true that Jesus was killed by the Jewish leaders, he would have died by stoning. Crucifixion was not a Jewish punishment—it was a Roman punishment—for the very worst criminals and the very worst offenses against the Roman Empire.”

Sam Hilt's avatar

Dear Rabbi Boteach,

Thank you for such a clear and eloquent exposition of an all-too-obvious truth. It's quite remarkable how rarely one comes across such expositions of Jesus' Judaism. I would suggest that it's Christian guilt for centuries of Jewish persecution that makes the obvious invisible to them. The failure to come to terms with the guilt leads to moral blindness and the inability to recognize who is the persecutor and who is the victim.

I first experienced the truth of your insight some years ago while looking at a Renaissance painting of a beleaguered Christ carrying the Cross on his way to Golgotha. While the crowd jeers and spits at him, in his agony he turns toward us. He looks out of the painting, right at us, seeking justice in a cruel, insane world. It brought to mind a photo I had seen at Yad Vashem of Nazi thugs having fun tormenting hapless Jews. And I made the same connection that you did, that depictions of Christ's suffering should be understood as images of Jewish victimization rather than of Jewish villainy.

Only a handful of Jewish artists, such as Maurycy Gottlieb and Mark Chagall, have dared to present Christ as a Jew. Meanwhile many Jewish artists have carefully avoid presenting themselves as Jews. As R.B. Kitaj showed in his "Second Diasporist Manifesto," most modern and contemporary Jewish artists have done their utmost to "transcend" or ignore the irrelevant fact of their birth. It's hardly unlikely that the centuries of Christian hatred and persecution played an important part in this failure of Jews to present themselves as Jews.

I hope I live long enough to see some of the ongoing efforts at reconciliation bear fruit. The essential first step must be to see the facts for what they were, and to accept the guilt where it is warranted. It's only after that painful experience that atonement and reconciliation can begin.

37 more comments...

Ready for more?