Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sam's avatar

I’m furious at people who happened to be born to Jewish parents and think that alone gives them the right to speak for Jews who actually live Jewish lives.

Being born Jewish isn’t a free pass. Jewish identity isn’t just genetics—it’s responsibility, commitment, and connection. People who have deliberately opted out of Jewish life and distanced themselves from Israel have no business lecturing religious or committed Jews about values, morality, or what Judaism is supposed to stand for.

What’s especially enraging is watching people who have virtually no relationship with Judaism or Israel use the label “Jew” as a shield while actively undermining Jews who are devoted to both. If you’ve chosen to live outside Jewish life, own that choice—and stop hijacking the voices of those who actually live it every day.

Expand full comment
Suzanna Eibuszyc's avatar

As a 2G of Holocaust survivors I shared this widely. Absolutely disgusting, there are Holocaust survivors still among the living.

Expand full comment
58 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?