Please consider supporting our mission to help everyone better understand and become smarter about the Jewish world. A gift of any amount helps keep our platform free of advertising and accessible to all.
This is a guest essay by Thane Rosenbaum, an essayist and author of the book, “Beyond Proportionality: Israel’s Just War in Gaza.”
You can also listen to the podcast version of this essay on Apple Podcasts, YouTube Music, YouTube, and Spotify.
There was a time, long ago — back in the drug-addled days of Woodstock.
Tie-dyed shirts were formal wear. Hair was both a Broadway musical and a countercultural trademark.
During those days, the progressive Left — known colloquially at the time as Hippies — knew their proper place, rarely overstepping.
Sure, they made their politics known. And, yes, many wished to change the world by urging to “give peace a chance.” But their groove remained mainly local and cultural. International affairs were largely left to the squares in suits.
The Vietnam War was important only because American teenagers were being drafted to fight a war on a far-flung continent, all for the purpose of keeping the Cold War on ice. Most people couldn’t find Vietnam on a map (and still can’t).
They also kept their allies to a minimum, and didn’t mistake enemies for friends. An Islamist partnership would have been a major stretch. Hippies would no sooner make common cause with the Ku Klux Klan, or start listening to Perry Como. The ticket to entry for the far left of those days demanded socialist leanings, radical bra-burning, maximal free speech, and Martin Luther King Jr.’s civil disobedience.
Of course, the house was always open for anyone on an acid trip.
Today’s Hippies are known as Progressives. They repurposed the psychedelic dye for their hair, ditched LSD for TDS (Trump Derangement Syndrome), and replaced all those peace medallions and love beads with keffiyeh scarves and face masks.
You can find such people on university campuses, of course, but also in the usual lefty haunts of major Western cities — especially in the Brooklyn neighborhood of Park Slope, where the mere word “co-op” can result in ecstasy (not the drug).
Recently, the members of the Park Slope Food Coop overwhelmingly voted to boycott Israeli products and to formally join the ranks of the BDS Movement, which is an acronym that most assuredly does not give peace a chance. It has but one goal: not coexistence in the Middle East, but the end of the Jewish state.
The Park Slope Food Coop, founded in 1973, has 17,000 members. Nearly 9,000 joined a Zoom meeting to vote on the measure, which passed by a wide margin — 67 percent voted to approve the boycott; 31 percent opposed; and 2 percent abstained. Those passionate about granola and mashed yeast, apparently, have been zealously trying to ban Israeli products since 2009.
To achieve this electoral outcome, the Coop’s leadership changed the bylaws and lowered the threshold for passage from a supermajority of 75 percent to a simple majority of 51 percent. After more than three hours of presenting the pro-boycott case (without allowing a rebuttal), the membership voted and Israeli oranges suddenly became unkosher in Brooklyn.
This roiling action jolted New York’s Jewish community. Many of the Coop’s members, including some of its top managers, are themselves Jews. This was yet another example of Reform Judaism’s social justice, misapplied tikkun olam obsession, and its steadfast Democratic Party allegiance, fracturing American Jewry over Israel and the war in Gaza that resulted from the October 7th massacre carried out by Hamas, Palestinian Islamic Jihad, and other Palestinians.
And now the Park Slope Food Coop has gone the way of Ben & Jerry’s. Several years ago, its corporate overseers forced the two former Brooklyn-born boys of Vermont to end their policy of refusing to sell their ice cream in the West Bank. Two Jews turning their back on Israel is no surprise.
Another former Brooklyn Jew living in Vermont, Senator Bernie Sanders, does it all the time. Ben & Jerry’s, after all, is a notoriously “woke” corporate entity. One of its popular flavors, Cherry Garcia, is loaded with butterfat and flower power nostalgia for the 1960s.
The recent actions by the Park Slope Food Coop, however, don’t quite offer the same cholesterol count or critical mass. For all the hippie hoopla, the Coop carries very few Israeli goods, just some tahini, snacks, produce, kosher matzah, hummus, and two hair products.
For that paltry selection of merchandise, you’d think the members came to blows over the fate of the entire produce aisle. Jewish members were literally afraid to attend meetings given how many “pro-Palestinian” activists were wearing keffiyehs and images of watermelon — Hamas’ latest mascot.
There were reported physical fights outside. “Pro-Palestinian” activists treated the entrance like a college campus encampment, chanting “genocide,” “apartheid.” and “Zionism” right in front of security guards.
A man posting an anti-boycott flyer on a lamppost was physically attacked by a ruffian hopped up on herbal stimulants. Community meetings devolved into conspiracy theories about Jews and their support for Israel. One member compared Jews to Nazis, declaring, “Jewish supremacism is a problem in this country.”
Never before has it been this volatile in the 53-year history of this Brooklyn landmark. A number of Jewish members, with no love lost for the Coop, cancelled their memberships. Others are contemplating legal options.
The National Jewish Advocacy Center filed a complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights. New York law prevents blacklisting products based on protected classes, such as national origin. Another action is planned pursuant to the New York law that governs corporations, of which co-ops are included. Intimidating and harassing your own members may violate the Business Judgment Rule, because the boycott is both grossly negligent and not in the best interests of the corporation.
In advance of the vote, the Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law sent a letter, to no avail, pressing the Coop to cancel the referendum — specifically, calling attention to security concerns. Brandeis Center’s executive director, Kenneth Marcus, reminded the Coop that BDS itself is inherently antisemitic, saying: “A grocery store should never become a springboard for extremist political campaigns.”
Quite right.
Imagine the astonishing amount of hubris it requires for a grocery store that sells only a few Israeli products to believe that the world values its opinion about a conflict it doesn’t really understand and smacks of both antisemitism and its own self-loathing. Today’s hippies sure have an inflated belief in their capacity to change world events by bullying its membership and lashing out for narcissistic attention.
The Park Slope Food Coop is now officially a cliché. It coexists within the overall pro-Hamas crowd in the bewildering confusion about grass roots politics. Screaming is not thoughtful, exclusion is not unifying, violence is not moral, intimidation is not neighborly, bullying is not consensus, and shouting down is not debate.
Ironically (tragically, even more so) but those who voted for the boycott are too antisemitic to realize that their real allies are not Hamas, who have no special affinity for progressives, but the Israelis who, on October 7, 2023, attended their own version of Woodstock at the Nova music festival. Many had tattoos and wore nose rings. They beheld the stars like time-travelers to the Age of Aquarius. All were feminists and many counted themselves among Israel’s vibrant LGBTQ community.
Queers for Palestine?
The October 7th victims awoke to a nightmare on the Jewish holiday of Simchat Torah — on Shabbat, no less. How more secular and progressive could they be? Southern Israel is teeming with kibbutzim that harvest the very fruits and vegetables which are the lifeblood and earthy sustenance of the Coop.
The one community that should have shown unwavering solidarity with Israel after October 7th was the Park Slope Food Coop. Unless they have been tripping out on antisemitism, what could possibly have drawn them to the side of carnivorous barbarians?
A version of this essay also appeared in the Jewish Journal.
Another irony (among the many): if I understand correctly, some of the Israeli products the Park Slope idiots have voted to boycott are made by companies owned or co-owned by Israeli Arabs, and which employ Muslim, Druze, Christian and Jewish workers. They should rename the Coop "The Gang Who Couldn't Boycott Straight."
The irony they still use Israeli technology. Selective stupidity.